South Africa: Workers Face the Backlash from Farmers 17:43 May 06 0 comments
Colombia: Represión armada contra corteros del ingenio La Cabaña 05:08 Mar 18 0 comments
El voluntariado en el ámbito social 19:04 Mar 16 0 comments
Aumenta la represión sindical en la Universidad Carlos III de Madrid 02:27 Mar 01 0 comments
Solidarity For Garment Worker Leo Vedél! 23:51 Feb 15 0 commentsmore >>
Recent articles by Alan McSimoin
Historia del movimiento anarquista coreano 0 commentsRecent Articles about North America / Mexico Workplace struggles
Which way forward for Ontario teachers? Mar 20 13
Focus on precarity - Change To Win (USA)
north america / mexico | workplace struggles | opinion / analysis Tuesday January 16, 2007 17:34 by Alan McSimoin - WSM - Red & Black Revolution 11
Last September saw a split in the USA’s Congress of Trade Unions, the AFL-CIO. The Change to Win Federation held its founding convention in St. Louis, Missouri, where they set out their plans: cut down on bureaucracy, devote a lot more resources to organising the unorganised, and start building industry-wide super-unions.
The seven founding unions were the Teamsters (a general union and the USA’s biggest), the Building Labourers, Service Employees (third biggest in the USA), UNITE-HERE (clothing and restaurant workers), Farmworkers, Food workers, and the Carpenters. Together they made up about 35% of the AFL-CIO's members.
Literally from day one, we could see this was not going to be some radical break from the undemocratic practices of the AFL-CIO. There was no membership vote over affiliation to this new federation, the handful of people on each union executive took the decision themselves.
So, is this new formation simply an attempt by a few discontented senior union leaders to increase their power or do they have ideas that merit serious consideration? Most of their literature has been long on describing the problems faced by working people, but short on offering solutions.
Well, there are very real problems in the US trade union movement. Whether you are a radical or a conservative, you can’t avoid the fact that the percentage of American workers in a union has dropped to an all-time low of about 12%. And that’s an open invitation to the bosses to stick the boot in, an invitation the bosses have been more than happy to accept.
“We are focusing our resources on organising tens of millions of workers who are without union representation. We are shifting our resources into organising”, said Anna Burger, Change to Win Chair. Indeed the federation has put it like this:
Among their proposals to achieve these objectives are encouraging unions to organize on an industry- wide basis, merging smaller unions into a few large unions, and spending more money on organising as opposed to electoral politics.
All well and good, but unions have to be seen to do more than merely hold the line against employer demands for cutbacks. They need to actually spearhead a fight for higher wages, more job security, better healthcare, shorter hours and improved pensions. There has to be a sense that we are going forward, that any sacrifices or risks we are asked to take will be worth it.
Just as important, even a brief look at labour history suggests that ideas, politics, and grassroots worker involvement are far more important than changes in organisational structures in the recipe for reviving union strength.
There are no shortcuts to rebuilding our movement, and that it will take far more than a few mergers or spending more on recruitment to produce the reversal in union fortunes that so many of us desire. After all, that’s what has been done here by SIPTU and IMPACT, to name but two of our own big unions which were formed through mergers.
This is not to say that the heads of the new federation are “sell-outs”, “traitors” or any of the other silly names that sometimes get thrown at union leaders. By and large they represent the general ideas of the members who elected them. When most workers see no alternative to the conservative political parties, let alone to capitalism, we should not be surprised that our unions are not some sort of revolutionary movement.
What is needed is not “better leaders”. We are not sheep who simply require a better or more farsighted shepherd. Real change necessitates the active participation of a lot of people.
All over the world we need to convince our work colleagues and fellow union members that a militant fight for workers’ interests is a good thing, that ordinary member involvement and control of our unions is a good thing, that a fundamental change in the way society is ordered is possible.
In our unions, whether in the USA or Ireland, experience suggests that we need a programme that puts far greater weight on political and social change, rank-and-file education and empowerment, and a commitment to reinvigorating collective bargaining as well as rebuilding membership. This was the experience of Connolly and Larkin, of the US Congress of Industrial Organisations in the 1930s, and of every large-scale union movement since.
This article is from Red and Black Revolution 11, published October 2006
Read all the issues of Red and Black Revolution at http://www.wsm.ie/rbr
Mon 20 May, 15:45
Anarchists and Wobblies Support Striking Refuelers at Toronto Island Airport 21:33 Wed 27 Feb 0 comments
Report From Right To Work for Less Protest in Michigan 03:00 Sat 22 Dec 0 comments
Solidarity Callout - Domino's Pizza Drivers Dispute 11:59 Mon 27 Aug 3 comments
Arizona set to abolish public unions 18:40 Mon 06 Feb 0 comments
Workers Solidarity Alliance - On Labor Day 22:15 Sat 03 Sep 0 comments
Unfazed by near tie, Jimmy John’s Workers vow to continue campaign 18:20 Sat 23 Oct 0 comments
Construction strike in Quebec? 19:24 Fri 27 Aug 0 comments
Teachers of Miami-Dade County Call: 11:33 Sat 10 Apr 1 comments
25 Dead in West Virginia Mining Disaster 05:08 Fri 09 Apr 0 comments
Warehouse Workers Shut Down Walmart Warehouse in San Bernardino County 04:45 Sun 24 May 3 commentsmore >>
Which way forward for Ontario teachers? Mar 20 0 comments
Moving to Action Sep 07 0 comments
Union Leadership Stands in the way of Workers in Wisconsin Apr 24 1 comments
Wisconsin: Why a general strike hasn't happened yet... Apr 04 2 commentsmore >>
Solidarity Callout - Domino's Pizza Drivers Dispute Aug 27 3 comments
Workers Solidarity Alliance - On Labor Day Sep 03 W.S.A. 0 comments
Unfazed by near tie, Jimmy John’s Workers vow to continue campaign Oct 23 Industrial Workers of the World 0 comments
Teachers of Miami-Dade County Call: Apr 10 1 comments
Warehouse Workers Shut Down Walmart Warehouse in San Bernardino County May 24 WSA (personal capacity) 3 commentsmore >>