The Broken Promises of Vietnam
south-east asia |
the left |
Sunday May 09, 2021 21:13 by Vietnamese Anarchists
A Vietnamese anarchist critique of the so-called "socialism" of Vietnam
... to exist is in itself a victory, thus a role manifests itself, a role to represent the voices of Vietnamese radicals. We aim at the future working class, the youth, who are both perpetuating and oppressed by capitalism and the state so that they can break through its oppressive chains.
Vietnam 2021, the mood in the air seems to be that of optimism. The government's relentless pursuit of a Zero-COVID strategy has won them widespread approval both domestically and internationally. The economy managed to squeeze out positive growth whereas many of its neighbours suffered a decline from the pandemic. Yet underneath all this bravado, one could sense that something is amiss. There's this nagging feeling that no one seems to be able to put a finger on. Almost as if, there is a spectre haunting Vietnam, the spectre of communism — the true kind without any bells and whistles.
As Emma Goldman astutely observed, there was no communism in the USSR. The same can be said of present-day Vietnam. The party in power — the Communist Party of Vietnam (CPV) — has long strayed from the path to communism.
Before the current party leader assumes his third term (2020–2025), he formulated an ambitious road map, in which by 2045 Vietnam would become a “developed” country, on par with Japan, South Korea, and Singapore. To us radicals, this is a betrayal to the working class, indigenous people, and marginalised groups who sacrificed so much for Vietnam's revolution. But as Marxist-Leninists with bright eyes and adamant conviction would tell you, that's all part of the plan™ and 2045 will be the long-awaited year when Vietnam finally advances to a classless, moneyless, and stateless, country.
However, a closer look at Vietnam's society today would show that the plan is but an illusion, and the promises are mere justification for the ruling class and capitalist class to continue sucking the life out of Vietnam for a while longer. The difference between what the party elites preach and what they allow to happen in reality is that between day and night.
As Vietnam's economy grows by leaps and bounds, so does the chasm between the rich and the poor. And no amount of welfare and regulation can stop the accumulation of capital or reverse the flow of wealth from the hands of the many into those of a few. Nowhere does this accumulation manifest itself more pervasively than in the system of land ownership. This system allows control of the land to be wrested from the peasants and the common people for little compensation and given to capitalists who often make many times more profit. All across the country, luxurious residential buildings sprung up but few of those displaced by them can afford to move in. The billionaire Phạm Nhật Vượng, whose family own as much wealth as 800,000 Vietnamese, couldn't have built his empire without public properties being handed into to his pocket in this manner.
Vietnam's already precarious ecosystem and indigenous communities also pay a heavy price for this rapid economic development. The plan for the electricity sector until 2045 gave some concession to renewable energies whilst supporting the construction of many new coal power plants, ignoring their huge CO2 footprint and many warnings about the link between coal power and the PM2.5 fog that covers major cities, threatening the well-being of millions. In the mid-2010s, hundreds of small hydroelectric power plants sprung up in the mountainous area around the country to sate the power-hungry cities and factories. These plants not only disrupted the river network and deprived the downstream agricultural land of essential sediment, they also caused untold damages to indigenous communities during construction and operation. Solar energy plants in Ninh Thuận robbed the indigenous Chăm of their ranching land. The Mekong Delta, Vietnam's primary rice cultivating area, is facing an existential threat from the many dams being constructed upstream in Thailand and China. And at the same time as a national project to plant one billion trees is ratified, numerous approvals went to capitalists so they can transform thousands of hectares of farm and forest land into resorts and golf courses.
Behind all this is a strong sense of nationalism — an effective tool to silence any meaningful criticism against the state, a value which can be utilised to undermine other people's struggle in the name of an abstract greater good. Nationalism has become the value that determines a Vietnamese citizen's worth.
It was nationalism that catapulted the Việt Minh into power during the 1940s. It was nationalism that motivated millions of young Vietnamese to put the nation's interest above their own as they throw themselves against foreign imperialism. Since the early days of the Party, there has been a consistent effort to cultivate a strong sense of nationalism everywhere. Nationalism is in the Vietnamese children's curriculum, in our songs, poems, art, and all over the media. One of the greatest successes of the Party has been the conflation of national identity and party loyalty. Modern Vietnamese capitalists like VinGroup or BKAV can be seen taking a cue from the state propaganda machine and incorporated nationalistic elements into the marketing of their products.
Ironically, it is the nationalists that claim to inherit Vietnam's “communist” revolution, yet they are the most vocal group against any and all radical ideals such as animal liberation, gender and sexuality liberation, indigenous autonomy, decriminalisation of sex work, and solidarity with international struggles, such as those in Hong Kong or Myanmar. The nationalist persuasion predictably morphed into a counter-revolutionary, reactionary force draping themselves in red.
Vulnerable victims of Vietnamese nationalism include, but are not limited to:
Queer people, who continue to face a high degree of discrimination in Vietnam. Recent progress in gender and sexuality liberation has largely come from liberal elements, such as the Pride movement, which is nothing more than a marketing ploy for foreign and local companies. Substantial changes, such as the recognition of same-sex families and transgender individuals' medical needs as rights have been delayed time and time again to prioritise “more pressing matters.”
Sex workers, who are stigmatised and targeted by the police. In the eyes of Vietnam's patriarchal society, sex work isn't recognised as labour, but a mere immoral ailment to be eliminated. Consequently, sex work is blamed for the spread of STIs like HIV, and sex workers, especially queer sex workers, are cast to the fringe of society.
Indigenous communities, who have been at the brunt of Kinh's (or Việt's) expansionist policies since the time of feudalism, find no assurance under the “anti-imperialist” rule of the current state. Worse off, the oppression they face has escalated, as the state obtains novel and more effective tools to neutralise any resistance, as well as to proactively patrol the indigenous population.
Abroad, many defenders of Vietnam's “socialism” have witnessed and ignored these obvious red flags, for all are justified in the name of their favourite “socialist” state's development. This demonstrates an apathy and ignorance toward Vietnamese people's continuous struggle for a just society, not to mention the embracing of capitalism, as long as it is draped in a red flag and claims to be against the imperialistic ambitions of “the West,” especially the US, even when all signs show that communism is and was never on the agenda.
In the end, to exist is in itself a victory, thus a role manifests itself, a role to represent the voices of Vietnamese radicals. We aim at the future working class, the youth, who are both perpetuating and oppressed by capitalism and the state so that they can break through its oppressive chains.
View Comments Titles Only
Comments (73 of 73)Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73
Traduction en français à cette adresse. http://ucl-saguenay.blogspot.com/2021/06/les-promesses-brisees-du-vietnam.html Vous pouvez la republier si vous désirez.
Ok super, merci Bob !
One of the greatest successes of the Party has been the conflation of national identity and party loyalty.
Vietnam's economy is slowly rising! It's beating some of its neighboring countries.
This demonstrates an apathy and ignorance toward Vietnamese people's continuous struggle for a just society, not to mention the embracing of capitalism, as long as it is draped in a red flag and claims to be against the imperialistic ambitions of “the West,” especially the US, even when all signs show that communism is and was never on the agenda.
Glad to visit this awesome site, great work.
Thanks for sharing this great article.
Glad I was able to read more about Vietnam on this site!
The Soviet Union had no communism, as Emma Goldman pointed out. The same may be said of Vietnam now.
I want to visit vietnam because of this blog.
Hey! This is truly and personally helpful to me and my friends. Thanks a lot!
Vietnam is now in fact a progressive country with very good agricultural advances.
Love this article! Glad I was able to read this. https://rockstar-ride.com/
I don't want to visit vietnam, it's hot there
If there is anything at all you require in the way of epoxy flooring and coatings, you know that this is the place to come --- https://epoxygaragefloorportstlucie.com/
The site was so nice, I found out about a lot of great things. I like the way you make your blog posts. Keep up the good work and may you gain success in the long run.
Fake news are spreading like wild fire. People should always strive for legit and credible sources before believing into malicious and fake news. | https://concretebloomingtonin.com
I believe we already have an update about this article here. People should always read between the lines. | https://southbendconcretecontractors.com/
Evansville Concrete Contractors Co has been serving the local communities of Evansville, IN, for many years. With vast experience, our team of experts understands the intricacies of our work explicitly and are able to perform all services to the highest standard. --- https://evansvilleconcrete.com
We have this so called saying, "Promises are made to be broken", in fact some of its aspects are true, however it would always depend on circumstances and factors affecting its cause. | https://fortwayneconcretecontractors.com
I'm so impressed with the details. Keep it up https://atlanticsigncompany.com/business-signs-cincinnati-ohio/
“A Rats' Revolution” by Diều Hâu. A Vietnamese anarchist critique of the so-called “socialism” of Vietnam. Limo Service Seattle
This is a good read, thanks for writing this article and sharing us great ideas! I appreciate it.
this is a great website and a really great article. thank you for sharing - https://londonconcretecontractor.com/
Great content here. Keep it coming!
The broken promises of vietnam live long in the memory and history continues to repeat itself
Thank you for sharing check my article here https://www.viralgrowthmedia.com/
awesome post thank you for sharing https://arieshemp.com/;
The scars of Vietnam live long in the memory unfortunately
Great! gotta love this!!
Vietnam is really rich in history. Thanks for publishing this article!
Vietnam is one of rising countries of Southeast Asia and I can't wait to see its progress in the future. https://haroclean.com/
I like the fact that you always post the truth on this site which is appreciateed.
I love Vietnam! I had visited the country once. https://changeofaddressnearme.com/
It's sad but life must go on. Let's learn from the past and be inspired to do better in the future.
Vietnam's buried memories. They know they can't escape it and faced those wholeheartedly. A great country rich in history!
I miss Vietnam! Travelled there when I was a teenager. https://www.mattbrandenburg.com/
I appreciate the persistence you put into your blog and the detailed information you provide.
This blog is very nice. I really like such a fantastic written blog. I will keep coming here again and again. Visit my link as well. https://www.tejadosolitenavarra.com/
Hello, I am one of the most impressed people in your article. I'm very curious about how you write such a good article. Are you an expert on this subject? I think so. Thank you again for allowing me to read these posts, and have a nice day today. Thank you. https://fencinghobart.com/
It's heartbreaking, yet life must carry on. Let us learn from history and be motivated to do better in the future. Thank you for sharing this article.
The work I am doing is very hard but articles like this make it much easier. Thank you for doing my research for me.
I haven't any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.
Love the article! https://junkremovalmesa.net
Love the website an knowledge guys. please keep sharing.
What an excellent post. Thanks for sharing! https://teamgarnerrg.com/
Very interesting stuff to read.
Great Work on this article. Thank you for sharing.
Awesome article. Thanks!
Love this! Thank you!
I appreciate you posting such a valuable article. https://plasticsurgerymesa.net
I've been troubled for several days with this topic. But by chance looking at your post solved my problem! I will leave my blog, so when would you like to visit it? https://concretekelowna.com
Awesome article. Very interesting!
Timeless article. Thanks for this!
This is great. Thanks :)
Thanks for the update!
Thanks for the artifcle hopefull no fake news only fake grass
THanks for this article. Hopefully things are better now any more people can freely express themselves
Really great content! Interesting!
Nice article! thanks for sharing the post!
Actually, it's pretty good to see!
Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for letting us know!
Thanks for sharing this to public!
Such a great post!
I visited Your blog and got a massive number of informative articles. I read many articles carefully and got the information that I had been looking for for a long time. Hope you will write such a helpful article in future. Thanks for writing.
Great blog post. Thanks for this!
I really like your take on this topic. Cheers!
good read and good comment section too
Really great. Thanks!