Benutzereinstellungen

Neue Veranstaltungshinweise

Indonesia / Philippines / Australia

Es wurden keine neuen Veranstaltungshinweise in der letzten Woche veröffentlicht

Non-violent action: Direct and “direct”

category indonesia / philippines / australia | community struggles | opinion / analysis author Montag Mai 27, 2019 11:45author by Melbourne Anarchist Communist Group - Anarkismo Report this post to the editors

What is required is a movement that knows the police are the attack dogs of the enemy and they are to be resisted with all the strength and intelligence we can muster. We need a movement that wants to #StopAdani directly, a movement that will create facts on the ground that the Government cannot ignore. And this movement, in challenging the State, will inevitably look beyond it, to a new society with no State and no cops, and where capitalism is no more.
onstrike.png

As more people realise that climate change is happening, and there’s no mainstream political call to stop it, they are starting to look beyond conventional political tactics. Writing to politicians, canvassing for votes and having a protest march from A to B won’t cut it. The peace and environment movements have a long tradition of adopting Non-Violent Direct Action (NVDA) when other tactics fail, without clarifying just what this means.

It is generally agreed that NVDA attempts to achieve aims by peacefully taking action that either directly reaches the goals or blocks the government or corporation from conducting business-as-usual (BAU). These are very effective tactics. Indeed, it can be seen that a strike is a primary example. Workers withdraw their labour and refuse to conduct BAU until the boss makes an adequate offer. Direct action gets the goods.

In practice, though, there is more to NVDA than meets the eye. While the peace and environment movements in Australia are almost totally united in supporting this approach, there has been much debate around how to go about it. Big campaigns over the Franklin Dam in the 1980s and Jabiluka in the 1990s were riven by conflicts over this issue. With the climate movement gearing up to wage an NVDA campaign to #StopAdani, the MACG believes it’s important to understand NVDA a little better.

Sometimes NVDA really is what it says on the tin. People come together to take action that achieves their goals directly. On other occasions, however, what occurs is Non-Violent “Direct” Action. The participants go through the forms of Direct Action, without the substance. The action is symbolic and the intent is to achieve its aims indirectly, through traditional channels.

Though many examples of such “Direct” Action have occurred in Australia, it is best illustrated by a particularly egregious case in the United States. Democracy Spring is a progressive organisation in the US trying to improve voting rights and limit the ability of rich people to use their money to influence elections – worthy objectives, but very limited ones. In April 2016, this organisation conducted a march from Philadelphia to Washington DC, culminating in a blockade of the Capitol Building, the Parliament House in the US. Over the course of a week, more than 900 people were arrested. An impressive display of Direct Action, it appeared.

Appearances, though, were deceiving. The “blockade” of the Capitol was a highly choreographed affair, conducted in close co-operation with the police. There was no serious attempt to impede access to the building. The arrestees were not even charged, something which would have clogged up the courts. Instead, they were released after paying $50 each to a fund that goes to the Washington DC police. This was “Direct” Action as a mere ritual, a symbol of determination, with the real objective of getting TV coverage that mentioned “a record number of arrests”. It was a media strategy based upon deception.

The difference between NVDA and NV“D”A is usually apparent in the media strategy. In Direct Action, the primary function of the media strategy is to draw more people into the action and to deter State violence. In “Direct” Action, its primary function is to generate mass media attention that affects the mainstream political process. Direct Action empowers the participants, while “Direct” Action treats them as a stage army, to be wheeled on and off according to the judgment of the leadership.

The difference between Direct Action and “Direct” Action can also be seen in their very different treatment by the police. Police in liberal democracies are often quite willing to collaborate with “Direct” Action as a symbolic spectacle, provided everything is negotiated properly beforehand and it is understood that there is no actual attempt to prevent BAU. The police are almost always very hostile to Direct Action. They are the armed thugs of the State and their job is to uphold an unjust social order. Direct Action puts the State in the position of either being forced to concede, or to use police violence to defeat the movement. The larger the Direct Action is, the more violence the State would require and the more it would be discredited by its response, sparking wider resistance. It is thus a challenge to the State, something no police force can tolerate.

Now that Adani have announced they intend to build their coal mine and railway line without borrowing from the banks, the probability of it actually starting work has increased. If the climate movement wants to #StopAdani, it will have to defeat the opposition of the Queensland Government. NVDA will be called for. The movement needs to be clear, though, that “Direct” Action is different from Direct Action.

When a government is firmly in the pocket of the mining companies, it will not be swayed by a few weeks of TV stories showing pictures of people passively sitting and waiting to be taken away by the cops. What is required is a movement that knows the police are the attack dogs of the enemy and they are to be resisted with all the strength and intelligence we can muster. We need a movement that wants to #StopAdani directly, a movement that will create facts on the ground that the Government cannot ignore. And this movement, in challenging the State, will inevitably look beyond it, to a new society with no State and no cops, and where capitalism is no more.

#STOP ADANI

*This article first appeared in The Anvil Vol 8 No 2, published 14 March 2019.

Verwandter Link: https://melbacg.wordpress.com/2019/04/21/non-violent-action-direct-direct/
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
Neste 8 de Março, levantamos mais uma vez a nossa voz e os nossos punhos pela vida das mulheres!

Indonesia / Philippines / Australia | Community struggles | en

Do 19 Sep, 07:18

browse text browse image

elections.jpg imageDon’t mention the emergency 06:40 Fr 17 Mai by Melbourne Anarchist Communist Group 0 comments

On 18 May, enrolled voters in Australia will decide which members of the capitalist class will represent us in Parliament and crush us in government for the next three years. This election occurs at a time when the world has been informed that it has, at most, until 2030 to take effective action to stop and begin reversing climate change, or risk crossing tipping points into runaway temperature rises that would kill billions and endanger industrial civilisation. So you’d think the major players would be presenting plans to fix it. But no, this is Australian capitalist democracy and we get something different.

cage.jpg imageElections are not the answer 23:04 Fr 01 Jul by Melbourne Anarchist Communist Group 2 comments

The Australian Federal election campaign grinds on, with most people being heartily sick of the whole thing. Neither the Liberals nor Labor are trusted by most voters and the major parties are horrified at the drift of voters to minor parties of all stripes. Anarchists have something to say about this, something deeper than just advising people about voting. We say if you’re looking to fix the problems in society, Parliament is the wrong place.

tumblr_lnb09kkgi91qdjbb7o1_500.jpg imageDispatches from the Greek Streets 13:40 Mo 28 Mai by Melbourne Solidarity 0 comments

Dispatches from the Greek Streets: Interview with Antonis Vradis - By Melbourne Solidarity with the anti-austerity movements in Greece

youcanthazweekenda3posterfinalv1.4jpeg724x1024.jpg imageSave Weekend Penalty Rates 21:22 Sa 28 Apr by Workers Solidarity Network (Melbourne) 0 comments

Save Weekend Penalty Rates: “You Can’t Haz Our Weekend” Protest

ifrrza5gvsvs_1.jpg imageSolidarity with Greece from Melbourne 19:30 Mo 26 Mär by Dimitri (MACG - personal capacity) 0 comments

Solidarity with Greece: We owe nothing, We're not selling, We wont pay!

7pm 29/3 @ Uniting Church Hall, Northcote 251 High Street, Northcote

7pm 29/3 @ Uniting Church Hall, Northcote 251 High Street, Northcote, VIC Concession $4/Waged $8/ Solidarity $12 (All proceeds from the night will be sent to support anti-austerity campaigns in Greece)

image131.jpg imageDefend the right to Protest! 15:13 Mo 04 Jul by Dimitri (MACG – personal capacity - republishing) 1 comments

- Defend the right to Protest!
- Defend the Max Brenner 19!
- Tuesday 5th of July, 6:30pm @ Trades Hall

bandaids_0.jpg imageNo More Band-aid Solutions 19:14 Di 16 Nov by Dmitri 0 comments

On Friday November 12th the “No More Band-Aid Solutions: End The Housing Crisis” rally closed down Victorian Housing Minister Richard Wynne’s electoral office in Collingwood. Despite sweltering heat and a looming rainstorm 80 to 100 people joined the protest playing drums and percussion, setting up tents and a clothesline and plastering Wynne’s office windows with band-aids and squatting stickers. Organised by the City Is Ours the rally called for immediate and genuine action against homelessness and housing stress and an end to the Victorian government’s support for profiteering developers and landlords.

textSupporting the Homeless in Melbourne 21:02 Do 05 Aug by Dmitri (MACG - personal capacity) 0 comments

With as many as 200 people sleeping rough in Melbourne's CBD on any given night, a group calling itself Homelessness Front - Stop the Suffering organised a protest outside the Smith Street office of Victorian Housing Minister Richard Wynne.

textKulon Progo Solidarity Action 20:34 Mi 23 Jun by MACG 0 comments

Kulon Progo Solidarity Action 2pm Sat 26 June: Indonesian Consulate

textNomadic Penan of Sarawak in trouble 15:38 So 24 Jul by Karen Saturday 0 comments

The Penan tribe of Sarawak, Borneo are under threat from the notorious Samling timber company.

more >>

imageThe struggle continues Sep 07 by MACG 0 comments

It is these things: Liberal arrogance, the danger of recession, accelerating climate change and the Fascist threat that, together, form significant elements of the political terrain in Australia today. And it is these things that will guide the MACG in the next few years.

imageDefeat the Liberals with a General Strike Dez 10 by Melbourne Anarchist Communist Group 0 comments

The Liberal Government brought down a budget in May that outraged workers across Australia. It is a massive attack on the working class across the board, with cuts to pensions, Medicare, higher education, State funding for health and education, unemployment benefits and much more. There is hardly a sector of the working class that won’t be dramatically affected.

imageIn response to the budget Jul 09 by Anarchist Affinity 0 comments

There is no budget emergency. This budget is a gross assault on the conditions of the working classes, smuggled in under contrived hysteria about debt. Meanwhile, Australia’s debt to GDP rate is the third lowest in the OECD. The 2014 budget is simply concerned with enhancing the profitability of corporate Australia and the power of the state on the backs of working people. The poorest people in our society will be the most affected – this means people of colour, Aboriginal people, women, young people and people with disabilities.

imageA tale of Sand Feb 21 by Saksi 0 comments

A Tale of Sand, and Those Who Feed From It: History and Etnographic explanation of Kulon Progo’s Village and Resistance. Translated from Amor Fati #3

imageKulon Progo Self-organised Struggle Against Neoliberal Megaproject Feb 19 by Kulon Progo Solidarity Network 0 comments

Considering these political implications and the revolutionary tendency of the peasant struggle, we urge to have a solid international solidarity. And on the behalf of the peasants, we need input on how to challenge these laws on international scale. We have made infrastructure of struggle in the village: community radio and social center. And also there’s twice of solidarity actions conducted by our comrades in Melbourne and Perth (due to the involvment of Australian Kimberly Diamond). We are in dire need for help to make this struggle successful without any interference of the leftist institution and its disgusting network. Please contact us for furtrher collaboration and we will update you with a more extensive and comprehensive data of the struggle. This letter are not our own initiative but were a result of our meetings with the PPLP-KP.

more >>

imageDon’t mention the emergency Mai 17 Anarkismo 0 comments

On 18 May, enrolled voters in Australia will decide which members of the capitalist class will represent us in Parliament and crush us in government for the next three years. This election occurs at a time when the world has been informed that it has, at most, until 2030 to take effective action to stop and begin reversing climate change, or risk crossing tipping points into runaway temperature rises that would kill billions and endanger industrial civilisation. So you’d think the major players would be presenting plans to fix it. But no, this is Australian capitalist democracy and we get something different.

imageElections are not the answer Jul 01 Anarkismo 2 comments

The Australian Federal election campaign grinds on, with most people being heartily sick of the whole thing. Neither the Liberals nor Labor are trusted by most voters and the major parties are horrified at the drift of voters to minor parties of all stripes. Anarchists have something to say about this, something deeper than just advising people about voting. We say if you’re looking to fix the problems in society, Parliament is the wrong place.

imageDispatches from the Greek Streets Mai 28 0 comments

Dispatches from the Greek Streets: Interview with Antonis Vradis - By Melbourne Solidarity with the anti-austerity movements in Greece

imageSave Weekend Penalty Rates Apr 28 0 comments

Save Weekend Penalty Rates: “You Can’t Haz Our Weekend” Protest

imageSolidarity with Greece from Melbourne Mär 26 Anarkismo 0 comments

Solidarity with Greece: We owe nothing, We're not selling, We wont pay!

7pm 29/3 @ Uniting Church Hall, Northcote 251 High Street, Northcote

7pm 29/3 @ Uniting Church Hall, Northcote 251 High Street, Northcote, VIC Concession $4/Waged $8/ Solidarity $12 (All proceeds from the night will be sent to support anti-austerity campaigns in Greece)

more >>
© 2005-2019 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]