Ghost of apartheid haunts George - PW Botha's town
southern africa |
opinion / analysis
Monday February 19, 2007 14:42 by Michael Schmidt
PW Botha's town still carries the baggage of the system he fought so vigorously to preserve, writes Michael Schmidt (Cape Argus, Cape Town, November 5, 2006)
Ghost of apartheid haunts George: PW Botha's town still carries the baggage of the system he fought so vigorously to preserve, writes Michael Schmidt
Pieter Willem Botha lies as cold and dead on the mortuary slab as Stephen Bantu Biko did in the back of a police van almost 30 years ago.
The Groot Krokodil, whose vice-like bite struck fear into so many hearts, evaporated into the night on Halloween like a wraith of mist on the Outeniqua Pass.
The nation is now at loggerheads over how his legacy should be assessed.
The comparison with Biko is partly unfair because PW Botha only ascended the pinnacle of racist rule in 1978, a year after the Black Consciousness leader had been murdered.
And yet, while Botha merely inherited apartheid's polarised world view, he alone transformed it into a death-star, giving it a baptism of fire that arguably even Nazi-sympathising nationalist Daniel Francois Malan had not foreseen.
Unfairly or not, Botha for much of the world embodied the final phase of white resistance to the "total onslaught" of democracy more than any other white Nationalist leader.
Malan, who had once told parliament that national socialism was the wave of the future, was followed by Johannes Gerhardus Strijdom whose regime removed coloureds from the voters roll and unsuccessfully prosecuted liberation movement leaders who signed the 1955 Freedom Charter.
Hendrik Frensch Verwoerd, the acknowledged architect of grand apartheid - its petty version having been introduced by the British - succeeded Strijdom.
Having banned the liberation movements after the Sharpeville Massacre, Verwoerd was, in a denouement worthy of Shakespeare, assassinated by the ultimately sane Dimitri Tsafendas, a quintessential South African "person of mixed race", the true common denominator that links us, in the year of my birth.
Verwoerd was followed by the descent into darkness that was Balthazar Johannes Vorster. Also pro-Nazi, Vorster lies buried under a large black marble slab in "heroes' acre" in the remote Eastern Cape town of Kareedouw, at the foot of the Langkloof.
As late as 2002, the Kareedouw hospital still treated black and white patients at separate entrances, and despite the fact that it had a black, ANC-dominated town council, erected its new black housing development with a 200m gap between it and its nearest white neighbours.
This is the shocking continuity, under the ANC, of the physical, economic structure of "separate development" that allowed right-wing American writer PJ O'Rourke in his Holidays in Hell to describe the country as "a place of evil and perdition," propped up by whites who found it normal to throw their cigarettes on the lawn - because there would always be someone darker to pick them up.
Botha, the alleged harbinger of the end of apartheid - a mantle and Nobel Prize assumed by his successor, Frederik Willem de Klerk - was, in fact, forced into adapting what he once called a mere corollary of "good neighbourliness" to changed circumstance.
Official apartheid was painted into a corner by a combination of the collapse of the bipolar Cold War order; the inability of the colour bar to create a skilled black workforce with sufficient purchasing power to afford its own products; and the effects of the nationwide insurgency.
But a cynic would say the white nationalists only surrendered power to the black nationalists once the physical barriers that ensured that privilege would remain secure in its laager were unassailable.
Kareedouw points to this being true and shows how, as one township resident tells me, the ghost of Vorster still haunts its hills.
Is the same true of George, Botha's former stamping-ground, the place where he built his reputation as a thug who broke up Union Party meetings - in much the same way as a young Nelson Mandela was blooding himself at the expense of the Communist Party?
Botha was our Pinochet. An early supporter of the pro-Nazi Ossewa Brandwag who later turned to the uniquely South African version of fascism called Christian nationalism, he forged an already anti-democratic South Africa into a military dictatorship along Francoist lines.
If former law and order minister Adriaan Vlok's statements to the Mail & Guardian this year are true, Botha issued personal, private orders to chosen individuals from within the State Security Council.
This suggests that beyond his obvious responsibility for the nuclear weapons programme and numerous cross-border raids into neighbouring countries, Botha was personally responsible, like his Chilean counterpart, for the "disappearance" of perhaps hundreds of anti-apartheid activists in South Africa and abroad.
Among them are the estimated 200 Swapo detainees murdered in cold blood and dumped, Chilean-fashion, from an aircraft into the ocean.
This also suggests that the man also nicknamed Pieter Wapen, remained, like Pinochet in his dotage, beyond the reach of the law he so regularly flouted.
Gerald L'Ange describes Botha, in his seminal study The White Africans as someone who did not see himself as others did, "a vain bully whose sense of self-importance ballooned in the thin air of the highest officeÂ…"
For all his steeliness, Botha had a capacity for seeing immediate issues realistically, and he attempted - though seldom with much finesse - to deal with them pragmatically.
Despite his rearguard initiation of limited reforms like the scrapping of petty apartheid, driven it seems as much by a strangely sentimental attachment to the coloured people as by his kragdadigheid, it is for his single-mindedness and aggression that he will probably be best remembered.
But Botha was unceremoniously unseated by De Klerk in 1989 after having suffered a stroke.
Until the end, he was deeply bitter that his vision of ending apartheid - on his terms and doubtless with a permanent sunset clause for whites - lay in tatters.
Botha in retirement seemed toothless, less of a crocodile and more like the vanishing Knysna elephant he apparently once saw, looming large over the landscape one minute, then vanishing into the scenery as if never there.
But in death, his ghost still haunts the Outeniqua Mountains and its backlands like the legendary, spectral hitch-hiker on the Uniondale road.
His former constituency as a belligerent young MP is a weird mixture of retired old-school English-speaking CEOs, back-packing neo-hippies, bulky young Afrikaans aluminium-siding salesmen, and inbred backwoods folk straight out of Kringe in die Bos.
Here you will encounter both cheerful and helpful coloured municipal staff and will o' the wisp rumours of shadowy groups in nearby Sedgefield who continue to celebrate Adolf Hitler's birthday each April 20.
Despite the new roads and new licks of paint evident in the black township of Thembelihle and the coloured township of Pacaltsdorp, they remain racially distinct "locations", separated from each other by a deep ravine and from mostly white George by the N2.
These divisions are an entrenched feature of the South African landscape, despite all the hubris about national unity.
Rian Malan in My Traitor's Heart tellingly explains how the Nederduitse Gereformeerde dopper movement got its name from the tin cap that was used to put out a candle, a metaphor for the doppers' reflex to extinguish the illumination of the Enlightenment, plunging the world into darkness again.
With national flags flying at half-mast, it is hard to guess whether this week, Thabo Mvuyelwa Mbeki will come to George to bury Botha or to praise him.
With race-classification still legal and the geographical bulwarks of apartheid barely eroded, as mourners sing Botha to his rest amid the reek of polished piety in the Nederduitse Gereformeerde mother-church, it will be far from clear which will prevail: the daylight or the ghosts.
Our History of Struggle: the 1980s “Workerist-Populist” Debate Revisited Dec 09 0 comments
Today the terms “populism” and “workerism” are widely thrown about in South African political circles. Often, these terms and others (“syndicalism,” “ultra-left,” “counter-revolutionary,” “anti-majoritarian” …) have no meaning: they are just labels used to silence critics. SA Communist Party (SACP) leaders do this often. But in the 1980s, “populism” and “workerism” referred to two rival positions battling for the soul of the militant unions.
These debates, thirty years on, remain very relevant: let us revisit them, and learn. Today’s radical National Union of Metalworkers of SA (NUMSA) was part of the “workerist” camp, while its key rival, the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) was identified with “populism.” The early battles over the direction of the Congress of SA Trade Unions (COSATU) still echo today, although there is no longer a clear “workerist” camp.
The 1976 Struggle and the Emancipation of the Future Dec 06 0 comments
The massacre of South African school children in 1976 – for protesting for instruction in their native languages and for a proper curriculum – continues to be remembered and to influence us today. It showed the brutality of the apartheid state and it left scars still felt by people today.
The challenges faced by youth today are different to that experienced in 1976. This does not mean everything has changed. We need to look to history to learn about and not to repeat mistakes made. But we also look to history to provide us with inspiration. We need to revisit the spirit of the youth of 1976 and copy their courage – to overcome these issues facing our young people today. We need to be the change that we want to see.
Anti-militarist United Fronts and Italy’s “Red week”, 1914 Sep 03 0 comments
The United Front tactic – aimed at uniting masses of workers in action and winning Communist leadership for the working class – was adopted as policy by the Communist International (Comintern) in 1921 and will be discussed later in this series. However, there are important examples of working class unity in action which predate Comintern policy and bear relevance to the united fronts discussion. One often-cited example is the united front to defend the gains of the February Revolution from a military coup in Russia in 1917, which will be discussed in the next article in this series.
Before looking at this, however, there is another example of proletarian unity in action – that didn’t seek to win Communist leadership – which warrants attention; that of a revolutionary worker-peasant alliance. This conception of united front action found expression in Italy’s anti-militarist “red blocs” and it is to these that we now turn.
First published in issue 87 of Workers World News
• Part 1: NUMSA and the ‘United Front Against Neoliberalism’
• Part 3: The 1917 Russian Revolution and United Front
• Part 4: United Working Class Action and the Workers’ Council Movement in Germany, 1920-1923
Remembering and Learning from the Past: The 1976 Uprising and the African Working Class Jun 17 0 comments
This year  marks the 30th anniversary of the 1976 Soweto uprising in South Africa, which marked the start of the fall of apartheid, and inspired activists worldwide. African working youth played a leading role, and their sacrifices showed us that ordinary people can make a difference to the injustices of our world. Revolutionaries should commemorate this struggle, but also learn from its failings.
Get Rich or Lie Trying: Why ANC Millionaire Julius Malema posed as a Radical Mar 06 0 comments
This article aims to explain, from an anarchist / syndicalist perspective, the rapid rise and fall of Julius Malema, the controversial and corrupt multi-millionaire leader of South Africa’s ruling party, the African National Congress’s (ANC’s) “youth league” (ANCYL). It is demonstrated that Malema’s posturing as radical champion of the black poor was simply a means to an end: rising higher in the ranks of the ANC, in order to access bigger state tenders and higher paying political office.
The larger political implications of the Malema affair are also considered, especially the role of the ANC – as a vehicle for the accumulation of wealth and power by the rising black elite, which is centred on the state.
CPSA veteran Alan Lipman's biography online Apr 10 allied to ZACF (southern Africa) 0 comments
The Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Federation (ZACF) of southern Africa is proud to present an online version of Alan Lipman's autobiography.