Agenda for the Global South After COVID-19 03:34 Jun 28 1 comments Another Sanders Betrayal 23:08 Apr 15 5 comments Contradictions of Post-Soviet Ukraine and the New Left 04:54 Mar 11 2 comments An inevitable division: the politics and consequences of the Labour split 18:03 Feb 27 0 comments La ofensiva contra el chavismo fracasó. No pudieron y no pasaron 04:16 Feb 27 1 comments more >> |
Recent articles by Eric
This author has not submitted any other articles.
Recent Articles about North America / Mexico The LeftThe Right’s Fantasy of a “Marxist” Threat Feb 14 22 Did the System Work? Aftermath of the 2020 Election Dec 30 20 Another Sanders Betrayal Apr 15 20 Brad Will death and Racism in the North
north america / mexico |
the left |
non-anarchist press
Tuesday October 31, 2006 06:01 by Eric
How White Privilege Teaches Us to Value Certain Lives Over Others This past Friday, October 27, 2006, at least five unarmed people were killed on the streets of Oaxaca City, Oaxaca. One of them happened to be a young, white, male, American anarchist, working for the radical media outlet “indymedia.org” named Brad Will. Now it is no surprise that the Corporate American media would jump on a story where any American is shot dead in the streets of a third world country, but that same mentality has trickled down across leftist/independent news resources like those of infoshop.org, indymedia.org, Democracynow.org, and others, to the point where the popular struggle in the streets of Oaxaca, is only a legitimate struggle now that Brad Will was killed. This Brings up many interesting questions of how the radical left in the United States views itself in the context of a global struggle. I’m not going to pretend to understand, or have lived the struggle that people of color, especially Blacks and Latinos, go through in this country, as I am myself, a white American. However, we have some real issues of racism within our movement that must be confronted in our everyday lives and in our organizing that many have witnessed this past weekend. |
Front pageSupport Sudanese anarchists in exile Joint Statement of European Anarchist Organizations International anarchist call for solidarity: Earthquake in Turkey, Syria and Kurdistan Elements of Anarchist Theory and Strategy 19 de Julio: Cuando el pueblo se levanta, escribe la historia International anarchist solidarity against Turkish state repression Declaración Anarquista Internacional por el Primero de Mayo, 2022 Le vieux monde opprime les femmes et les minorités de genre. Leur force le détruira ! Against Militarism and War: For self-organised struggle and social revolution Declaração anarquista internacional sobre a pandemia da Covid-19 Anarchist Theory and History in Global Perspective Capitalism, Anti-Capitalism and Popular Organisation [Booklet] Reflexiones sobre la situación de Afganistán South Africa: Historic rupture or warring brothers again? Death or Renewal: Is the Climate Crisis the Final Crisis? Gleichheit und Freiheit stehen nicht zur Debatte! Contre la guerre au Kurdistan irakien, contre la traîtrise du PDK Meurtre de Clément Méric : l’enjeu politique du procès en appel |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (9 of 9)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9I agree with your article about racist america. i am a person of color who has met brad from activism and i am very sorry to hear of his death. i want to go to the demostrations and peace rallies on his behalf but all of the participants are white. one hundred percent white. how can this be, the segretation of a movement but it exists here in new york in seperate movements.
I'm sure you enjoyed typing your radicaler-than-thou critique, but you earn no points. Yes, there is a problem with white supremacy and patriarchy and all the rest within American activists (of all identities) that need to be rooted out; we are products of our culture after all.
But your critique holds little water.
First, the demands of the protests have called into question the situation in Oaxaca. Specifically, New York activists have explicitly pushed to expand this past a white american human interest story and to trumpet the demands of the people of Oaxaca. While not all of us are experts on Oaxaca, some of our community have been doing support work and a handful have traveled back and forth to film and spread the story of the struggle long before Brad's murder. Please don't mistake the corporate press for who should be your allies. The rest of us weren't just toasting our privilege: there happens to be only so many hours in a day and we're trying to bring down a global system of exploitation and there is a lot of work to be done on a number of issues. We didn't include the pictures of the other people because we didn't have pictures of all the other people killed, but we did have their names and we trumpeted their names in the protest.
Second, and most important, we did have pictures of Brad because he was our member of our community and while perhaps, in your strident analysis, you think that the hundreds of people out there protesting today in new york simply sent Brad through the old identity value machine and saw that it spit back "valuable because white male", your strawman is weak. Brad was killed on, what, Friday? It's Monday: people are mourning the loss of their friend and a member of their community. People are in grief and while the pictures captured a lot of vibrancy and excitement, I saw numerous people bawling outside the consulate today. These aren't "random activists;" The people protesting today had lived with, worked with, fought with, sang with, loved with, smoked with, and pushed struggle with Brad for the last decade.
Please, save your critiques. Note that I don't say discard; I say save. We need to talk about white supremacy in activist culture, but don't shotgun the mourning process with your boilerplate critique. It doesn't do your criticism any justice and, in a time of mourning and grief, that is in the shortest supply.
This story maybe an attempt to earn points from fellow anarchists; however, it still holds true. To the person who wrote about he and his friends being in mourning and should thus be respected - immune from any criticism , I say with all due respect to the life, family and friends of Brad Will, if he was not willing to risk his in Oaxaca, he shouldn't of been there. As a Mexican here in the US, I've been disgusted by the fact that both Mexican and US media outlets have focused their almost exclusive attention on Brad Will's death. If he was a revolutionary, if you are a revolutionary, you should be celebrating his life not mourning it. Another point that struck me was that if Brad Will had been killed in NYC, say while he and his group were being evicted, the same corporate media entities would of not given a *f*. To them he was a dirty hippie, but somehow while amongst Mexicans, he is "one of us" and given all the rights and prevlidges of a White American.
You may take this as disrespect to you and your friend, but again, if you're truly revolutionary you'd be honored to give your life in the service of a noble cause. If you're not, don't go to Oaxaca, don't put your life at risk trying to save us - focus on saving yourselves.
¡Fuerza y Animo al Pueblo Digno de Oaxaca!
Chepe
xe_cs@yahoo.com
i absolutely agree that it's important to bring a critique of white supremacy into any struggle, especially an anarchist one. we should always be trying to unpack the complexities of this murderous bullshit we're facing, in order to more effectively confront and destroy it, right?
but i don't think this little article went deep enough at all. excuse me if i'm getting spiteful because i'm in new york and have been close to the grieving and action around here, but i don't think it's fair at all to take an image presented by the corporate media--"gringo killed in mexico! egads!"--and project it onto any action that people in the north take hereafter in solidarity with folks in oaxaca.
keep in mind that in nyc, just as folks were starting to reel from the impact of their friend getting shot, Fox used the latest murders as a pretext to storm Oaxaca with thousands of federal riot police. so not only had a close companero been killed, but now that death, and its presentation by corporate media, was being used to support further repression. what to do?
a big part of the conversation around actions in nyc focused on how to bring attention to the situation in Oaxaca by akido-ing all the attention focused on Brad's death. with banner drops, lockdowns, and traffic-blocking, folks put their bodies on the line to say that Brad wasn't "caught in the crossfire" of dangerous, dark-skinned, leftist violence--rather, he died supporting a struggle that we also support, that of people's resistance in Oaxaca. and we said as much in our list of demands--which echoed those of the APPO--our calls to action, and our distributed literature.
so, aside from acting out of grief over the death of one of their own, radicals in nyc were also taking a situation presented them by bullshit, white-supremacist power structures--Brad Will's death as an indication of the need to "restore order"--and turning it into action against those structures--"Brad and others died supporting these struggles; let's support them too!" it's not a perfect strategy, but it's a reasonable one--and it deals with the reality presented us by the systems of power and control. it's also a hell of a lot more complex than this author bothers to mention.
(another point: part of the voluminous online response to Brad Will's murder is probably connected to the many contacts he made traveling around the Western Hemisphere and Europe--which he may have been able to do, in part, because of the background afforded him by skin color. if that's the case, then a critique of the situation shouldn't boil down to "don't be sad about this or else you're racist and less radical than me", but rather "this death resonates with many people because this guy was able to travel a lot--how can we make sure that people from the lower rungs of global apartheid are also able to travel, share ideas, and make contacts?" that strikes me as a lot less hurtful, and a lot more productive.)
Before we start self-castigating over this, I'd just like to point out that since June 14th, many people have been killed in Oaxaca, and we haven't been out marching in the streets over them, nor do we remember their names.
The reason that Brad's death has meaning to us is because we knew him. We knew him in the context of indymedia reporting, which is something that many of us have in common. He was one of us. Yes, 'us' is mostly white, middle class kids. Luckily, our government has
not started shooting us in the streets (yet), and so we are shocked when that happens to one of us.
Grief is not something that can be formed logically around politically correct philosophies. I feel what I feel, and Brad's death touched me in a way that none of the other deaths in Oaxaca have. I will not feel ashamed of that. But nor will I stop doing what I can to help the people in Oaxaca, many of whom are being touched much more deeply by the loss of their friends and family in the struggle to free Oaxaca.
So what is the author's recommendation for purging our souls of white guilt? "Call out your white comrades, because if you don’t, what kind of comrade does that make you?"
How do you "call out" your friends? Demand that they feel grief for people they didn't know? Or perhaps demand that they not act on the grief they feel for Brad? I resent the implication that we are doing something wrong, with no clear recommendations for how to do it differently.
Howard Besser wrote:
Yes, there certainly is racism within the various
"movements" in the US that support "peoples'
struggles" in other countries. But I think that you've
chosen the wrong example to focus on. Making a big
deal of an American journalist killed in a "peoples'
struggle" in another country is both a pretty natural
reaction, and a long-standing organizing tool. I'm
living in Brazil. A year ago a Brazilian named Jean
Charles de Menezes was killed by security forces in
London because they mistook him for a terrorist. There
was enormous publicity over this in Brazil. And even
though every day people are killed all over the world
by security forces (and even though hundreds of other
"innocent" people die in Brazil every week), the focus
on this one person and one incident had an enormous
effect on the average Brazilian. It help focus the
average Brazilian on what the "War on Terror" meant to
personal freedoms, it pointed out the kind of
xenophobia that leads people in most countries to be
suspicious of any foreigner, and it made the average
Brazilian feel that you didn't have to be in the
Middle East of the US to become a victim of the "War
on Terror".
I don't think that it's morally right, but the truth
is that the average American will take notice of an
American killed in Oaxaca more than they will respond
to an APPO member being killed. But more importantly,
if Oaxacan security forces would openly kill an Anglo
like Brad Will, it means that the threat to Oaxacans
is much greater! So, making a big deal about Brad's
murder shows how much worse it is for the average
Oaxacan. Like Rachel Corrie's death pointed out the
kinds of things that happen to Palestinians every
single day.
I totally agree with your point that people need to
recognize and own up to racism within the various
movements. But trying to use too broad a brush to
paint a racist picture doesn't do anyone any good. And
to say that what's been happening in Oaxaca has become
a "legitimate struggle"for progressive organizations
ONLY since Brad's death is really stretching it
(particularly for the organizations you mention)!
Democracy Now! had dozens of stories on the APPO, long
before Brad was killed. IndyMedia has had many more.
Maybe it's fewer than you wanted to see, but it
certainly was enough for me (and many many others) to
feel more informed about what was going on there than
on just about any other struggle anywhere else in the
world.
One more point: when someone you know is murdered,
don't you spend a little more time complaining and
shout a little louder about it than when someone you
don't know is murdered? That doesn't mean that you
don't value the lives of all the other people who have
been murdered! To be extra vociferous about harm that
has come to someone you know personally is not a
racist act. (By no means does this obsolve all the
people complaining about Brad from any racism; but
complaining about him being killed is not itself a
racist act.) Brad was intimately involved with
IndyMedia, and had many friends on the staff of
Democracy Now!.
I would guess that every single day hundreds (or maybe
thousands) of people in the world are killed
struggling for what I would regard as basic human
rights. And though I wish I had time to write about
and demonstrate
about each of those struggles (and each of those
people), if I did so, I wouldn't have time to eat or
sleep, and eventually I wouldn't be able to support
even a single one of those struggles.
If you're going to complain about the very real
problem of racism, please look to better examples than
activist journalists supporting a comrade slain in a
struggle that they had previously singled out as an
important one.
Yes, i'm white, and my neck is wikid red. To read this shit makes my face a little red, too. a little shame, a little anger. a little jaundiced with contempt. Do you know who victor alejo plata is? or demon? their asses are in jail. they're organizers, victor has been on a wanted list for six years and they got him. they're from oaxaca, and could use your attention. I hope you follow up on that, everyone reading this should check victor out in the movie el enemigo comun (elenemigocomun.net) and start replacing brad's name here and ther with victors' name, because victor is alive and a badass.
Yeah, so, Brad was a friend of mine. You don't get creedence or respect from me with your pointy-headed prick critique. It's fucked up, and you're fucked up, and this charming bit of constructive analysis is going to stir up a bunch of grief and fear and anger-driven, misguided defensive bullshit and counterspin, energy that is needed to respond to the situation in oaxaca and the upcoming general strike across mexico that the zapatistas have called for november 20. Your totally right, but go a little softer. this dialogue is non-stop amongst the organizing in NYC. We figure brad wants to be used for every drop to get the oaxaca msg out. My problem with you is that you're being a snot.
There's something about unconstructive criticism, criticism motivated by self-aggrandisement and lacking in productive input, that i think further entrenches PATHOLGICAL tendencies. Anyway, fuck you and your cheesy second-hand pathology, don't spit on my mans' grave and don't distract us from the work. We're busy and you are undermining the credibility of a very important introspective critique that is essential to our survival. That shit really chaps my ass. Do us and this discussion a favor. EARN yourself a little respect by introducing yourself a little more humbly and the work that you're doing to make your opinion relevant, or show us something that means something to the oaxaquenos. Apologize for your vitriolic "pinch-my-nipple-and-call-me-honky!" fetish routine and work on your half-assed shtick a little and i won't have to tear your shit down in public any more.
check out that elenemigocomun.net and friendsofbradwill.org, good online organizing and education going on there.
love and elbow grease, hambone
;~)
Bush/Calderon are seeking to send $1.5 Billion dollars of u.s military aid and Blackwater mercenaries to repress the people even more in Mexico. Congress is considering it now. There have been actions in Congress I read and locally anyone can meet with their Representatives or organize an action if that is not their cup of tea. All colors. Aho!