user preferences

A Talk on the Ukrainian-Russian War

category international | imperialism / war | opinion / analysis author Thursday August 31, 2023 03:36author by Wayne Priceauthor email drwdprice at aol dot com Report this post to the editors

Based on a talk I gave at the August 12, 2023 Los Angeles Anarchist Book Fair

A talk on the Ukrainian-Russian war, from an anarchist perspective. I reviewed my reasons for being in solidarity with the Ukrainian people. But revolutionary anarchists should give no political support to the Ukrainian government nor to the U.S. imperialists who help it.
images.jpg

When the Russian state invaded Ukraine, I was immediately on the side of the Ukrainian people. Mainly this was because, like most people, I hate oppression, exploitation, and bullying. I am on the side of the oppressed, the exploited, the beaten, the marginalized, and the dominated. Especially whenever they fight back. While my political opinions have evolved over the years, this attitude has continued to be at the heart of my worldview.

Also, I have long supported the freedom of an oppressed people to national self-determination. I learned this concept during the fight against the U.S.-Vietnamese war (dating myself). My comrades and I had no illusions in the North Vietnamese state nor the leaders of the south Vietnamese war (the “Viet Cong” or NLF). They were Stalinists and would establish a Communist-type state-capitalist dictatorship (as they did). They received military aid from the imperialist Soviet Union. But there was no question that the peasants and workers of Vietnam were supporting the war and its leadership. We gave no political support to the Stalinist leaders and rulers, we were their opponents. Yet we definitely were in solidarity with the Vietnamese people in their fight for independence and unity and whatever freedoms they might gain. We wanted the U.S. military forces to lose.

I thought these lessons of the Vietnamese-U.S. war applied to this war. They implied solidarity with the Ukrainian people (however much we opposed the Ukrainian state and its capitalist “oligarchs”) and full opposition to the Russian invaders. It implied that the oppressed people have the right to get arms from wherever they can, even from other imperialists who were competing with their immediate aggressor (then the Soviet Union, now the U.S. and NATO).

However, when I wrote this, I received much disagreement, often expressed with great personal hostility, expressed in name-calling, childish insults, and red-baiting. I was betraying anarchism! Some of my critics could not separate political disagreement from personal conflicts.

The first wave of arguments I faced held that “no anarchist” would support the war. This was because anarchists did not support wars, or anarchists did not support wars between capitalist states. This is to say that my critics rejected (or ignored) the importance of imperialism. They did not distinguish between wars between imperialist states and wars between an oppressed, colonized, nation and an imperialist state.

It was repeatedly pointed out to me that Peter Kropotkin had supported France and the Allies in World War I but that almost all anarchists at the time and later felt that he was badly mistaken. His comrade Errico Malatesta had written to condemn Kropotkin for taking sides in the Great War. But my critics did not know that Malatesta had also supported wars of national liberation by oppressed peoples (for example, in Libya against the Italian army, or in Cuba against the Spanish empire). (Price Nov. 2022)

I demonstrated that “classical anarchists” had supported popular struggles for national self-determination: including, but not limited to, Bakunin, Kropotkin, Malatesta, Makhno, and others. All (with the exception of Kropotkin) distinguished between wars among imperialists (of which they opposed all sides) and wars between imperialists and oppressed, non-imperialist, countries (of which they supported the oppressed peoples). (Price July 2022; 2023)

I also pointed out that many—perhaps most—of the Ukrainian anarchists supported—and participated in—the Ukrainian side of the war. Similarly, Russian and Belarusian anarchists were on the side of the Ukrainian people, and so were many other anarchists.
In a report on the 2023 International Anarchist Conference at St. Imier, Switzerland, a commentator wrote,

“Most events held on the war accepted the right of self-defence for Ukrainians as the minimum anarchist political basis….The event by anarchists from Russia, Ukraine and Belarus, who are actively resisting the invasion, was one of the most interesting of the meeting.” (Transnational Institute 2023)

All this does not prove that it is right to support the Ukrainian people, but it does disprove the claim that no anarchist would take such a stand.

In general, my opponents could not distinguish between “nationalism” and “national self-determination” or “liberation.” “National liberation” meant the freeing of a people from the oppression of the state of another nation. “National self-determination” meant that a people were able to decide for itself whether to be independent and what kind of political and economic system to have (which could be a capitalist state or libertarian socialism). But “nationalism” is one possible program meant to supposedly solve national oppression—by creating a new state and national capitalist economy (perhaps state capitalist). Anarchists should be for “national self-determination” and “national liberation” but are thoroughly opposed to “nationalism.” Instead we advocate international anarchist socialism to achieve freedom for all peoples everywhere.

Others argued that Ukraine did not deserve national defense because it was not really a nation! They claimed that Ukraine was a recent invention, that its people were indistinguishable from Russians, and so on. (While not supporting the Russian invasion, many anarchists repeat Putin’s propaganda and lies.) In my opinion, all these claims were irrelevant. Historically there had been a Ukraine for centuries, oppressed by the Czars and then by the Stalinists. During the 70 years of the Soviet Union, there had been a recognized Ukrainian Republic in the USSR. But this too was not really relevant.

What was important was that the Ukrainians regarded themselves as a nation. In 1991 the Ukrainian people voted overwhelming for national independence from Russia—by more than 92 per cent. This included about 80 per cent in the eastern, mainly Russian-speaking, Donbas and about 54 per cent in Crimea. (Mirra 2023; p. 126) It was their opinion which counts, not that of foreign anarchists nor of Putin and his army.

To which some replied, that therefore the people of the eastern Ukraine, the Donbas, were a nation or nations because they had voted for their own republics merged into Russia. I would agree, except that the drive for their “national separation” was so clearly a Russian put-up job (with Russian soldiers everywhere). Indeed the whole movement for Donbas secession was organized since 2014 by Russian and pro-Russian agents.

Another argument was that anarchists must not support a capitalist state. In fact, no Ukrainian anarchists gave any political support to the Zelensky government. They did not vote for it nor urge others to vote for it. They did not join the ruling party nor any other. They did not participate in the government in any way. They have opposed the neoliberal austerity and anti-union policies of the Zelensky government. There is no “Popular Front.”

Suppose there was a strike in the U.S. Anarchists would be on the side of the workers. Outside anarchists would do labor-support activities to help the strike. Anarchist workers at the workplace would join the strike and be active in its organizing. Yet the union would undoubtedly be run by a bureaucratic and possibly corrupt leadership. Should anarchists still participate? Or should they stand aside or perhaps cross the picket lines, because the union was undemocratic and centralized? Obviously, revolutionary anarchists would join the strike and be the most militant strikers, while fighting for a more democratic, federalist, and militant union. The same is true of anarchists in a just national war of self-determination, being part of the war while working for an eventual anarchist-socialist revolution.

Anarchists are participating in the war. Some distribute food and medicines. Others help refugees. But some formed Territorial Defense groups affiliated with the army. And some joined the army, fighting at the front.

It would have been optimal if Ukrainian anarchists had been able to organize militias or guerrilla groups independently of the state. Unfortunately they are far too weak to do that. They must either support the existing army in one way or another, or be passive. After all, while Ukrainian anarchists have much to criticize the army for, anarchists are not opposed to its fighting the Russian invaders!

Suppose anarchists were to say to the Ukrainian people, “We are against the Russian invasion, but we are also against the national army—we are even for sabotaging it—because it is the army of a state and capitalism.” Most workers would (correctly) regard this as treasonous de facto support of the invaders. On the other hand, anarchist participation in the war, in whatever capacity, can only increase positive views of anarchists among the population.

Much of the opposition to supporting Ukraine is due to its getting arms and aid from the U.S. and the rest of NATO. It is often called a “proxy war.” There is an assumption by many that only U.S. imperialism is evil. But while U.S. imperialism is terrible, it is not the only imperialism. There is Russian imperialism, as the Ukrainians know.

It is not unusual for one imperialist power to intervene when a colony rebels against its imperialist master. During the Cold War, the Soviet Union often aided, with guns or money, national struggles against Western imperialists—in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Meanwhile the U.S. was “on the side” of eastern European states against the Soviet Union. Even during World War II, Nazi Germany gave “support” to Arab rebels in Britain and France’s colonies, and even to Ireland, while Imperial Japan claimed to be “freeing” Asian colonies from Britain, France, and Holland. So it was not surprising that Soviet Russia gave aid to Vietnam against the U.S.—or that the U.S. and allies should give aid to Ukraine. The U.S. state is acting for its reasons, its imperial interests in weakening its imperial competitor, not out of the “idealism” of its cynical politicians.

But make no mistake. For the Ukrainians, this is no “proxy war.” It is their villages, towns, and cities which are bombed and destroyed, not those of the U.S., Germany, or Britain. It is their population which is being massacred on the ground and from the air. It is their soldiers who are fighting and being killed in massive numbers. They are fighting and dying for their country, their people, and no one else.

I would not offer tactical advice to Ukrainian anarchists. But strategically I would say that their goals are two-fold: to defeat the Russian invasion and to spread anarchist ideas among the people, especially the workers. As revolutionary anarchists, we continue to be in solidarity with the oppressed, especially when they fight for their freedom.

References

Mirra, Carl (2023). “The War in Ukraine.” New Politics. Summer 2023. Pp. 125—137.

Price, Wayne (July 2022). “Malatesta on War and National Self-Determination” https://www.anarkismo.net/article/32666

Price, Wayne (Nov. 2022). “Kropotkin and War—Today.”
https://www.anarkismo.net/article/32683?search_text=Wayne+Price

Price, Wayne (2023). “Anarchists Support Self-Determination for Ukraine; What Did Bakunin Say About National Self-Determination?” https://www.anarkismo.net/article/32774?search_text=Wayne+Price

Transnational Institute of Social Ecology (2023). “Report From the International Anarchist Meeting in St. Imier, Switzerland”
https://anarchistnews.org/content/report-international-anarchist-meeting-st-imier-switzerland

* submitted to Workers Solidarity: A Green Syndicalist Webzine

author by Jimmy - Alpha Drywall Contractors of Wichita Fallspublication date Tue Sep 12, 2023 08:37author email author address author phone Report this post to the editors

The article emphasises the complexity of the issue and the necessity to recognise that the Ukrainian people are most immediately affected by the conflict, regardless of imperialist geopolitics.

author by fnaf - davidjohnspublication date Wed Sep 20, 2023 16:51author email johndavidd8888 at gmail dot comauthor address colombia, michiganauthor phone 02593647853Report this post to the editors

In the context of the Ukrainian-Russian war, showing support for the Ukrainian people who are affected by the conflict, including civilians caught in the crossfire, is a central concern. Indeed, the popularity of Five Nights at Freddy's https://fnafgo.com/ extends well beyond the gaming community.

author by Ainz - Cleveland Drywall Prospublication date Thu Oct 05, 2023 08:17author email ampva301 at gmail dot comauthor address author phone Report this post to the editors

Solidarity with those who resist oppression remains a core principle.

author by Amor Scott - fence rental company Tampapublication date Thu Oct 19, 2023 06:50author address author phone Report this post to the editors

In times of conflict, the lines between activism and the actions of states can become blurred, and different anarchists and anti-authoritarians may take various positions. Your stance on supporting the Ukrainian people's resistance, spreading anarchist ideas, and being in solidarity with the oppressed reflects a principled and humanitarian approach to a situation with significant consequences for those directly affected by the conflict.

author by geometry dash - geometry dashpublication date Tue Nov 21, 2023 17:24author address author phone Report this post to the editors

This is a very helpful and practical article on how to improve your writing skills. You have shared some useful tips and techniques that can help anyone become a better writer. Your article is clear and easy to follow.

author by Shawnpublication date Thu Mar 28, 2024 07:28author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Thank you for sharing this great information on this site.

author by Kurt - microneedlingpublication date Thu Mar 28, 2024 07:31author address author phone Report this post to the editors

This is awesome! Glad to visit this site.

author by Kitty - https://www.delawaredrywallerspublication date Tue Apr 09, 2024 10:52author address author phone Report this post to the editors

After all, while Ukrainian anarchists have much to criticize the army for, anarchists are not opposed to its fighting the Russian invaders!

author by Kimpublication date Fri Apr 12, 2024 01:07author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Such an informative blog! thanks for sharing this with us.

Related Link: https://amicoglobal.com/stayform-concrete-forming/
author by callgirls inlahore - Call Girls in Lahorepublication date Wed Apr 24, 2024 14:39author email emaanali4513 at gmail dot comauthor address 03001616926author phone 23056896523Report this post to the editors

Our college girl escorts are girls who are young and very beautiful. These girls are sensual as well as full of sexual desires. Our VIP clients who want to have sex with a young, beautiful and energetic escort can book these lavish college girls. These girls are eager to give you memorable moments of happiness 24 hours a day and night. You will consider yourself lucky to meet one of our college girl escorts.

Related Link: https://celebritygirls.online/
author by Homer Miranda - geometry dash litepublication date Fri May 03, 2024 16:40author email sener65342 at rehezb dot comauthor address Anchorageauthor phone Report this post to the editors

Let's continue focusing on planning and devising workable solutions to create a healthcare system that is more just and equal.

author by stevejobb - capybara clickerpublication date Tue Jul 30, 2024 18:05author email stevejobb1102 at gmail dot comauthor address 155author phone 4325555566Report this post to the editors

I wonder when the war between the two countries will end?

author by macwillmspublication date Sun Aug 25, 2024 17:35author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Thank you for your enlightening discourse on the Ukrainian-Russian War. Your analysis and viewpoint on the dispute are both insightful and thought-provoking. Understanding these intricacies is critical for engaging in meaningful discourse and finding solutions. "Cheap tow truck companies in Queens" are the best for you in case of desires and discounted service.

Related Link: https://bestcitytowingnyc.com/best-way-to-hire-auto-repair-shop-online-in-queens/
author by Ethan Walker - West chester roofingpublication date Sat Nov 30, 2024 01:00author email walker.ethan1989 at gmail dot comauthor address East 15th street Brooklynauthor phone Report this post to the editors

Your analysis of the tension between anarchist principles and real-world conflicts is insightful and complex. The debate over whether anarchists should support Ukraine in its fight against Russian aggression touches on historical, theoretical, and ethical questions that have long divided anarchists and leftists more broadly.

author by Amber Brion - Paramount Asphalt Sealcoatingpublication date Thu Mar 20, 2025 23:32author email amberbrion31 at gmail dot comauthor address East 15th street Brooklynauthor phone 9185001264Report this post to the editors

It sounds like you’re sharing a transcript or summary of your talk from the Los Angeles Anarchist Book Fair.

author by smm servicespublication date Tue Apr 01, 2025 16:05author email officialsmmpanel12 at gmail dot comauthor address author phone Report this post to the editors

You’ve made some excellent points here! It’s always good to be reminded of the bigger picture."https://smmpanel.com/

author by 928380504 - qbj928380504@163.compublication date Sat Apr 05, 2025 10:32author address author phone qbj928380504@163.comReport this post to the editors

The language style[ ]()is relaxed and humorous, making it stress free to read
https://stimulation-clicker.org

author by Sophia Miapublication date Thu Apr 24, 2025 03:53author email kyliefromkoala at gmail dot comauthor address H #784author phone Report this post to the editors

I want to talk about a conflict that has reshaped modern geopolitics, strained global alliances, and devastated countless lives—the war between Ukraine and Russia.
More than just a regional dispute, this war reflects larger tensions in the international order and touches on themes of sovereignty, power, identity, and survival. Stay informed with The House Detective News. The updates are nonstop! https://thehousedetective.com/

author by Sophia Miapublication date Thu Apr 24, 2025 03:53author email kyliefromkoala at gmail dot comauthor address H #784author phone Report this post to the editors

I want to talk about a conflict that has reshaped modern geopolitics, strained global alliances, and devastated countless lives—the war between Ukraine and Russia.
More than just a regional dispute, this war reflects larger tensions in the international order and touches on themes of sovereignty, power, identity, and survival. Stay informed with The House Detective News. The updates are nonstop! https://thehousedetective.com/

author by Asphalt repair Plainfieldpublication date Fri May 02, 2025 15:14author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Top 5 Benefits of Asphalt Sealcoating for Driveways and Parking Lots

Asphalt is a durable and cost-effective paving material, but over time, exposure to weather and traffic can cause it to deteriorate. Sealcoating is a protective layer applied to asphalt surfaces that extends their lifespan and enhances their appearance. Whether you own a residential driveway or a commercial parking lot, regular sealcoating can save you money and protect your investment. Here are the top five benefits of asphalt sealcoating  https://www.sealcoatingasphaltjoliet.com

1. Protects Against Harsh Weather

Asphalt surfaces in Joliet, IL, are constantly exposed to the elements, including harsh winters and intense summer heat. UV rays, rain, snow, and ice can break down the asphalt binder, leading to cracks and potholes. Sealcoating acts as a barrier, preventing moisture from penetrating the surface and reducing the risk of damage caused by freezing and thawing cycles. This extra layer of protection helps maintain the integrity of the asphalt, especially in climates with extreme weather variations.

2. Prevents Cracks and Erosion

One of the primary causes of asphalt deterioration is oxidation, which weakens the surface and makes it prone to cracking. Once cracks form, water can seep into the underlying layers, causing erosion and structural damage. Sealcoating slows down the oxidation process by shielding the asphalt from oxygen and moisture. By filling surface voids and creating a smooth, waterproof barrier, sealcoating prevents cracks and prolongs the life of the pavement.

3. Enhances Curb Appeal

A freshly sealcoated surface has a smooth, jet-black finish that enhances the overall appearance of your property. For homeowners, a well-maintained driveway boosts curb appeal and adds value to the property. For businesses, a clean and attractive parking lot leaves a positive impression on customers and visitors. Sealcoating gives asphalt surfaces a polished look, making them appear newer and well-maintained.

4. Saves Money in the Long Run

Regular sealcoating is a cost-effective way to protect your asphalt investment. Without sealcoating, minor cracks and surface damage can escalate into major repairs, such as resurfacing or even complete replacement. By applying a protective sealant every 2-3 years, you can extend the life of your pavement and avoid expensive repairs. Sealcoating is a small upfront investment that delivers significant long-term savings.

5. Improves Safety and Reduces Liability

Cracked or uneven asphalt surfaces can pose safety hazards for pedestrians and vehicles. Sealcoating smooths the surface, reducing the risk of trips, slips, and falls. For businesses, maintaining a safe and hazard-free parking lot minimizes the risk of accidents and potential liability claims. Sealcoating also enhances the visibility of pavement markings, ensuring better traffic flow and safety.

Conclusion

Sealcoating is a vital maintenance step that protects asphalt surfaces from damage, enhances appearance, and saves money over time. Property owners in Joliet and surrounding areas can benefit from regular sealcoating to extend the lifespan of their driveways and parking lots. For professional asphalt sealcoating services in Joliet, visit https://www.sealcoatingasphaltjoliet.com and schedule a free estimate today!

Google Maps: https://www.google.com/maps?cid=8438917140161966205

Related Link: https://www.sealcoatingasphaltjoliet.com
Number of comments per page
  
 
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
© 2005-2025 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]