Benutzereinstellungen

Neue Veranstaltungshinweise

International

Es wurden keine neuen Veranstaltungshinweise in der letzten Woche veröffentlicht

Kommende Veranstaltungen

International | History of anarchism

Keine kommenden Veranstaltungen veröffentlicht

Review: The International Anarchist Congress Amsterdam (1907)

category international | history of anarchism | review author Thursday July 28, 2011 00:24author by Anarcho Report this post to the editors

This is an impressive addition to anarchist history. The reports, debates and motions of the International Anarchist Congress held between August 24th and 31st 1907 are available for the first time in English. This meeting, held in Amsterdam, attracted the leading lights of the international libertarian movement – Errico Malatesta, Emma Goldman, Pierre Ramus, Christiaan Cornelissen and a host of others (Peter Kropotkin being an notable absentee). A long list of subjects was to be discussed: syndicalism, anti-militarism, the 1905 Russian Revolution, organisation, co-operatives and much more. Most of this is still relevant and so this book is not just for those interested in anarchist history, it is of interest to modern activists. [Nederlands]
antonioli.jpg


Review: The International Anarchist Congress Amsterdam (1907)


This is an impressive addition to anarchist history. The reports, debates and motions of the International Anarchist Congress held between August 24th and 31st 1907 are available for the first time in English. This meeting, held in Amsterdam, attracted the leading lights of the international libertarian movement – Errico Malatesta, Emma Goldman, Pierre Ramus, Christiaan Cornelissen and a host of others (Peter Kropotkin being an notable absentee). A long list of subjects was to be discussed: syndicalism, anti-militarism, the 1905 Russian Revolution, organisation, co-operatives and much more. Most of this is still relevant and so this book is not just for those interested in anarchist history, it is of interest to modern activists.

There is a useful, if at times cryptic, introduction by the editor which puts the congress into context. This is followed by the reports to, discussions in and motions to the Congress in chronological order. This is followed by an account of two syndicalist meetings and an appendix on the recent Russian Revolution. All are of interest. The reports to the congress on the state the anarchist movement in various countries makes interesting reading (not least the lengthy account of the USA anarchist and labour scenes by Max Baginsky and Emma Goldman). Some of these will appear familiar to militants today, for better or worse!

It is a shame, however, that Luigi Fabbri’s report on the Italian anarchist movement is not included. While excited to here that there is "a forthcoming collection of Fabbri’s writings" in which it will be included, its exclusion detracts from claims this book is the full report of the congress.

Then the discussions get going. The one on organisation seems somewhat redundant, as everyone agreed it was necessary ("On this point all the anarchists - Proudhon, Bakunin, those of the Jura Federation, Kropotkin - are in agreement" noted Amédée Dunois (pp. 84-5)). However, while much was discussed (and translated into many languages!), this congress is best remembered for the debate between leading French union militant Pierre Monatte (pp. 108-16) and veteran Italian anarchist militant Errico Malatesta (pp. 121-6) on libertarian attitudes to revolutionary syndicalism.

Monatte used the experience of the French Conféderation Générale du Travail (CGT) to expound the virtues of revolutionary unionism. Malatesta took a much more critical perspective. Although he stressed that "anarchists must enter the workers’ syndicates" Malatesta did not think unions, by themselves, were inherently revolutionary. Thus the need for anarchists to organise both as workers and as anarchists in order "to incite the syndicates to the ideal, guiding them little by little towards the social revolution." (p. 124)

Suffice to say, it is over 100 years since this debate and it fair to say that Malatesta was correct in his critique of syndicalism. For example, few syndicalists today would disagree with Malatesta on the need to turn a general strike into an insurrection and the descent of the CGT and other revolutionary unions into reformism confirmed his fears that unionism "is and always will be a legalitarian, conservative movement with no other goal - at best - than the improvement of working conditions." (p. 122)

Which raises a translation issue. Syndicalism is just the French for (trade) unionism - hence the "revolutionary" qualifier used by CGT militants like Monatte. This became simply syndicalism in other languages. This raises issue of whether syndicalism is better translated as "unionism" in certain places in these debates as at times it appears that Malatesta is discussing unionism rather than syndicalism. Malatesta, to prove an example, proclaims that "even if it is reinforced by the pointless use of the adjective revolutionary, syndicalism" is "a conservative movement" before pointing to "the great North American unions." (p. 122) Surely "unionism" would be more appropriate in that context and others like it? Still, regardless of this quibble, his meaning is clear from the context.

It must also be noted that Malatesta’s talk has been used by both liberal libertarians and Leninists to draw a distinction between syndicalism and anarchism. Previously this exchange was only available in George Woodcock’sThe Anarchist Reader, which did not include Malatesta’s first paragraph which proclaimed "I will only deal here with those areas in which I am in disagreement with" in order to eliminate "pointless repetition." As becomes clear seeing the whole debate and Malatesta’s resolution at the congress, he was not denying the need for unions, class struggle and anarchist participation within the labour movement. Far from it! He was simply critical of the "overly simplistic" conceptions (p. 123) expounded by certain syndicalists and combating those libertarians who were letting themselves "be absorbed by" the labour movement, so replacing the end (anarchism) by the "means" (class struggle). (p126) As his joint resolution with Cornelissen and Vohryzek to the Congress put it:

"the Syndicates [are] organisation fighting in the class war for amelioration of the conditions of labour, and as unions of productive workers which can help in the transformation of capitalist society into Anarchist Communist society... But [it] is the duty of Anarchists to constitute the revolutionary element in those organisations... the Syndicalist movement [is] a powerful means of revolution, but not... a substitute for revolution... [that is] armed insurrection and expropriation by force..." (pp. 132-2)

In short, Malatesta’s position was not anti-syndicalism but rather syndicalism-plus. His opposition to certain elements of syndicalism cannot be used, as has been by Leninists, to suggest a difference between the two. This is confirmed by the debate itself, with Monette stating that syndicalism had "reminded anarchism of its worker origins" while anarchists have "contributed in no small way to dragging" the unions "along the revolutionary path." (p. 108) He also linked syndicalism with the "idea of the proletariat, organised into ‘resistance societies’, being the agent of the social revolution that lay at the heart of the great International Working Men’s Association" [IWMA] along with the "ideas of autonomy and federation" expounded by those who "took sides with Bakunin" and "rose up against the abuse of power by the general council" (p. 110). Malatesta, for his part, stated he had "never stopped... pushing comrades to the path that syndicalists, forgetting a glorious past, call new, but the first anarchists had already established and followed within the international." (p. 122) In this, this vision of anarchist organisations working within the labour movement, he followed his old mentor Bakunin’s lead when argued that the Alliance of Socialist Democracy should be active within the IWMA.

After the discussions at the Congress, the book summarises two private meetings of syndicalist attendees, via an article by Dunois, on international relations between revolutionary unionists. Finally, there is the appendix on the Russian Revolution that gives important accounts of both the Russian Anarchist movement and the events of 1905. Strangely, the last article does not appear to have been written by an anarchist given that it ends by stating "a new form of government will arise" based on "the cooperative, democratic spirit of eighty million peasants, it will doubtless be a government of natural justice and equality"! (p. 270) Still, the accounts of 1905 and the rise of Russian anarchism and debates within it are of interest.

Indeed, some of the accounts of the Russian Anarchist movement have to be read to be believed. Clearly, a very brutal regime provoked extreme resistance and the account is full of comrades assassinating particularly abusive bosses/officials or committing expropriations from the bourgeoisie (for workers on strikes, propaganda, etc.) then getting into gun-battles with the police. More often than not, these are ended by the anarchists shooting themselves to escape capture.

While all very heroic, it does seem a counter-productive approach to producing a revolutionary libertarian workers movement. It goes strike the reader to ask whether the 1917 revolution would not have benefited if those comrades had still been around and had spent the intervening years building a movement. Simply put, Peter Arshinov and Nestor Makhno were imprisoned but after being released from prison both helped deepen the Ukrainian revolution. I cannot help feeling there may be lessons there for those who prefer the glamour of the Black Bloc to the more boring activities of getting our ideas across and organising.

All in all, all those involved in getting this account 1907 Congress available in English should be congratulated. It is an extremely valuable addition to both our understanding of early 20th century anarchism and its debates but it also gives valuable lessons which can enrich our activity now.

The International Anarchist Congress Amsterdam (1907)
Edited by Maurizio Antonioli
Translation and English edition by Nestor McNab
Black Cat Press, Alberta, 2009, £15

Verwandter Link: http://anarchism.pageabode.com/cat/anarcho
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch

International | History of anarchism | en

Fri 07 Oct, 22:11

browse text browse image

textOctober 2014 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online 18:21 Wed 29 Oct by KSL 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 80, October 2014 has just been posted on our site.
You can get to the contents here http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/fn30cz or read the full pdf here http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/m6406g

ksl.jpg imageOctober 2013 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online 20:24 Sat 26 Oct by Kate Sharpley Library 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 76, October 2013 has just been posted on the site.

oldbakunin.jpg imageInternational conference for bicentennial of Mikhail Bakunin 21:20 Fri 08 Mar by Organizing committee of Pryamukhino Readings 2014 0 comments

On May 30, 2014 we will be celebrating 200 years of Mikhail Bakunin (1814 – 1876), a famous activist of the Russian and international revolutionary movement, a social thinker and one of the founders of the international anarchist movement. [Français] [Русский]

textFebruary 2013 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online 22:41 Sat 23 Feb by KSL 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 73, February 2013 has just been posted on the site. You can get to the contents here http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/qrfkm1 or read the full pdf here: http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/g4f5zm.

caferiocoverweb.jpg image"Revolution", by Carlo Cafiero 05:27 Fri 03 Aug by Black Cat Press 2 comments

Black Cat Press is pleased to announce the publication of "Revolution" by Carlo Cafiero for the first time ever in English (indeed nor has it ever been published as a complete volume in the original Italian!). The book brings what is certainly Cafiero's most complete, original work to English-speaking audiences for the first time. It is also an extremely important work in that it is one of the earliest attempts at compiling a complete theoretical view of the revolutionary ideal of anarchist communism. [Italiano] [Nederlands]

textA visit to the Kate Sharpley Library (2012) 20:48 Sat 21 Jul by KSL 0 comments

I’ve just come back from visiting the Kate Sharpley Library in California. Things have changed from the days when I could get there on the bus and we were buying our first filing cabinet. Lots of filing cabinets now, as well as boxes like the Left Bank Books archive. It’s good to look at the non-fiction shelves, seeing ‘old friends’ and new acquisitions.

ksl.jpg imageJuly 2012 Kate Sharpley Library bulletin (double issue) now online 18:02 Fri 20 Jul by Kate Sharpley LIbrary 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 70-71, July 2012 [Double issue] has just been posted on the site. You can get to the contents or read the full pdf too.

iron_column.jpg imageOctober 2011 Kate Sharpley Library bulletin online 18:37 Sat 05 Nov by Kate Sharpley Library 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 68, October 2011 has just been posted on the site.

cover2.jpg imageAnarchism and Syndicalism in the Colonial and Postcolonial World, 1870-1940 14:30 Sat 15 Jan by Steven Hirsch and Lucien van der Walt 0 comments

Narratives of anarchist and syndicalist history during the era of the first globalization and imperialism (1870-1930) have overwhelmingly been constructed around a Western European tradition centered on discrete national cases. This parochial perspective typically ignores transnational connections and the contemporaneous existence of large and influential libertarian movements in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and Eastern Europe. Yet anarchism and syndicalism, from their very inception at the First International, were conceived and developed as international movements. By focusing on the neglected cases of the colonial and postcolonial world, this volume underscores the worldwide dimension of these movements and their centrality in anti-colonial and anti-imperialist struggles. Drawing on in-depth historical analyses of the ideology, structure, and praxis of anarchism/syndicalism, it also provides fresh perspectives and lessons for those interested in understanding their resurgence today.

archivesmall.jpg imageNestor Makhno Archive - update 21:29 Wed 07 Apr by Nestor McNab 0 comments

The Nestor Makhno Archive has now been updated, with the addition of over 70 new documents in Arabic, Bulgarian, Croatian, Czech, English, French, Greek, Hungarian, Italian, Macedonian, Russian, Spanish and Ukrainian.

more >>

imageTaking the Mick: Bakunin in the 21st Century Jul 11 by LAMA 2 comments

A short introduction to some of the basic ideas of Bakunin and their relevance in the 21st Century.

imageThe First International and the Development of Anarchism and Marxism Jun 11 by Wayne Price 4 comments

There are recent histories of the First International researched from anarchist perspectives, which balance the dominant Marxist narrative. Both sides had their strengths and weaknesses, but overall the anarchists had the better program.

imageJames Guillaume (1844-1916) & the birth of syndicalism, anarchist communism May 29 by Lucien van der Walt 2 comments

From Mother Earth volume 12, number 1, March 1917: OBITUARY : James Guillaume (1844-1916

imageBridges between anarchism and democratic confederalism – 2 Apr 04 by BrunoL 0 comments

Introduction to this particular issue, April 2nd Bruno Lima Rocha

In this part I will expose some basic historical information about the anarchist political organization model and in the end, make a comparison between these experiences and the nowadays mission of the political organization that intends to be the catalyst of a Democratic Confederalist social change. [Italiano]

imageThe Life of Bakunin: anti-imperialism, anti-capitalism, anti-statism Jun 01 by SAASHA 0 comments

We do not see Bakunin as a god who never made mistakes. Of course he was not perfect. was a man, but a man who gave his all for the struggle of the oppressed, a revolutionary hero who deserves our admiration and respect. “From Bakunin, we can learn much about revolutionary activism. We can learn even more about the ideas needed to win the age-old fight between exploiter and exploited, between worker and peasant, on the one hand, and boss and ruler on the other. The greatest honor we can do his memory is to fight today and always for human freedom and workers liberation.”

more >>

textOctober 2014 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online Oct 29 Kate Sharpley Library 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 80, October 2014 has just been posted on our site.
You can get to the contents here http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/fn30cz or read the full pdf here http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/m6406g

imageOctober 2013 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online Oct 26 KSL 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 76, October 2013 has just been posted on the site.

textFebruary 2013 Kate Sharpley Library Bulletin online Feb 23 Kate Sharpley Library 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 73, February 2013 has just been posted on the site. You can get to the contents here http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/qrfkm1 or read the full pdf here: http://www.katesharpleylibrary.net/g4f5zm.

imageJuly 2012 Kate Sharpley Library bulletin (double issue) now online Jul 20 KSL 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 70-71, July 2012 [Double issue] has just been posted on the site. You can get to the contents or read the full pdf too.

imageOctober 2011 Kate Sharpley Library bulletin online Nov 05 KSL 0 comments

KSL: Bulletin of the Kate Sharpley Library No. 68, October 2011 has just been posted on the site.

more >>
© 2005-2022 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]