user preferences

New Events

Southern Africa

no event posted in the last week
Recent articles by Benjamin Fogel
This author has not submitted any other articles.
Recent Articles about Southern Africa Workplace struggles

South Africa: New Amendments to the LRA – Their Meaning and Implicatio... Sep 15 14 by David Cartwright, Komnas Poriazis

South Africa: Justice for UJ Cleaners Aug 08 14 by Persistent Solidarity Forum

Revolutionary Trade Unionism: The Road to Workers’ Freedom Mar 24 14 by Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Front

Notes from a Farmworkers Strike

category southern africa | workplace struggles | non-anarchist press author Saturday December 08, 2012 20:50author by Benjamin Fogel Report this post to the editors

Ben Fogel on the media response to the self-organised farm workers' strike in the Western Cape.

Politics is not only about the exploits of big men (and the occassional woman); it’s not only about Zuma vs Motlanthe or Malema vs Zille and the rest of this sorry, but entertaining coterie that our political class consists of. Politics begins with people being able to talk and organise in their own communities or workplaces, it begins with ordinary men and women, rather than the latest Manguang related shenanigans.

The farmworkers’ strike which resumed with a bang and ended apparently without a whimper in the Western Cape this week, is no exception to this. Farmworkers are perhaps the most brutalised and exploited section of South Africa’s working class. Even inhumane and barbaric practices such as the dop system have yet to be fully purged from the agricultural sector. It is for this reason, that the farmworkers’ uprising is of particular significance.

Last Sunday, I attended a farmworkers rally in Ashton called by the small independent union CSAAWU (Commercial, Stevedoring, Agricultural and Allied Workers Union), the Democratic Left Front (DLF) and the Mayibuye Land Rights Forum. In attendance at the Ashton stadium were about 500 workers, representatives of a range of Western Cape social movements, assorted NGOs, and even Amplats worker’s committee spokesperson Gaddafi Mdoda. Awaiting patiently outside were at least two dozen police vehicles some Nyalas, and over 50 police officers.

The primary demand of the rally was a minimum wage of R150 a day, of which a worker told me afterwards, “was only a start.” For, “who can survive on R3000 a month?” They issued other demands such as a living wage of R12 500 for all South African workers; a call for the formation of democratic workers’ committees in every farm and an end to all abusive labour practices on farms. Such demands have clearly been inspired by the Marikana strike wave. Workers at both this gathering and a parallel one held in De Doorns appear to support the resumption of the strike, following the ‘Farmworkers Strike Coalition’s announcement that the strike would continue last week, before it was ended by a random COSATU decree which surprised both workers and journalists alike.

The difficulties of organising farm workers remain immense. Some of the challenges that farm workers face in trying to organise include the presence of widespread illiteracy, local political party squabbles and the fact that many farmworkers and their families remain vulnerable because of their dependence on housing provided by farmers. It is not uncommon for entire families of farmworkers to be evicted from the housing provided by farmers for joining a union or being too ‘outspoken’ on farms where they have been residing for generations. It remains to be seen if the ambitious goal of organising these workers can be translated into reality.

At the rally, Western Cape COSATU and ANC leader Tony Ehenreich also made an appearance in which he spoke briefly and then quickly disappeared. His speech was received with mixed reaction by the crowd and many speakers criticised COSATU’s unwillingness to take direction from the workers.

Yet, despite the brevity of his appearance and the lack of support he had at the rally, Tony Ehrenreich’s opinions featured prominently in the pages of the Cape Times and assorted wire reports thereby drowning out the voices of workers and other grassroots organisations which have actual popular support amongst the strikers. The commitment of the ANC and COSATU to the struggles of farm workers remains to be seen.

It is crucial that the coverage of the strike focuses on the reality of the activity of workers on the ground rather than attempting to portray the strike as a power battle between the ANC and the DA over the future of the province. The ANC did not give birth to the strike and judging by their reaction to Marikana and their own lack of action during their tenure in control of the Western Cape, they would probably have responded to these strikes as harshly, if not worse than, the DA.

Another attendant at Sunday’s rally was Mario Wanza who can only be described as the Zelig of Western Cape politics. Here, I am referring to the Woody Allen movie in which he played a human chameleon who reappears again and again throughout history opportunistically adapting to whatever surrounding he found himself in.

Wanza was first an ANC politician before being expelled for running against his branch’s chosen candidate a few years ago. He then became the leader of the Proudly Mannenberg ‘social movement’ and then briefly as Cape Town mayor Patrica de Lille’s arch-enemy in the build up to the failed occupation of the Rondebosch common. Then he briefly teamed up with de Lille for a photo-op in front on the Mannenberg Human Settlement Contact Centre before finally ascending to his current status as the leader of a reborn UDF (United Democratic Front).

This current UDF, far from being the mass movement of times past, consists of Wanza and several of his friends, associates, and alleged cronies attempting to suck whatever legitimacy or attention they can from the legacy of the UDF. It’s pretty much the equivalent of me getting drunk on Saturday night and declaring myself the new Tupac, despite being white and unable to rap and then getting media attention on that basis. There are also serious allegations by Manenberg community members and others who have worked with him, claiming that he is hopelessly authoritarian and corrupt.

Legitimacy for such figures as Wanza is ultimately derived from their ability to work the media thereby compensate for the lack of a popular base. Quite often in the media, the viewpoints of the popular base are left out altogether – such as in the case of the Marikana massacre in which only 3% of news stories actually cited the miners as sources of information.

A particularly egregious example of such coverage, can be found in this recent SAPA article carried by City Press, which has the notable achievement of reporting that the farmworkers strike will continue without actually consulting any actual farmworkers. Instead we are left with the words of non-farmworkers such as Wanza and Ehrenreich. We should be more careful to look into the backgrounds of such figures before granting them legitimacy to speak for the strikers.

Too often, focusing on the colourful characters (we should never underestimate Malema’s entertainment value) of our powerful elite and their hangers-on leads journalists to treat their opinions, distortions and curiosities as newsworthy in themselves. This leads to an excessive focus on these personalities to the exclusion of the activities of people on the ground who actually drive political change.

In an age where political reportage is often submerged in an ocean of spin, pressures on journalists to produce quantity over quality leads to the uncritical repetition of elite opinions as news. Distorted narratives can be reproduced in such a way that it justifies state repression or gives credence to our politicians’ favourite habit of blaming a ‘third force’ each time people take to the streets to demand their rights. Just as often, such narratives give rise to political charlatans who suddenly find themselves gifted with the aura of political legitimacy.

It is vital to pay close attention to the manner in which the farmworker strikes have been and will be covered in the mainstream media. The DA continues to use xenophobic references to blame foreign nationals or ANC operatives as the forces behind the strike while ignoring that the real ‘third force’ is the perpetual chain of exploitation and poverty that farmworkers find themselves trapped in. The persistence of starvation wages and feudal living conditions in the agricultural sector is the real reason people are taking to the streets.

Last week, Helen Zille made what seems to be her now habitual call (mostly via twitter), for the SANDF to intervene. She has called it a preemptive attempt to prevent the outbreak of further violence. Perhaps Zille is taking her cues from the Israeli Defence Force’s live tweeting of its attacks during their most recent assault on Gaza?

It is up to journalists to ensure that such dangerous solicitations do not go unchallenged and that the narratives of workers are not subsumed by the petty infighting of our political class. Will South Africa’s media finally rise to the challenge? Or will we continue to claim that reporting on political soap operas (under the guise of freedom of the press) actually constitutes legitimate journalism?

In short, journalistic responsibility cannot be separated from social and political responsibility – they go hand-in-hand

This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
Verso lo sciopero generale e sociale nel mondo del lavoro, nei territori, nelle piazze

Southern Africa | Workplace struggles | en

Sun 26 Oct, 06:36

browse text browse image

textStatement by the Anti-Government-in-Exile of Wits University 16:49 Thu 08 Sep by Mbuyiseni Ndlozi, James Pendlebury, Komnas Poriazis 0 comments

Beginning on Sunday 28 August, Wits students have been littering parts of campus in solidarity with the cleaners’ strike. Cleaners throughout South Africa are demanding a living wage of R4 200 per month: this compares with less than R2 000 paid to cleaners at Wits, who are employed by outsourcing companies such as Supercare. The strike has been undermined, at Wits and elsewhere, by the presence of scab labour; Wits management and the outsourcing companies are striving for “business as usual”. This undermines the entire purpose of the strike, which is to compel exploiter-managers to meet workers’ demands by withdrawing their labour, by preventing the job from getting done – by making sure the campus is not clean.

textSupport S. African public sector strike 19:56 Wed 20 Jun by Melbourne Anarchist Commounist Group 0 comments

A Melbourne Anarchist Commounist Group Statement in support of South African public sector strike

textOAE – Greece supports the strikers in S.Africa 20:54 Wed 13 Jun by OAE-Greece 0 comments

The Federation of Anarchists of Greece (OAE) is calling for a further action in terms of unity and organisation.

textZACF Statement of Support for Public Sector Strike 18:53 Wed 13 Jun by Jonathan 7 comments

The Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Federation (southern Africa) supports the public sector strikers, not just in their demand for a wage increase of 12%, which has now been reduced to 10%, but also in their struggle to improve the standard of all public sector services.

textAnti-Privatisation Forum May Day Rally 19:29 Tue 01 May by Dale McKinley 0 comments

The APF will be hosting a May Day Workers Rally in the community of Residensia (Sebokeng – Vaal Triangle) at Tshepo Themba School at 10h00 tomorrow in support of all the working class struggles in the country.

textConditions for Workers in South Africa 17:44 Tue 31 May by Phillip Nyalungu 0 comments

t is common amongst bosses to prefer workers coming from countries that are torn by civil wars or famine. This is because they do away with any responsibilities to cover for workers' health if exposed to health risk scenarios while working. Because these people are not citizens, the country's labour laws do not count for them. That way the bosses don't have to worry about precautionary equipment and measures expected by governmental labour standards

imageAlternative Needed to Nationalisation and Privatisation Feb 28 by Tina Sizovuka and Lucien van der Walt 1 comments

Privatisation – the transfer of functions and industry to the private sector – is widely and correctly rejected on the left and in the working class. Privatisation leads only to higher prices, less and worse jobs, and worse services. Given this, some view nationalisation – the transfer of economic resources (e.g. mines, banks, and factories) to state ownership and control – as a rallying cry for a socialist alternative. This article argues that nationalisation has never removed capitalism, nor led to socialism, and it certainly does not have a demonstrable record of consistently improving wages, jobs, rights and safety. This article appeals to progressive working class forces to look instead to another way:collectivisation from below, where industry is placed under direct workers’ self-management, subject to worker-community participatory democratic planning and control to meet human needs and end oppression, in a universal human community.

imageReaping what you sow: reflections on the Western Cape farm workers strike Feb 09 by Shawn Hattingh 0 comments

The series of strikes and protests that recently took place in and around farms in South Africa’s Western Cape Province was fuelled by the deep-seated anger and frustration that workers feel. On a daily basis, farm workers face not only appalling wages, bad living conditions and precarious work, but also widespread racism, intimidation and humiliation. The extent of the oppressive conditions run deep and it is not uncommon for workers to even be beaten by farm-owners and managers for perceived ‘transgressions’. Indeed, life for workers in the rural areas has always been harsh, but over the last two decades it has in many ways gotten even worse and poverty has in many cases grown.

imageWhat the Marikana Massacre tells us Sep 04 by Shawn Hattingh 0 comments

While any human being with any sense of justice should be appalled by what happened at Marikana it would, however, be a mistake to view it as an isolated incident that emerged out of the blue.

imageCleaning out super-exploitation Sep 14 by James Pendlebury 0 comments

Cleaning workers throughout South Africa have been on strike since Monday 8 August. They are demanding a living wage of R4 200 per month, as well as a 13th cheque and shorter hours.

imageBuild a Better Workers’ Movement: learning from South Africa’s 2010 mass strike Jul 11 by Lucien van der Walt and Ian Bekker 0 comments

The biggest single strike since the 1994 parliamentary transition in South Africa showed the unions’ power. It won some wage gains, but it threw away some precious opportunities. We need to celebrate the strike, while learning some lessons: • the need for more union democracy
• the need to use strikes to link workers and communities
• the need for working class autonomy
• the need to act outside and against the state
• the need to review our positions: against the Tripartite Alliance, for anarcho-syndicalism

more >>

textStatement by the Anti-Government-in-Exile of Wits University Sep 08 Anti-Government-in-Exile of Wits University 0 comments

Beginning on Sunday 28 August, Wits students have been littering parts of campus in solidarity with the cleaners’ strike. Cleaners throughout South Africa are demanding a living wage of R4 200 per month: this compares with less than R2 000 paid to cleaners at Wits, who are employed by outsourcing companies such as Supercare. The strike has been undermined, at Wits and elsewhere, by the presence of scab labour; Wits management and the outsourcing companies are striving for “business as usual”. This undermines the entire purpose of the strike, which is to compel exploiter-managers to meet workers’ demands by withdrawing their labour, by preventing the job from getting done – by making sure the campus is not clean.

textSupport S. African public sector strike Jun 20 0 comments

A Melbourne Anarchist Commounist Group Statement in support of South African public sector strike

textOAE – Greece supports the strikers in S.Africa Jun 13 Anarkismo 0 comments

The Federation of Anarchists of Greece (OAE) is calling for a further action in terms of unity and organisation.

textZACF Statement of Support for Public Sector Strike Jun 13 Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Federation 7 comments

The Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Federation (southern Africa) supports the public sector strikers, not just in their demand for a wage increase of 12%, which has now been reduced to 10%, but also in their struggle to improve the standard of all public sector services.

textAnti-Privatisation Forum May Day Rally May 01 Anti-Privatisation Forum (APF) 0 comments

The APF will be hosting a May Day Workers Rally in the community of Residensia (Sebokeng – Vaal Triangle) at Tshepo Themba School at 10h00 tomorrow in support of all the working class struggles in the country.

more >>
© 2005-2014 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]