user preferences

New Events

Ireland / Britain

no event posted in the last week

V For Vendetta - Anarchist Youth Pirate Film Showing

category ireland / britain | culture | opinion / analysis author Wednesday May 24, 2006 20:36author by V for anarchist youth - WSM (personal capacity) Report this post to the editors

Anarchist Youth in Dublin recently showed V For Vendetta and had a discussion about the politics of the film. These are the speakers notes from the discussion.

p>After spending a long week outside St. Patricks Cathedral Anarchist Youth yesterday held a film showing to allow everyone to relax. We chose to show the major hollywood film "V For Vendetta" for free as we are opposed to the idea of entertainment as a commodity and intellectual property laws that outlaw downloading and sharing information (movies, music, games, software).

The following is the basic text of a talk given before the film.

V for Vendetta was originally a graphic novel written in the 80's by Alan Moore about a man taking on a fascistic regime and promoting "Anarchy". The comic was full of choice quotes on the nature of the state, justice and the struggle for a free society. The main character, "V", is an 18th century style "propaganda by the deed" anarchist who spends his time blowing up buildings and murdering people, it's all very exciting if not somewhat cliché.

Many American anarchists were enraged that V's "anarchist" message was cut out of the film and even launched a campaign to promote V as an anarchist and to fill people in on what was left out of the film taking the angle; "you know what V was against now find out what he was for". For me this shows the naivety of certain American anarchists, did they ever think that Hollywood would produce a film sympathetic to real revolutionary ideas? Surely they didn't think the Wachowski brothers, of "The Matrix" fame, would leave the story intact. Has Hollywood ever taken a decent idea and turned it into anything more than a dumbed down, meaningless, 2 hour long forumlaic product? But the question the question that really struck me while watching the film was, is V actually an anarchist?

Can anyone who acts on behalf of the people instead of alongside them consider themselves an anarchist? His so called revolution, a crude plot to overthrow the government by blowing up the houses of parliament would not and could never lead to an anarchist society, if anything it would only serve to strengthen the state. Capitalism is a social relationship, defined by the system of wage labour, class structures and the pursuit of profit. We have bosses and rulers, cops and big business all working together to keep the organised chaos of the free market ticking over.

In this film V seems to be little more than the crude personification of the media stereotyped anarchist. If he blows up parliament, will there be anarchy? Or would another set of rulers just step into place and continue business as usual? Unfortunately I think the latter is far more likely. This is why anarchists believe that we must build the revolution now in how we organise and we must make our ideas the leading ideas within society before we can ever hope to overthrow this system. To quote a comrade of mine arguing for an anarchist revolution ,

"For us means and ends are interconnected. The means we use influence the society we want to see and we feel that an anarchist or communist society cannot be brought about by centralising power. But this doesn't mean that we believe in a "quick change". Revolution isn't a spectacular event, it's a process. To stop a minority seizing power after a revolution we need to encourage the self activity and organisation of the Working Class in here and now. Following a revolution when the bourgeoisie state is overthrown there will obviously be a vacuum of power, or a dual power situation. This vacuum can be filled by the democratic (mandated) organs of the Working class or by a vanguard that takes control in the name of, and even possibly supported by the class."

Related Links,
Our site, made with open source software.
Torrent site where you can download copyrighted films, music, etc.
American "anarchist" site which claims V was an anarchist.

This article was first published on indymedia.ie at http://www.indymedia.ie/article/76214

author by Waynepublication date Fri May 26, 2006 05:22author address author phone Report this post to the editors

I posted this piece on the nyc@ list. The following comment was made in response by a member of the NYC group (A for Anarchy) which has been campaigning around this issue:

(here is a response from A4@'s Steve McFarland)
*******************

This article takes an uninformed cheap shot at our work, one that that calls for a response.

The afor@ project was never about publicly registering our shock or anger than Hollywood would pervert some sacred text of the anarchist canon. We grew up in America. We harbor no illusions about how Hollywood operates. Moreover, while there are insurrectionary anarchists among us, the majority of our group find the politics put forward by the original comic book problematic-- anachronistic at best, and puerile at worst. Some of us hold ideas that closely align with those of the WSA. Our website provides links to anarchist ideas and activities of all stripes. So we weren't acting as Alan Moore's avengers, 'promoting' the comic book V as the paragon of anarchist virtue.

We simply saw the opportunity to hitch some anarchist propaganda to a rampaging hollywood juggernaut, and provide a gateway to the world of anarchism that is usually confined to the margins. So far we've been pretty successful-- we handed out thousands of flyers in Manhattan, have gotten thousands more hits on our website, and inspired autonomous activities in other countries. We've gotten positive feedback from places like Spain, Turkey, the UK, Australia, and Singapore. We have more activities being planned around the August DVD release.

It's demoralizing when allies distort the character of your hard work to rack up "more anarchist than thou" points. We hope than by the time Dublin's Anarchist Youth grow up, they will have learned to publicly evaluate the efforts of fellow anarchists in the spirit of solidarity.

____

 
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
George Floyd: one death too many in the “land of the free”
© 2005-2021 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]