Anarkismo.net     http://www.anarkismo.net

An Anarchist Analysis About The Anarchists In Ukrainian Resistance Against Russian Invasion

category international | imperialism / war | opinion / analysis author Friday March 04, 2022 21:23author by Batur Ozdinc

A group of Ukrainian anarchists living in Kyiv declared that they have joined popular resistance against Russian invasion and organized their own group- leading to many debates among anarchist circles. As long as we do not exactly know their own circumstances, one might think that they are purely pro-NATO people, confused nationalist-anarchists or even neo-Nazi supporters. Actually, they are not! According to their declarations before and during the war, they do exactly know what NATO, capitalism, nationalism and imperialism is; and they are against all of them. For me, they are just a group of comrades who found themselves in the middle of a war and trying to find out a way to defend their own lives and their own ideas.

A group of Ukrainian anarchists living in Kyiv declared that they have joined popular resistance against Russian invasion and organized their own group- leading to many debates among anarchist circles. As long as we do not exactly know their own circumstances, one might think that they are purely pro-NATO people, confused nationalist-anarchists or even neo-Nazi supporters. Actually, they are not! According to their declarations before and during the war, they do exactly know what NATO, capitalism, nationalism and imperialism is; and they are against all of them. For me, they are just a group of comrades who found themselves in the middle of a war and trying to find out a way to defend their own lives and their own ideas.

Personally, (perhaps as many anarchists) I think the “Russian state” (apart from Donbass or whatever) does not have any “right” to invade Ukraine as a whole under the excuse of defending itself against NATO. In this sense, the resistance of local (civil) people in Ukraine (not the Ukrainian army though) might be seen as a “right”. However, the war has two opponents; both are pro-capitalist, although one might seem to be more oppressive and imperialist. In addition to this, it is the state and capitalist mechanism provoking civil people against each other and imposing nationalist ideas- in some cases leading to massacres or genocide; as it did in the late Ottoman period against Armenians and in Nazi Germany against Jews and Romani people. Therefore, although at first look it may seem “innocent”, the “civil resistance” may lead to lynches, massacres against other nations and opponents or end up with establishing a new “nationalist” state.

Supporting Ukrainian “side” is not the same as anarchists did in the past during the 1936 revolution in Catalonia (so-called the civil war in Spain) in which both capitalist, religious and statist institutions were questioned nor it has something to do with the things going on in Rojava (North Syria) which is highly influenced by the ideas of Bookchin. Ukraine may be more “democratic” and an open society in the liberal sense (than Russia), but it is still a capitalist state.

On the other hand, the anti-Russian atmosphere, led by the Western media is somehow transforming itself into a kind of racism, a hostility against Russian people and culture as a whole – not just Putin, Russian state or imperialism at all. I believe, this is something, which -as anarchists- we should stand against as long as emphasizing that NATO is as bad as (maybe in some cases even worse than) Russian imperialism.

Anarchism and “war” are two different concepts, which do fully disagree. Many of us still use the term “class war” in some cases but what we mean is not the same as the supporters of states do. We do not defend the idea of a group of “permanent armed people” organized to defend a country (an organized army) or even (as most of anarchists) we do not support any “army” at all. In general, we are fond of libertarian guerilla struggle; which either aims for a social revolution or self-defense (or both). In some cases, although we found ourselves in cooperation with different (capitalist, statist or even imperialist) forces, as Durruti said “No government in the world fights Fascism to the death.” and we should know that such a cooperation is temporary and something which we are not so fond of.

For many of us, it is easy to say “No to War and No to both NATO and Russian imperialism”. In Turkish, we say “Davulun sesi uzaktan hos gelir” (“The drum sounds nice from a distance”-“The grass looks greener on the other side”). On the other hand, I have read many things about the repression on Belarusian anarchists who were forced to flee (to Ukraine and Poland mostly); also, I can just imagine how hard it is to live and survive in a country which is invaded by an imperialist state as Ukrainian comrades do. So, I can only guess how they do suffer from the oppressors in Belarus and Russia; in this sense I try to understand their rage against Russian imperialism.

In the final analysis, although (as anarchists) our actions and expressions may differ depending on time and space, we are all against state, capitalism and imperialism. In these circumstances, while as an exception we might cooperate with non-anarchist forces, we should not forget that whom we fight on the same side might be our enemy in the near future. Our main aim should be developing international solidarity among our comrades and working class; and carry on anti-war struggle.

Comments (2 of 2)

Jump To Comment: 1 2
author by Wayne Pricepublication date Sun Apr 03, 2022 12:37author address author phone

Batur Ozdinc deals with an important problem for anarchists, how to relate to the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the Ukrainian resistance. But he starts from a wrong perspective: "the war has two opponents; both are pro-capitalist, although one might seem to be more oppressive and imperialist" Yes, there are two capitalist states at war, but one of them really is "imperialist" (not just "seems to be") while the other, Ukraine, is a non-imperialist, oppressed, nation (the poorest in Europe). One state, the Russian, has chosen to invade the other, sending its army to blow up cities, drive the population from their homes, kill the people, and take over the government if they can. In the other, the people--not just the capitalist state but the workers and other ordinary people--have opposed this invasion. They have organized themselves, with much voluntary cooperation and initiative from below, to fight for their people. Unfortunately they are being organized by the national state. No doubt the Ukrainian anarchists are trying to change their minds about the need for a state. But meanwhile the state is there. Shall anarchists refuse to support the struggling Ukrainian people because they are so unfortunate as to have a state? Shall anarchists declare, your resistance is just, but since you have a capitalist state we cannot support you or show solidarity? This is not the way to win Ukrainians for revolutionary anarchism!

author by Waynepublication date Sun Apr 03, 2022 13:01author address author phone

Readers of this statement may be interested in my article, Defend Ukraine! Oppose Russian and U.S. Imperialism!

https://www.anarkismo.net/article/32559

This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch

http://www.anarkismo.net/article/32563

Anarkismo.net is a international anarchist-communist news service