|
Recent articles by Mazen Kamalmaz
Φεντεραλισμa... Jan 13 16 Ο Θεός είναι τ&... Apr 12 15 Sam Harris, New atheism and Islam![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() This is a comment on the Sam Harris - Glenn Greenwald debate about Islam. Sam Harris, New atheism and IslamThis is a comment on the Sam Harris - Glenn Greenwald debate about Islam; see : http://www.samharris.org/blog/category/islam http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/apr/03/sa...nimus I think that the Harris - Greenwald debate missed the main issue of the matter they debated, that is Islam and Muslims. We could agree with the poll quoted by Greenwald, that only 7 % of Muslims are radicals, and religiously devoted. And that the rest (93% of Muslims) are moderate and good. But unfortunately both writers wasted their time arguing about the goodness of this 93%, while I think that the whole issue related only to the other 7%, who neither argued about their "goodness". For Islamists, those 7% of Muslims, they used this debate only to stigmatize ant criticism of their dogmas as racism and bigotry, etc. But I don't think that convinced and devoted Nazi or fascists never exceed 7 % of German or Italian population at any time. And that the remaining 93% were always moderate and good, even when they were used by the ruling 7% to inflict atrocities on others. Being controlled, brainwashed and suppressed themselves, they became tools in the hands of the 7% to suppress and control others. What we saw in Iraq after 2003 and in Syria and Libya after 2012, that this 7% claimed superiority and hegemony over the rest (the 93%) , as self-proclaimed, sole representative of the divine, the sacred. They assume moral and intellectual authority over others, then using this authority, combined with brutal force; to suppress the rest, who couldn't fight back properly. In fact , both Harris and Greenwald are dangerous representatives of their ideas. Harris didn't hide that his atheism is an authoritarian, Euro-centric one; as he called for repressive measures to counter the Islamist fundamentalist threat. In fact , this type of atheism is not new to Middle East or "Islamic" countries, where generations of autocrats and dictators practiced such atheism for a long time now. Not only that any "victory" won by such measures was only a false and transient one, but that this authoritarian atheism has no libertarian content at all, it is just another dogma to support some brutal and harsh dictators.
Greenwald is also a dangerous "friend" of the 93% of Muslims, whose goodness he wishes to prove. By underestimating the threat of the 7% on this good majority, and the potential of using Islam as undisputed justification of the hegemony of this 7% upon the rest of Muslims and upon other minorities and neighbors of Muslim societies, Greewald is not of real help to this 93% he wishes to defend... Finally , it is true that Harris questions (1) that the present situation of Muslim countries could be Euro-centric or even racist, but they are very serious ones, that dismissing them simply as being racist is a lost opportunity for the 93% of Muslims to look thoroughly in their present and try to find deeper answers to such serious questions.... |
Front pageEl Rei està nu. La deriva autoritària de l’estat espanyol Es Ley por la Lucha de Las de Abajo Covid19 Değil Akp19 Yasakları: 14 Maddede Akp19 Krizi [Perú] Crónica de una vacancia anunciada o disputa interburguesa en Perú Nigeria and the Hope of the #EndSARS Protests Aλληλεγγύη στους 51 αντιφασίστες της Θεσσαλονίκης Women under lockdown all around the world Solidarity with the Struggle of North American People! A libertarian socialist view of the capitalist and health crisis in the Americas Para las Clases Populares del Mundo, Pandemia, Crisis, Todos los Tiempos son de Lucha Nossa Concepção De Feminismo Na Perspectiva Do Anarquismo Organizado Frente a la Pandemia Capitalista, Solidaridad entre los Pueblos La force des femmes change le monde The competition between Iran and United States over Iraq Beyond Pension Reforms: Interview on the General Strike in France Comunicado de lanzamiento de la Coordinación Anarquista Latinoamericana (CALA) |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (1 of 1)
Jump To Comment: 1Spot on. Do some YouTube presentations of your well spoken opinions. I'll subscribe, maybe.