[South Africa] We are dying for food 22:31 Aug 06 1602 comments "En Haití está desarrollándose una rebelión de las masas en contra de un sistema neocolonial" 09:04 Mar 28 0 comments What Colour is Your Vest? The Gilets Jaunes Revolt Shaking France 20:53 Feb 14 5 comments Yellow Vests and I 19:55 Jan 12 0 comments Trespass 3 23:45 Jan 03 0 comments more >> |
Recent articles by Insane Dialectical Posse
This author has not submitted any other articles.
Recent Articles about North America / Mexico Community strugglesNo more Presidents Nov 03 20 Is President Donald Trump a threat and danger? Jul 02 20 Estados Unidos, tierra fértil para un nuevo municipalismo Aug 21 18 Announcing: FARE STRIKE! San Francisco 2005: First-Hand Accounts
north america / mexico |
community struggles |
other libertarian press
Monday April 16, 2007 14:25 by Insane Dialectical Posse - Insane Dialectical Editions
A collection of first-hand accounts of the Fare Strike, in which thousands of San Franciscans openly and spontaneously united along class lines and rode mass transit for free. Announcing: FARE STRIKE! San Francisco 2005: First-Hand Accounts |
Front pageSupport Sudanese anarchists in exile Joint Statement of European Anarchist Organizations International anarchist call for solidarity: Earthquake in Turkey, Syria and Kurdistan Elements of Anarchist Theory and Strategy 19 de Julio: Cuando el pueblo se levanta, escribe la historia International anarchist solidarity against Turkish state repression Declaración Anarquista Internacional por el Primero de Mayo, 2022 Le vieux monde opprime les femmes et les minorités de genre. Leur force le détruira ! Against Militarism and War: For self-organised struggle and social revolution Declaração anarquista internacional sobre a pandemia da Covid-19 Anarchist Theory and History in Global Perspective Capitalism, Anti-Capitalism and Popular Organisation [Booklet] Reflexiones sobre la situación de Afganistán South Africa: Historic rupture or warring brothers again? Death or Renewal: Is the Climate Crisis the Final Crisis? Gleichheit und Freiheit stehen nicht zur Debatte! Contre la guerre au Kurdistan irakien, contre la traîtrise du PDK Meurtre de Clément Méric : l’enjeu politique du procès en appel |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (2 of 2)
Jump To Comment: 1 2FARE STRIKE! San Francisco 2005: First-Hand Accounts...hmmmmm...an ideological truth-in-packaging law should apply here...
1. This prolix leftists' memoir of failure pamphlet is clearly intended for the consumption of people who were safely far away from San Francisco in the summer and fall of 2005, and who might be hoodwinked into believeing its wildly innacurate depiction of the fare strike fiasco; mass spontaneous resistance on a class basis, and other I-stiil-believe-in-the-Easter-Bunny versions of reality;
2. The people behind it, Gifford (GH), etc, intervened from the right against an already existing radical effort, and did all they could to turn it into a typical, Bay Area leftist single-issue complaint phenomenon,
3. They were successful in this. They were able to make the effort a product of their "vision," or more accurately lack of vision.
Subsequently the effort was a flop. All the Muni operators, bus drivers and streetcar operators, I spoke to afterward, several dozen of them, were unanimous in saying this, and they were in a better position to judge than anyone else.
4. Now GH, consistent with his Warner-Brothers-cartoon-character comical pattern of dishonesty in all things, tries to paper over the abject failure of his politics in action by claiming that this clear and obvious failure was somehow really a great-moment-in-proletarian-history,
5. And after doing all they could to turn a potential mass transit self-reduction effort on SF's Muni into a typical SF Bay Area, left-wing-of-capital load of crap, we get an airbrushed history book version -- garlanded with quotes from Guy Debord!
These guys did all they could to denude the effort of any actual anti-capitalist content. All the pro-Situ references afterward can't reverse that.
There is a big disconnect between the fact that the Potemkin-Village group "Insane Dialectical Posse," posting here, and his buddies, acted in every way like conventional leftists of the Trotskyist, social democratic or idealistic left-wing of the Democratic party stripe during the failed effort to foment a transit system fare strike in San Francisco in 2005. In the one mass action that most of them have engaged in they were the most rightward-pointing faction of the effort
Revolutionary consciousness is what it does; if what the person or people in question do in the larger world is the same old left-wing of capital crap, then that's what their politics are. All the references to Mattick, Pannekoek and the Situationists can't redeem that.
I suppose these leftists offer a good example of what results when a gaggle of nominally "Marxist" college town slackers in early middle age attempt, in the case of almost all of them, for the very first time in their lives, to engage in some kind of substantial radical collective action -- nothing happens. The haven't honed their communications skills enough to effectively communicate any message they might have to convey to contemporary working people.
"...in the performance their interests prove to be uninteresting and their potency impotence...the democrat comes out of the most disgraceful defeat just as innocent as he was when he went into it."
Karl Marx, in 'The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Napoleon,' quoted here from
'Muni Social Strikeout -- the Failed Transit System Fare Strike in San Francisco in 2005,' is available on the 'Love and Treason' web page at the Mid-Atlantic Anarchist Infoshop:
http://www.infoshop.org/myep/muni_social_strikeout.
'The Failed Transit System Fare Strike' article is also available on libcom.org, and in numerous other places on the internet.
Kevin Keating
proletaire2003@yahoo.com
Several thousand people did participate in the fare strike. The fare strike was a failure in that it did not gain enough support to force the Muni bureaucrats or city politicians to back off on the fare hike and service cuts. The people who put out "Fare Strike" were in the Muni Fare Strike group, which kevin criticizes as being to the right of the Muni Social Strike group, which he participated in. But the Muni Fare Strike group was more successful than Social Strike in its outreach efforts to other community groups, and this resulted in the one major extension of the strike, through the participation of the day laborers' organization in organizing among Spanish-speaking immigrants. Kevin's own interventions in Social Strike were a cause of that group's lack of outreach since Kevin denounced just about any other group due its not passing Kevin's ideological litmus test. I've also written a piece on the fare strike at:
http://libcom.org/library/post-mortem-on-the-san-francisco-fare-strike-2005-tom-wetzel