user preferences

New Events

Russia / Ukraine / Belarus

no event posted in the last week

Are Anarchists Giving in to War Fever?

category russia / ukraine / belarus | anarchist movement | opinion / analysis author Saturday February 18, 2023 01:22author by Wayne Priceauthor email drwdprice at aol dot com Report this post to the editors

In Defense of Anarchists Who Support the Ukrainian people

My response to an article, “British Anarchism Succumbs to War Fever” by Alex Alder. That article expresses dismay that many anarchists, in Britain and Eastern Europe and elsewhere have come to support the Ukrainian side of its war with Russian imperialism. It regards this perspective as a betrayal of anarchism, internationalism, and anti-militarism.

I, on the contrary, think that this solidarity with the Ukrainians is a very good thing. It is completely consistent with revolutionary anarchism.

This is my response to an article, “British Anarchism Succumbs to War Fever” by Alex Alder. It appeared on the libcom site and has been promoted by the Anarchist Communist Group. It was published on anarchistnews. https://anarchistnews.org/comment/51586#comment-51586

Its author is dismayed that so many revolutionary anarchist-socialists are in solidarity with the Ukrainian people. “How is it that today the anarchist movement in Britain (and elsewhere) is supporting one nation’s military against another, ideologically justifying and materially provisioning the Ukrainian war effort? … From the long-standing anarchist paper Freedom and anarcho-communist Anarchist Federation (AFed), to the anarchist ‘scene’ around antifascist and other activist groups, war fever is rife.” From my perspective it is a very good thing that so many Western anarchists are supporting the Ukrainian people against the Russian imperialist attack. So are most Ukrainian, Russian, and Belarusian anarchists. “Many of the anarchists in Ukraine, and across Eastern Europe, have thrown themselves behind Ukraine’s war effort.” Alex Alder sees this as a betrayal of anarchist internationalism and anti-militarism. I do not.

If two slave masters get into a brawl, freedom-loving people will stay out of it. We don’t care who wins. But if a slave master is fighting with a slave who is trying to escape, freedom-loving people will support the slave. If another slave master (an enemy of the one fighting) throws a club or knife to the slave, we who love freedom will still support the slave and help him or her escape. (The metaphor does not present the “slave” as the Ukrainian state but as the Ukrainian people.)

Nationalism and Internationalism

Alder argues that supporting Ukraine contradicts anarchist opposition to nationalism. He quotes with favor a previous statement by the British AFed against nationalism: “As anarchist communists, we have always opposed nationalism…including that of ‘oppressed nations’. While we oppose oppression, exploitation and dispossession on national grounds, and oppose imperialism and imperialist warfare, we refuse to fall into the trap … of identifying with the underdog side and glorifying the ‘resistance’— however ‘critically’.”

Surely this is an odd statement. On the one hand it opposes national oppression and exploitation and imperialist warfare, while on the other hand it refuses to identify with the “underdog,” the oppressed and exploited. Why should anarchists, opponents of all oppression and exploitation, not identify with the underdog, and support (if not “glorify”) the popular resistance?

The reason given is that national resistance is done under the ideological cover of “nationalism.” Here it is worth citing the view of the great Italian anarchist, Errico Malatesta (associate of Bakunin and Kropotkin). In 1915, he wrote “While the Carnage Lasts,” in opposition to both sides in World War I. Among other things, he wrote,

“We are cosmopolitans….But we understand that in countries where the government and the main oppressors are of foreign nationality, the question of freedom and economic emancipation presents itself under the guise of nationalist struggle, and we therefore sympathize with national insurrections as with any insurrection against the oppressors. In that case, as in all others, we are with the people against the government.…We bow before the will of those concerned.”
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/errico-malatesta-while-the-carnage-lasts

In other words, anarchists are not nationalists but internationalists (“cosmopolitans”). Yet we recognize that sometimes peoples are oppressed by rulers from other nations. For example, the Ukrainians are not just exploited as workers (although the class conflict is always involved). They are bombed, massacred, raped, and tortured as Ukrainians. As Ukrainians they are threatened to have their language banned from schools, their children kidnapped, and their independence abolished. This is what the earlier quotation called “oppression, exploitation and dispossession on national grounds.” Therefore they tend to see this conflict in nationalist terms—not surprisingly. As Malatesta concluded, “We therefore sympathize with national insurrection…We are with the people against the [invading foreign-WP] government.”

“Nationalism,” which anarchists oppose, is not simply the same thing as opposition to national oppression. It is not just a desire for one’s people to be able to decide for themselves what kind of country they will have. That is “national self-determination”—including the freedom of a people to chose what political system they want (e.g. a democratic state, a centralized state, or no state at all [anarchy])—and their freedom to decide what economic system they want (state socialism, capitalism, libertarian socialism).

Rather, nationalism is only one program proposed for national self-determination. It implies the total unity of the nation, denying the reality of class and other differences, and supporting the ruling class and its state. Anarchists reject nationalism but not the goal of national self-determination. In the same article, Malatesta wrote, “We would like every human group to be able to live in the conditions it prefers and to be free to unite and break away from other groups as it pleases.” This is anarchism.

Similarly, Michael Bakunin wrote, “Nationality…denotes the inalienable right of individuals, groups, associations and regions to their own way of life. And this way of life is the product of a long historical development. That is why I will always champion the cause of oppressed nationalities struggling to liberate themselves from the oppression of the state.” (Referring specially to the foreign state which is oppressing that nationality.) (Bakunin On Anarchism. [S. Dolgoff, Ed.] 1980; Black Rose. My emphasis.)

Unlike nationalists, anarchist-socialists (anarchist-communists) believe that all countries can achieve full self-determination only through the revolution of the international working class and its allies among all the oppressed. This includes women, people of color, and, among others, people of oppressed countries. Meanwhile, anarchists should not use popular nationalism as an excuse to not be “with the people against the [invading] government.”

The Ukrainian state is getting significant support from the U.S. and its NATO allies. Alder argues, “In supporting Ukraine, British anarchists have found themselves on the side of NATO, an imperialist military alliance …But rather than take this as an opportunity to repudiate NATO, acknowledging a mere coincidence of interests in this particular situation, anarchists in Britain have wavered in their opposition.”

If true, those anarchists are making a mistake. It is possible to continue opposition to NATO, calling for its dissolution, while recognizing that there has been a “coincidence of interests” between Western imperialism and the Ukrainian people. However much the U.S. and other imperialist states are materially aiding the Ukrainians, it is the Ukrainians who are doing the actual fighting. It is the Ukrainian people who are being bombed and massacred. They are paying for their independence with their blood.

It is not unknown for competing imperialisms to support the rebellion of countries oppressed by the other imperial state. During the Cold War, the USSR gave support, military and otherwise, to peoples rebelling against the Western empires in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Meanwhile, the U.S. supported Russia’s satellites in Eastern Europe.

The Vietnam-American war was a mirror image of the Ukrainian-Russian war, but the principle was the same. The U.S. was the active aggressor, while Stalinist Russia sent military aid to Vietnam. Yet the central conflict was between the rebellious Vietnamese people and the imperialist U.S. That the imperialist Russians sent aid or that the Vietnamese were misled by Ho’s Stalinist-nationalists, did not change the fundamental dynamics nor the justification for solidarity with the people of Vietnam.

There is no need to politically endorse NATO. There is merely a “coincidence of interests” and they would betray the Ukrainians in a heartbeat if it suited their interests—as the U.S. has repeatedly done with the Kurds. But the Ukrainians have every right to take arms and aid from NATO. They have to get missiles from somewhere and where else is there? (Similarly, in the Vietnam-U.S. war, the Vietnamese had every right to get weapons from the Soviet Union.)

Anti-Fascism and the Popular Front

Alex Alder understands that Putin’s Russia and Zelensky’s Ukraine are not the same. While he would not call either “fascist,” he regards Russia as
having “reached a level of authoritarian nationalism, internal repression, and revanchist expansionism comparable to the fascist regimes of the twentieth century. The Ukrainian state can better be described as a neoliberal, corrupt democracy.” There are fascist movements in both societies, but he rejects Putin’s claim to be “denazifying” Ukraine.

He does not deny that it is better to live under a limited, bourgeois, democracy than under a semi-totalitarian dictatorship. But he does not believe in fighting for bourgeois democracy. He quotes Gilles Dauve, “The fight for a democratic state is inevitably a fight to consolidate the state, and far from crippling totalitarianism, such a fight increases totalitarianism’s stranglehold on society.”

He does not realize that the fight for bourgeois-democratic rights is also a fight for elements of workers’ democracy which exist under capitalism: the freedom to form unions, to form radical political organizations, to argue for anarchism and socialism, to publish left literature, to organize for greater freedom for women and for People of Color, to demonstrate against ecological disaster, and against imperialist wars, and so on. Nor does he realize the revolutionary significance of the capitalist state’s inability to live up to its democratic promises. The fight for democratic freedoms must come up against the limitations of bourgeois representative democracy. If fought for all the way, it leads toward anarchist-socialist revolution.

Alder repeatedly compares support of the Ukrainian war to a “Popular Front.” In the 1930s, Popular Fronts were political alliances of “workers’ parties” (Socialists and Communists) with liberal and conservative pro-capitalist parties, to form governing coalitions. Because they included bourgeois parties, they guaranteed that the government could not go beyond capitalism, despite the “workers’ parties” claims to stand for some sort of socialism. Popular Fronts were formed in a number of countries, France being one and Spain another. In Spain, after Franco’s fascist military rebellion, the main anarchist organizations (the CNT-FAI) also joined the Popular Front government. Then and now, revolutionary anarchists have regarded this as a disaster and a prelude to the victory of the fascists.

In fact, none of the anarchists who support the Ukrainian side of the war have advocated Popular Fronts. In particular, in Ukraine, where almost all anarchists support the war, no one has joined Zelensky’s party, urged votes for Zelensky, endorsed his party, allied with his party, taken positions in the government, or even ran for election on a separate ticket. Nor have other anarchists in Britain or elsewhere called for coalitions with bourgeois parties.

However, to Alder and his co-thinkers, just participating in the war makes anarchists collaborators with the capitalist state, a part of its militarism, in a de facto Popular Front. Other anarchists have seen things quite differently. For example, during the Spanish Civil War of the 1930s, some revolutionary anarchists denounced the policy of the anarchist leadership. They opposed joining the Popular Front and cooperating in the rebuilding of the Spanish state. They demanded that the anarchist leaders withdraw from the government. But they did not call on the anarchist workers to withdraw from the war against the fascists. The workers would not have understood such a proposal; they would have seen it as surrender to fascism. (And today, Ukrainians would see a demand for them to stop fighting as a call for surrender to Russia.) Further, working in most industries during a war was almost as much serving the war as being in the military. Instead they proposed to stay out of the government, but to participate in the anti-fascist war effort, with the aim of eventually winning over enough of the working class to carry out a revolution against both the liberal Republicans and the fascists.

One such dissident anarchist group was The Friends of Durruti Group. In their pamphlet Towards a Fresh Revolution (written 1938 by Jaime Balius), they wrote:

“There must be no collaboration with capitalism….Class struggle is no obstacle to workers continuing at present to fight on in the battlefields and working in the war industries….Revolutionary workers must not shoulder official posts, nor establish themselves in the ministries. For as long as the war lasts, collaboration is permissible—on the battlefield, in the trenches, on the parapets, and in productive labor in the rearguard.” (emphasis added)

This strategy is based on the assumption that the war is just, in the interests of the working class and the oppressed, and that the anarchists’ goal—whether short-term or long-term—is to make a revolution against the state and capital.

War and Class Struggle

The author interprets the European conflict as having only two aspects, the capitalist class and its state versus the working class. His approach fits with the slogan, “No War but Class War!” Yet most anarchists these days would acknowledge other oppressed groups besides the proletariat. There are women, People of Color, LGBTQ people, Deaf people, Jews, other religious minorities (depending on the country), and so on and so forth. To be sure, these oppressions all overlap with class conflict but they also have their own reality and dynamics. Shall we then chant, “No War but Class War, and War Against Patriarchy by Women and their Allies, War Against White Supremacy by People of Color and their Allies, War against Antisemitism by Jews and their Allies, Etc., Etc.”? It would make an awkward slogan, but most anarchists these days really mean this when they chant, “No War but Class War!”

While almost all anarchists accept all these non-class (but overlapping with class) oppressions as real, for some reason a great many reject national oppression as real. As I have previously quoted, Bakunin took it as real and Malatesta took it seriously as something people cared deeply about. Yet many reject national self-determination because they see it as supporting a new state, which anarchists know is not the answer. But a people’s self-determination means that they can chose their own society. They are (relatively) free to decide if they want a state, or to merge with another state, or to form a federal or centralized state. Right now most peoples are not anarchistic. They want their own state. Hopefully they will have the opportunity to learn from their mistakes. But we who believe in freedom want them to have their own chance to find out for themselves—the Palestinians, the Tibetans, the Puerto Ricans, the Yemenis, the West Saharans, the Uighurs, the Chechens, African-Americans, or, yes, Ukrainians.

We Who Believe in Freedom

To some anarchists and revolutionary libertarian socialists, by no means limited to Alex Alder and the Anarchist Communist Group (UK), support for Ukraine is un-anarchist. So is support for any national liberation struggle. Yet, to their dismay, many revolutionary anarchists do stand in solidarity with the Ukrainian people—despite their government, their capitalist class, and the support (for its reasons) by U.S. imperialism. This is true of many British anarchists as well as Ukrainian and Eastern European anarchists. So many anarchists disagree with them! Also, although Alder does not mention it, many anarchists throughout the history of the movement have supported wars of national self-determination. I have cited Bakunin and Malatesta; there are many other examples.

We who believe in freedom do not reject both sides when a powerful imperialist army tries to crush a smaller, weaker, and poorer country. We are not neutral when an imperialist dictatorship is seeking to destroy a people’s independence, culture, and national freedom. We do not look for excuses to stand off from supporting the attacked people. Neither do we drop our principled program of revolutionary opposition to all states and all capitalists. We do not support the Ukrainian state and its ruling class. We do solidarize with the workers, farmers, and others of the mass of Ukrainian people who are bravely resisting their re-colonization by the imperial Russian state. This is a part (not the whole) of the struggle for freedom, which is what anarchism is all about.

Will a victory by Ukraine, with its current state and imperialist alliances, open up the possibility of more freedom and democracy—leading to a greater possibility of an anarchist-socialist revolution? This cannot be said for sure. I do not have a crystal ball. But the defeat of the Ukrainian people by the authoritarian Russian empire of Putin will probably make our goals even harder to reach. In either case, it is the right thing to do to stand on the side of greater freedom.

*written for Anarkismo.net

author by amanahtotopublication date Tue Mar 12, 2024 16:01author email author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Dengan minimal deposit 10.000 saja anda sudah dapat melakukan permainan ke semua permainan. dijamin deh pasti untung berlipat ganda apa lagi setiap kemenangan pasti langsung di bayar dengan lunas https://www.shopatnorthland.com/

Related Link: https://www.shopatnorthland.com
author by xx-vedeos - bupublication date Tue Mar 05, 2024 22:53author email mersiaya757 at gmail dot comauthor address author phone Report this post to the editors

Everyone talks about their interests and hobbies, and I won’t be far behind and say that my main hobby is online casinos. Most of the time I play at night because it is my favorite time of the day. You can spend a lot of time doing what you love, and I am no exception. https://anne-braden.org/ The most popular place for me is online casinos, more information by clicking, because there is real money there. It seems to me that everyone should decide to take this step.

Related Link: https://anne-braden.org/
author by Amanahtoto - amanahtotopublication date Sun Feb 25, 2024 21:01author email amanahtotoseo at gmail dot comauthor address Jakartaauthor phone +62854215411450Report this post to the editors

Amanahtoto adalah tempat toto online situs terpercaya di Indonesia yang menghadirkan pasaran resmi dan terpercaya nomor satu. Amanahtoto menyediakan beberapa beragam deposit seperti e wallet , via bank QRIS, dan pulsa. maka dari itu mendaftar di https://twtapps.com/ amanahtoto sekarang juga.

Related Link: https://twtapps.com/
author by satset store - satset storepublication date Sun Feb 25, 2024 17:21author email author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Top up free fire paling murah hanya di satset store, sudah terpercaya dan legal sudah jadi regulasi top up nomor satu free fire di Indonesia. Mau top up? solusi terbaik adalah dengan top up di tempat website terpercaya https://satsetstore.id/Mobile-Games/Free-Fire.

Related Link: https://satsetstore.id/Mobile-Games/Free-Fire
author by Riyachadhapublication date Mon Feb 05, 2024 19:35author email cher75829 at gmail dot comauthor address author phone Report this post to the editors

Dehradun Call Girl for personal enjoyment and to earn a lot of money to fulfil all my dreams. I am an Independent escort girl and a young escort, a very busy Call Girl in Dehradun. I always provide my services to a high-profile client. So, if you are in Dehradun Escorts. https://www.glamorousescort.in/

author by Woopublication date Sat Aug 05, 2023 15:58author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Jasa backlink terbaik adalah layanan yang menyediakan tautan balik (backlink) dari situs web otoritatif dan relevan ke situs web Anda. Backlink adalah salah satu faktor penting dalam optimasi mesin pencari (SEO) yang dapat membantu meningkatkan otoritas dan peringkat situs web Anda di halaman hasil pencarian. Jasa backlink terbaik akan memberikan backlink berkualitas tinggi yang sesuai dengan pedoman mesin pencari dan dapat membantu meningkatkan visibilitas dan reputasi situs web Anda. https://www.kepointernet.com/jasa-backlink/ jasa backlink .
Jasa backlink PBN (Private Blog Network) permanen dan aman menyediakan backlink dari jaringan blog pribadi yang dimiliki oleh pihak ketiga. Backlink dari PBN dapat meningkatkan peringkat situs web karena sifatnya yang otoritatif. Namun, perlu diingat bahwa penggunaan PBN bisa melibatkan risiko jika tidak dilakukan dengan hati-hati, karena mesin pencari bisa mengenali PBN dan memberlakukan sanksi. Jasa yang menyediakan backlink PBN permanen dan aman biasanya berusaha untuk memitigasi risiko ini dan menghadirkan backlink yang tampak alami dan aman bagi SEO situs web Anda. https://www.kepointernet.com/jasa-backlink-pbn/ jasa backlink PBN kepointernet .
Travel Aswindra Jaya mungkin adalah sebuah perusahaan travel atau agen perjalanan. Informasi lebih lanjut tentang Travel Aswindra Jaya tidak disediakan dalam permintaan Anda, namun agen perjalanan seperti ini biasanya menawarkan paket perjalanan wisata, transportasi, akomodasi, dan layanan terkait lainnya untuk membantu pelanggan menjelajahi tujuan wisata dengan nyaman. https://www.aswindrajaya.com/ Travel Agent Bali .
Paket wisata murah Bali adalah tawaran perjalanan yang mencakup kunjungan ke berbagai destinasi wisata di Pulau Bali dengan harga terjangkau. Paket ini mungkin mencakup biaya akomodasi, transportasi, kunjungan ke tempat-tempat wisata populer, dan makanan tertentu. Harga paket wisata murah biasanya menarik bagi wisatawan yang ingin mengeksplorasi Bali dengan anggaran terbatas. https://www.aswindrajaya.com/paket-wisata-bali/ Paket wisata Bali Terbaik .
Jasa pembuatan PT (Perseroan Terbatas) di Jakarta adalah layanan yang membantu perusahaan atau individu dalam proses pendirian perusahaan dengan bentuk hukum PT di wilayah Jakarta, Indonesia. Proses pembuatan PT melibatkan beberapa tahap hukum dan administrasi, termasuk pendaftaran badan hukum, pengajuan dokumen, dan persyaratan lainnya yang harus dipenuhi sesuai dengan ketentuan hukum yang berlaku. https://www.lenus.id/Article/JASA-PEMBUATAN-PT-JAKARTA-TERBAIK-and-PROFESIONAL-LENUSID.html Jasa Pembuatan PT Jakarta .
Followindo mungkin adalah platform atau layanan yang berhubungan dengan media sosial, khususnya Instagram, yang berkaitan dengan peningkatan jumlah pengikut (followers). Ini dapat mencakup strategi, alat, atau metode tertentu yang bertujuan untuk membantu pengguna Instagram meningkatkan jumlah followers mereka dengan cara yang sah dan sesuai dengan pedoman media sosial. https://followindo.com/ SMM panel Indo .
WordPress adalah platform manajemen konten populer yang memungkinkan pengguna untuk membuat situs web tanpa harus memiliki keahlian pemrograman atau desain yang mendalam. Cara membuat website dengan mudah di WordPress melibatkan langkah-langkah seperti memilih hosting, menginstal WordPress, memilih tema, menambahkan konten (seperti halaman, posting blog, gambar, dll.), dan mengaktifkan plugin jika diperlukan. WordPress menyediakan antarmuka yang intuitif dan ramah pengguna untuk membantu pemula membangun situs web dengan mudah. https://www.kepointernet.com/cara-mengganti-tema-website-wordpress-video/ Cara mengganti tema website di Wordpress .
Paket bulan madu murah di Bali adalah tawaran perjalanan khusus untuk pasangan yang baru menikah (bulan madu). Paket ini berisi pengalaman romantis dan liburan mewah di Pulau Bali dengan harga yang terjangkau. Isi paket biasanya mencakup akomodasi romantis, makanan khas, kunjungan ke tempat-tempat eksotis, dan aktivitas-aktivitas lain yang menciptakan kenangan indah bagi pasangan tersebut. https://www.aswindrajaya.com/paket-honeymoon-bali/ paket honeymoon bali terbaik .
Harga paket honeymoon 3 hari 2 malam di Bali mencakup biaya perjalanan romantis selama tiga hari dan dua malam di Bali. Paket ini mungkin mencakup akomodasi di hotel atau vila khusus untuk pasangan, sarapan, makan malam romantis, kunjungan ke tempat-tempat menarik di Bali, dan aktivitas khusus lainnya. Harga paket dapat bervariasi tergantung pada fasilitas yang disediakan dan tingkat kenyamanan yang diinginkan oleh pasangan. https://www.aswindrajaya.com/paket-honeymoon-bali/4-hari-3-malam-bali-private-pool/ paket honeymoon 4 hari 3 malam Bali .
Layanan sewa mobil terbaik di Bali adalah layanan penyediaan mobil untuk disewa oleh wisatawan atau penduduk setempat di Pulau Bali. Layanan ini biasanya menawarkan beragam jenis mobil, seperti mobil pribadi, minivan, atau mobil mewah, dengan sopir atau tanpa sopir, sesuai dengan preferensi dan kebutuhan pengguna. Layanan sewa mobil terbaik akan menjamin kondisi mobil yang baik, ketepatan waktu, dan kenyamanan selama perjalanan di Bali. https://www.aswindrajaya.com/sewa-mobil-bali/ Rental mobil di Bali terbaik .
Baju olahraga lengan panjang adalah pakaian khusus untuk aktivitas fisik atau olahraga yang memiliki lengan panjang. Baju ini dirancang untuk memberikan perlindungan lebih pada lengan dan seringkali terbuat dari bahan yang dapat menyerap keringat dengan baik. Baju olahraga lengan panjang biasanya digunakan dalam olahraga luar ruangan seperti sepak bola, lari, mendaki gunung, dan aktivitas fisik lainnya untuk menjaga tubuh tetap hangat dan melindungi kulit dari paparan sinar matahari langsung. https://www.mj-506.com/grosir-sepatu-olahraga-murah/ GROSIR SEPATU OLAHRAGA .
Grosir sepatu olahraga adalah bisnis atau penyedia yang menjual sepatu olahraga secara massal atau dalam jumlah besar. Biasanya, grosir sepatu olahraga menyediakan berbagai merek dan jenis sepatu olahraga, seperti sepatu lari, sepatu sepak bola, sepatu basket, sepatu tenis, dan banyak lagi. Bisnis grosir ini ditujukan untuk para pengecer atau individu yang ingin membeli sepatu olahraga dalam jumlah besar dengan harga yang lebih kompetitif. https://www.mj-506.com/ TOKO BAJU OLAHRAGA .
Jasa iklan Adwords adalah layanan yang membantu perusahaan atau individu dalam membuat dan mengelola iklan berbayar menggunakan platform periklanan Google Ads (sebelumnya dikenal sebagai Google AdWords). Jasa ini berfokus pada kampanye iklan berbayar di mesin pencari Google dan jaringan iklan terkait, sehingga iklan dapat ditampilkan di atas atau di sebelah hasil pencarian organik. Jasa ini bertujuan untuk meningkatkan lalu lintas situs web, meningkatkan kesadaran merek, dan mencapai tujuan bisnis lainnya. https://www.murtafidigital.co.id/jasa-iklan-google-ads/ Jasa Google Ads .
Cetak buku online adalah layanan yang memungkinkan seseorang atau penerbit untuk mencetak buku atau materi penerbitan lainnya melalui layanan online. Pada umumnya, layanan ini menyediakan platform yang memungkinkan pengguna untuk mengunggah desain buku, memilih jenis kertas, ukuran, dan jumlah yang diinginkan, serta menentukan pilihan lain seperti cover, jilid, dan sebagainya. Layanan cetak buku online memberikan kemudahan bagi penulis independen atau penerbit dalam mencetak buku tanpa perlu pergi ke percetakan fisik. https://www.pentasgrafika.com/ Cetak buku murah .
Cara menaikkan followers Instagram adalah berbagai strategi dan taktik yang dapat digunakan untuk meningkatkan jumlah pengikut (followers) pada akun Instagram seseorang. Beberapa contoh cara yang umum dilakukan termasuk mengatur postingan yang menarik dan berkualitas, menggunakan hashtag yang relevan, berinteraksi dengan pengikut dan akun lain, mengikuti akun-akun dengan minat yang sama, berkolaborasi dengan pengguna lain, dan menggunakan fitur-fitur Instagram seperti Stories atau Live. Menaikkan jumlah followers dapat membantu meningkatkan visibilitas, interaksi, dan potensi pemasaran dalam platform media sosial ini. https://jasafollowers.id/cara-menambah-followers-instagram/ Cara followers ig banyak .
Undangan online adalah undangan yang dibuat dan dikirimkan secara elektronik melalui internet. Biasanya, undangan ini berbentuk file digital yang dapat dikirimkan melalui email, platform media sosial, atau situs web khusus. Undangan online populer untuk acara seperti pernikahan, ulang tahun, pertemuan bisnis, dan acara lainnya karena praktis, ramah lingkungan, dan dapat diakses dengan mudah oleh para tamu. https://undigindo.id/ Undangan pernikahan .
Jasa cuci sofa di Jogja adalah layanan yang ditawarkan oleh penyedia jasa untuk membersihkan sofa secara profesional. Mereka menggunakan peralatan dan bahan pembersih khusus untuk membersihkan sofa, termasuk membersihkan noda, debu, dan kotoran lainnya. Jasa ini umumnya ditujukan untuk memperpanjang umur sofa dan menjaga kebersihannya. https://gradeshomecleaning.web.id/ cuci sofa di jogja .
Jasa sumur gali di Jogja adalah layanan untuk menggali sumur, biasanya digunakan untuk keperluan air tanah. Penyedia jasa ini memiliki peralatan dan keahlian dalam menggali sumur dengan aman dan efisien. Sumur gali sering dibutuhkan untuk rumah, pertanian, dan proyek-proyek lain yang memerlukan pasokan air yang andal. https://sumurmurni.com/ jasa sumur gali jogja .
HP (Handphone) harga 2 jutaan mengacu pada ponsel atau smartphone yang memiliki harga dalam kisaran dua juta rupiah. Ponsel dengan harga ini biasanya adalah model-entry level atau mid-range dengan spesifikasi yang cukup baik untuk kebutuhan sehari-hari seperti berkomunikasi, menjalankan aplikasi, dan berselancar di internet. https://www.gizmonesia.com/2022/06/hp-2-jutaan-terbaik.html hp harga 2 juta .

author by Adam - slither iopublication date Mon Jun 12, 2023 11:00author email ghgha at gmail dot comauthor address Texasauthor phone 0868483658Report this post to the editors

I have read your post very carefully and I just want to say that the information you shared is really great and I have learned a lot from it.

author by Lindapublication date Mon Jun 12, 2023 10:56author email emmanbrownusa at gmail dot comauthor address Texasauthor phone 0868483658Report this post to the editors

This is one of the coolest websites I've ever seen. The articles posted on this website are very qualified and have a lot of useful information in many fields.

author by Karapublication date Mon Jun 12, 2023 10:53author email emmanbrownusa at gmail dot comauthor address Texasauthor phone 0868483658Report this post to the editors

I really like the information you share. I learned a lot of new and useful knowledge from your post.

author by Lindapublication date Mon Jun 12, 2023 10:52author email ghgownusa at gmail dot comauthor address author phone 0868483658Report this post to the editors

Thank you for sharing this information. I just wanted to let you know that I checked out your website and that I thought it was extremely fascinating and educational. I look forward to reading many of your postings.

author by rakshapublication date Sat Apr 29, 2023 11:09author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Ponniyin Selvan: 2 has undoubtedly set high expectations for the audiences with its intriguing storyline, brilliant star cast, and breathtaking visuals. The movie has received a positive response from the audience, and its first-day box office collection is a testament to its popularity. Despite the challenges posed by the pandemic, the film has managed to earn a whopping Rs. 20 crores [url=https://boxofficecollection.co.in/]box office collection[/url] (early estimate) on its opening day in India alone, which is a great feat.

author by FKNpublication date Wed Apr 26, 2023 11:46author address author phone Report this post to the editors

https://election-result.in/ Election result will be delcared on 13 may

author by Stevenpublication date Tue Apr 18, 2023 18:16author address author phone Report this post to the editors

Are you someone who enjoys solving puzzles and brain teasers? If so, you may have come across the game Word Wipe. Word Wipe is a popular word game that challenges players to create as many words as possible from a given set of letters. In this article, we will take a closer look at Word Wipe, how it works, and the benefits of playing this game.

Related Link: https://wordwipe.online
author by fdpublication date Sun Mar 26, 2023 16:17author address author phone Report this post to the editors

“the fascist governments of the US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taking power. https://pricehub.ng/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki https://www.fynxt.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://victoryofthepeople.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.magickuwait.online/product/pestcontrol-kuwait/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.1stkaraoke.com US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://ips-us.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.agiledigitalmktg.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.craftsmanpainters.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://stanleywindowcare.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.stonewoodwc.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://städly.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://s3.amazonaws.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://storage.googleapis.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://s3.us-west-001.backblazeb2.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://us-east-1.linodeobjects.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://agencia-de-marketing.b-cdn.net/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://s3.us-east-1.wasabisys.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://agencia-de-marketing.nyc3.digitaloceanspaces.com/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://ewr1.vultrobjects.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://objects-us-east-1.dream.io/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://id7idg7os66s.compat.objectstorage.us-ashburn-1.oraclecloud.com/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://usc1.contabostorage.com/52e78a6bb5534763a875429eac87debc:agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://pressreleasesnews.blob.core.windows.net/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://filedn.com/lACVtAqGeFTLQiOy1AqX0v0/marketing-digital/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://p8r2.c16.e2-1.dev/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://pub-5ecea708072c4ac081cd70feebb1a905.r2.dev/agencia-de-marketing/tijuana-bc/daseo-marketing-digital-seo.html US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://daseo-marketing-digital-and-seo.neocities.org/daseo-marketing-digital-seo US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
http://thebigslice.org/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.risingelementsmassage.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki
https://www.drivefool.com/ US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taki

author by Waynepublication date Thu Mar 09, 2023 08:24author email drwdprice at aol dot comauthor address author phone Report this post to the editors

Billie,

The government of Ukraine is not “fascist.” It is a representative bourgeois-democratic state, dominated by big business, fairly corrupt, following neo-liberal austerity and anti-union policies. In the last elections, the actual fascist parties lost largely.

“the fascist governments of the US and Russia” is not a thing. While one major party leans to the far-right in the US, the US regime is not fascist (at this time anyway). This was demonstrated in the last presidential and midterm elections where the US establishment (big capitalists, top military brass, national police forces, etc.) prevented Trump and his minions from taking power.

Russia has an authoritarian far-right government, with a thin veneer of bourgeois democracy. Not fascist at this time.

None of which refutes the analysis of an imperialist government invading and trying to destroy an independent (non-imperialist) country.

Your recommended source seems to be a game site. Maybe I'm missing something. The site says it is based in NYC with a branch office in Russia. So even if I could find your references, I doubt they are very reliable.

author by Billie - AHFpublication date Tue Mar 07, 2023 16:02author email joliebillie276 at gmail dot comauthor address author phone Report this post to the editors

The fascists in Ukraine were encouraged by the US before the 2014 revolution. Here are some references for that. Ukraine is being used as a staging area by the fascist governments of the US and Russia. The government and media of Ukraine are questionable, as is typical for the area.

Related Link: https://wordwipe.co/
Number of comments per page
  
 

This page has not been translated into Nederlands yet.

This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
© 2005-2024 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]