France at a Crossroads 06:59 Jan 16 1 comments Apoyo a los y las Trabajadoras de los Servicios Públicos en Rosario (Argentina) 01:37 Dec 31 0 comments Labor in the age of Duterte: The Pacific Plaza strike 00:20 Mar 14 0 comments The Google Walkout: An International Working-Class Movement 18:55 Nov 05 1 comments [South Africa] Stop the repression of casualised/contract workers in Ekurhuleni! 07:27 Sep 29 0 comments more >> |
Recent articles by Laure Akai
Κατάληψη εργ ... 0 comments FagorMastercook Unionists Repressed. Workers Ready to Strike 1 comments Shut Down EU Migrant Hunters! 0 comments Recent Articles about Poland / Czech / Slovakia Workplace strugglesLa Polonia abolisce la giornata lavorativa di 8 ore Jun 17 13 Poland does away with the 8-hour day Jun 16 13 Solidarecon kun la anarkisindikatistaj gekamaradoj de IP Pollando Jul 11 12 In Defense of the Polish Miners
poland / czech / slovakia |
workplace struggles |
opinion / analysis
Thursday July 28, 2005 02:56 by Laure Akai - FA Praga cube at zigzag dot pl
Miners fight to defend retirement rights Why the rioting miners in Warsaw were not only justified in their demands but they actually were asking for way too little. On July 26, about 8000 miners descended upon Warsaw. This was the largest protests the miners had had since 2003 when they brought riots to the city. In Defense of the MinersOn July 26, about 8000 miners descended upon Warsaw. They had come to the Sejm, the Polish parliament, to protest reforms in retirement rules which allow them to retire after 25 years of work. A number of unions organized for the protest, which was the largest the miners had had since 2003 when they brought riots to the city. The miners, who have long been at the forefront of the labor movement, unfortunately have become victims of much interclass antagonism. The media has portrayed them as drunk, volatile elements who use violence to force unreasonable demands down people's throats. If some years ago workers from other sections of the economy (and other regions of the country) largely sympathized with the miners, nowadays, a disturbingly large segment of the population have begun to parrot the government line: that mines are unprofitable, that miners are overpaid, have unreasonable privileges and are, in essence, a burden on the economy. In other words, other workers have begun to feel like they are subsidizing the miners' free ride. In fact, the case looks very much different. The coal market is booming. Some years ago, coal sold for 20 dollars a ton - now it sells for over 60. (1) Demand, both local and for export, is high due to the increased construction and production in Poland and the huge Chinese market. And the coal companies, most of which have not been privatized (2), are reaping record profits. So much in fact that even their very optimistic profit forecasts were exceeded. (3) Of course business people would argue that 40% of the labor force had to be downsized over the last 10 years to achieve this. (4) And many more redundancies are expected in the future. And while it is true that the coal market is cyclical, forecasts predict good times for the coal industry for some years to come. (See KW's 2007 forecast below.) Back to the miners, there are theoretically other options to early retirement, like career changes after some years but unfortunately there are no other jobs on the market in their region - or at least no jobs they could fill without retraining. This would require a social commitment and a more vigorous rejection of age discrimination. However, tendencies in the job market are towards hiring younger, cheaper workers, even in skilled jobs and the government created employment programs which allow employers to circumvent many social costs and pay lower wages to first-time job seekers. To the miners, it may seem that other alternative employment is a distant dream. In fact, we may suppose that if other employment were readily available, fewer people might even choose to be miners without special incentives. What the people forget about when complaining about the uppity miners are the categories of other workers which have early retirement benefits. Such as the police. Or soldiers. (Allowed to retire after 15 years and with generous housing, health and retraining allowances.) Even many civil servants may retire early. I have more sympathy with the miners. When confronted with these facts, people's moods seem to change. People sometimes change their tone and become more sympathetic, although, still thinking that their tax money pays for all this, the resentment cannot help but triumph. The mood set by the media machine is hard to overcome. But the question we should be asking is not why we should pay for early retirement or not, but why aren't the miners in charge of the profits of this industry? If the mines were run by collectives of miners, excess profits could be sent to a fund to cover early retirement expenses. Right now, much of he industry's wealth goes not towards wages but to the state, to paying back the state's debts, and, as is typical with state controlled companies, into a vortex of sorts. Individual theft of state resources and gross mismanagement continue to be a huge problem. Not that they would be any better off if the industry were privatized. Then the miners would be working for company profits, for the bosses and shareholders. In coal (and in steel) even a relatively modest shareholder can earn enough money on the profits of this industry to allow himself an early retirement. It's exactly these shareholders, including, ironically, many people's pension funds, that force more and more rationalization schemes that hurt the miners economically in order to give more profit for the shareholders. Of course we rarely hear miners on TV complaining that the money sucked out of mining companies has meant that their labor is paying for the retirement nest eggs of tens of thousands of others. This is part of the horror of investment capitalism; that the better or more secure financial future of workers with capital to spare and pension schemes is ensured by firing people, pushing costs down and maximizing corporate profits. It is a vicious circle that only can be broken by abolishing such investment, by taking the profit motive out of industry. And in all this financial shuffling, whether by private capitalists or state ones, it's the miners whose production value is being controlled on their behalf but not in their interests. It's time not to think about getting more value out of the miners by making them work longer, but about getting rid of the state and capitalist vampires that suck the life blood out of all of us. When the people control things, either coal production will by cut as we find alternatives to and reject current production models or a much wider segment of the population will take turns working in the mines and nobody will work there for more than a few months. No more subproletariats doing all the shit work and reaping few of the benefits. The yuppie workers in their steel skyscrapers forget that without miners, farmers, factory workers, none of their shitty money counts for anything. It's time to get over the illusions of the skilled and educated workers that the lowly miner needs to accept more humble working conditions. On the contrary, all of us workers not only deserve, but we can do much better for ourselves. Laure Akai Videos of miners' riot in Warsaw: http://wiadomosci.onet.pl/7988,film.rd http://wiadomosci.onet.pl/7980,film.rd (1) Different sorts of coal have different prices and a lot depends of the end user. One company sells for over 150 dollars a ton to retail customers. (2) Although there are some private mines, most coal mines are part of 7 companies owned by the State Treasury. They hope to consolidate these into two companies to be privatized in full. (3) One example, KHW, which has 7 mines, exceeded their forecasts by 30% in the first 6 months of 2005, earning gross profits of 86.4 million zl. (29 million dollars). Kompania Weglowa (KW) which is the largest coal company in the EU, also made healthy profits. Their net profits (sorry, no figure for gross) were 121.9 million zl.(over 40 million dollars) in the first five months of 2005. Last week the state transferred stock and cash to them for a capital increase of 900 million zl. (300 million dollars). KW has set a target of 1 billion zl. net profit for 2007, almost 400% percent higher than what they forecast by the end of this year. (KW financial statement, 22.07. 2005 http://www.kwsa.pl/index.php?m=9&ind=74) (4) The World Bank of course was involved in the restructuring process. In 2004 alone, the state took $300,000 million dollars from the World Bank to restructure the coal industry. Poland owes the World Bank 5.9 billion dollars. The cost of coal restructuring - between 2 and 4 billion dollars. |
Front pageSupport Sudanese anarchists in exile Joint Statement of European Anarchist Organizations International anarchist call for solidarity: Earthquake in Turkey, Syria and Kurdistan Elements of Anarchist Theory and Strategy 19 de Julio: Cuando el pueblo se levanta, escribe la historia International anarchist solidarity against Turkish state repression Declaración Anarquista Internacional por el Primero de Mayo, 2022 Le vieux monde opprime les femmes et les minorités de genre. Leur force le détruira ! Against Militarism and War: For self-organised struggle and social revolution Declaração anarquista internacional sobre a pandemia da Covid-19 Anarchist Theory and History in Global Perspective Capitalism, Anti-Capitalism and Popular Organisation [Booklet] Reflexiones sobre la situación de Afganistán South Africa: Historic rupture or warring brothers again? Death or Renewal: Is the Climate Crisis the Final Crisis? Gleichheit und Freiheit stehen nicht zur Debatte! Contre la guerre au Kurdistan irakien, contre la traîtrise du PDK Meurtre de Clément Méric : l’enjeu politique du procès en appel |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (1 of 1)
Jump To Comment: 1I just wanted to add that the government has agreed to extend the miners' early retirement.
I think in this case, it goes to show that being organized and behaving badly can be effective.
:-)