user preferences

New Events

Ireland / Britain

no event posted in the last week

Shell to Sea release detailed report revealing Garda Ombudsman spin & misinformation

category ireland / britain | community struggles | opinion / analysis author Wednesday April 25, 2012 14:10author by Workers Solidarity Movement - WSM Report this post to the editors

Garda Ombudsman: spin and misinformation

Shell to Sea have released a very detailed report into the GSOC 'investigation' of the Garda at the center of the 'Corrib Cops Rape Tape' which first came to public attention one year ago today. The report reveals that the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (GSOC) engaged in spin and misinformation that misled the public over the Corrib ‘rape’ recording incident of March 2011 and undermined the case against Gardaí. The report details GSOC’s attempts to serve the interests of An Garda Síochána by undermining the women who made the recording public, while deflecting attention from the behaviour of Gardaí. The document was prepared by Shell to Sea with one of the women about whom the ‘rape’ comments were made and seven academics at NUI Maynooth. It has been made available online as a PDF and we are republishing it here:


Garda Ombudsman: spin and misinformation

How the Garda Ombudsman blatantly misled the public over the March 2011 Corrib Garda rape comments recording and undermined the women who brought the recording to public attention - April 5th, 2012

This document examines the handling by the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (GSOC) of its investigation into the incident in Co Mayo on March 31st 2011, when a Garda sergeant and several Gardaí inadvertently recorded themselves discussing threatening to rape a woman who was in their custody. The manner in which GSOC conducted its investigation, particularly its July 2011 ‘Interim Report’, is deeply troubling in several respects. The evidence suggests that GSOC attempted to serve the interests of Gardaí by undermining the women who made the recording public, while deflecting attention from the behaviour of Gardaí.


GSOC’s Interim Report (July 2011) into the incident undermined the case against the Gardaí primarily through two key pieces of false information:

i) The report implies that the recording of the Garda conversation on March 31st had been “tampered with” before being handed to GSOC. In fact, this recording was fully intact on the camera and had not been altered in any way. GSOC was clearly fully aware of this fact. However, GSOC exploited a confusion created by the deletion of an older, unrelated file from the camera – a recording of a confidential academic research interview.

ii) The report implies that one of the women arrested on March 31st may have said the word “rape” during the arrest. The two women utterly refute the suggestion that they said the word “rape” at any time. However, the report fails to make any reference to their accounts of the arrests, despite the fact that GSOC officers had full statements from both and interviewed one of them for 4.5 hours. Instead, the report quotes an unnamed Garda who gives a vague account of possibly having heard one of the women mention rape.


One year on from the start of GSOC’s investigation, there is no word of any disciplinary action against the Gardaí involved. The only people threatened with criminal prosecution in relation to the Corrib Garda “rape” comments incident were the people who brought the recording to public attention. Within days of the release of the recording, GSOC threatened several people with criminal proceedings: Jerrie Ann Sullivan, one of the women whose arrest led to the recording being made; Caoimhe Kerins, a Dublin Shell to Sea spokesperson; several of Ms Sullivan’s academic supervisors from NUI Maynooth and Ms Sullivan’s solicitor. GSOC also briefed journalists in a way that undermined these people. One example was an article in the News of the World on April 17th 2011, which quoted GSOC sources as saying that Ms Sullivan was not co-operating with its investigation. This document contains accounts by some of these people of their dealings with GSOC.


GSOC officers interviewed Ms Sullivan for 4.5 hours. They also interviewed several of her academic supervisors from NUI Maynooth. GSOC exchanged extensive correspondence with Ms Sullivan and her supervisors. Despite this, no reference is made in the Interim Report to anything they said. The only quote from the investigation that is included in the Interim Report is one from an unnamed Garda detective, who makes a vague report of having heard someone shout “rape”, though s/he was “unsure of the exact words used”... as s/he says his/her back was turned. Ms Sullivan told GSOC categorically that neither she nor the other woman used the word “rape” during the arrest (no other protestors were present at the scene of the arrest). However, there is no reference to this in the Interim Report.

A GSOC press release stated on July 28th, 2011: “The Commission is satisfied that the interim report has provided as complete a picture as possible of what happened.”


It is unclear why GSOC has given such prominence in its report to the allegation that one of the women used the word “rape” during the arrest. This appears to be an attempt to shift the blame away from the Garda Sergeant and Gardaí and onto the people whom they discussed raping and who brought the recordings to public attention. This cry of “the women used the word rape first” represents an apparent attempt to mitigate or justify the behaviour of the Gardaí. It is also a disturbing echo of the old notion that a woman is somehow to blame if she is the victim of sexual abuse.


The digital video camera on which Gardaí recorded themselves talking about rape belongs to NUI Maynooth. The camera also contained an older video file, recorded on March 12th, 2011, several weeks prior to the rape comments incident. It was a recording of an academic research interview and was subject to academic confidentiality. In order to protect the confidentiality of the interview subjects (Erris residents talking about their experience of the Corrib Gas project, including policing), the single specific research file was deleted in the presence of a number of NUIM academics, before the university authorities handed the camera over to GSOC. GSOC’s Interim Report exploited this dilemma in a blatant manner.
  • Ms Sullivan and her academic supervisors explained to GSOC officers on several occasions in April 2011 that they were under a strict obligation to protect the confidentiality of people she had interviewed for academic research purposes and that, consequently, she could not hand over an earlier recording of an academic interview.

  • Bizarrely, GSOC chose to ignore this information in its interim report. Instead, GSOC simply stated that footage had been “deleted and overwritten”. This resulted in some highly misleading media reports, which claimed that part of the crucial recordings from March 31st had been recorded over.

  • Between April 8th and 13th 2011, Ms Sullivan and her academic supervisors made several attempts to reach a compromise solution with GSOC. They suggested to GSOC that an independent third party could delete the research interview file in the presence of Ms Sullivan and any technical experts required. GSOC rejected these offers and continued to issue threats of criminal prosecution. GSOC’s Interim Report makes no reference to these offers. Instead, it states: “the significance of these deleted files to the GSOC investigation was not known.”

  • The effect of all this was that journalists and the public believed that crucial evidence had been interfered with in some way.


When GSOC launched its “public interest” inquiry on April 5th into the incident, GSOC briefed journalists that this was not a criminal investigation and that the Gardaí under investigation were unlikely to face criminal charges. However, within days of this, GSOC officers began threatening civilians with criminal prosecution for allegedly not co-operating with their “criminal investigation”.


The interim report was never published on GSOC’s website and has not been sent to any of the civilians affected by it, which is their legal right. However, it was passed to journalists and was published on the RTE news website. It was released at a quiet time for news, on July 28th, resulting in extensive news coverage of the allegations contained in it. The fact that it was released without any warning to the two women involved, putting them back in the media spotlight, is typical of the insensitivity that characterised the investigation.


GSOC has yet to issue a final report about ‘rape’ comments recording in March 2011. To date, no Gardaí have been disciplined in connection with the incident.


When the rape comments recording story broke in early April 2011, GSOC moved swiftly to set up an inquiry. It clearly sought to be seen to be investigating this matter urgently, threatening civilians with criminal charges if they did not co-operate quickly and briefing journalists that these people were not co-operating. In contrast to this, numerous people living close to Shell’s inland refinery in north Mayo are still waiting (years, in some cases) to hear any response from GSOC over complaints submitted about abuse by Gardaí policing the protests there.

GSOC began hearing complaints in May 2007. Between that date and November 2009, 111 complaints were lodged with it in relation to policing of protests against the Corrib Gas project. Of the 111, 78 were deemed admissible, but only seven files were sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The DPP refused to prosecute any of these. Most strikingly, only one file has been sent by GSOC to the Garda Commissioner’s office calling for disciplinary action. To date, no action has been taken. Despite this damning failure, dozens more complaints have been lodged since November 2009, as the GSOC complaints procedure remains the only route open to people who have experienced Garda violence and misconduct. Many Erris residents have stopped making complaints to GSOC, as they now regard it as a waste of time.

In 2007, GSOC sought to do a “policies and practices” investigation into public order aspects of the Corrib protests. Permission was denied by then Justice Minister, Brian Lenihan. The 2010 Front Line Defenders report into Corrib policing argues that this refusal creates “the impression that the State does not want the Garda Síochana held properly to account over the policing of the Corrib dispute”. Front Line Defenders called on GSOC to reapply for permission for this investigation. GSOC has so far failed to act on any of Front Line Defenders’ recommendations.


GSOC’s investigation bears all the hallmarks of a media campaign rather than an independent inquiry. Within hours of the story breaking, GSOC announced a public interest investigation. Privately, officers threatened several civilians with criminal prosecution because these people were faced with a dilemma over an older recording that was subject to academic confidentiality.

GSOC’s briefings to journalists and in particular its July 2011 Interim Report served to transform what was a very straightforward case into a confused and complicated one. The Interim Report was highly selective, omitting all information provided by Jerrie Ann Sullivan and her academic supervisors, such as:
  • the explanations about why an older file had to be deleted from the camera;
  • their offers to GSOC to have the file deleted in the presence of an agreed third party;

The release of the Interim Report in late July 2011 resulted in extensive mainstream media coverage, much of which focused on the false implication that the recording had been “tampered with” and the baseless allegation that the women involved used the word “rape” during their arrest.

The conduct of GSOC in this case raises grave doubts about its independence as a statutory Garda watchdog body in the policing of the Corrib Gas controversy. The lessons of this saga are that any Shell to Sea campaigner who embarrasses An Garda Síochána – as well as leaving themselves open to character attack by anonymous Gardaí via crime correspondents – may also be undermined by, and threatened with prosecution by, the very body tasked with investigating Gardaí.

The document was prepared by Jerrie Ann Sullivan; by seven academics at NUI Maynooth; and by the Dublin Shell to Sea campaign.

Caoimhe Kerins (Dublin Shell to Sea) 085-8328130
Laurence Cox (NUI Maynooth) 087-9851029


A. Account by Jerrie Ann Sullivan with detailed timeline
B. Letter of Complaint from Jerrie Ann Sullivan to GSOC re Interim Report
C. Statement by NUI Maynooth academics
D. Technical notes
E. Copy of GSOC’s Interim Report (July 2011)

This text is from "Garda Ombudsman: spin and misinformation. How the Garda Ombudsman blatantly misled the public over the March 2011 Corrib Garda rape comments recording and undermined the women who brought the recording to public attention". Published by Shell to Sea April 5th, 2012

The PDF, including appendices, can be downloaded from the Shell to Sea site:

Related Link:
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
Zabalaza no.14 Out Now

Ireland / Britain | Community struggles | en

Sat 28 Nov, 20:07

browse text browse image

12191964_764045583722229_7664759228698311548_n.jpg imageStatement from the Barricade inn squatted anarchist social centre 00:07 Thu 29 Oct by Barricade Inn 0 comments

On Wednesday The Barricade Inn Collective received court summons papers informing us that the following day (Thursday 22nd October) the estate holders of the building would be seeking an injunction against us. Court was adjourned and the case will be back in court next Wednesday (28th October).

milliuonstrong.jpg imageWhy we are leaving Campaign Against Home and Water Taxes (CAHWT) 21:57 Wed 26 Jun by Workers Solidarity Movement 0 comments

The Workers Solidarity Movement has decided to withdraw from the Campaign Against Home and Water Taxes. Please see statement below. We have made a donation of €1,000 towards paying off the debts of CAHWT.

textPeople in deprived areas 3 times more likely to take their lives in Northern Ireland 14:36 Thu 13 Sep by Sean Matthews 0 comments

People in deprived areas in Northern Ireland are three times more likely to take their lives. Health minister Edwin Poots said, ‘Unemployment rates in deprived areas further affect people and this is a major concern. Studies indicate that a 1% increase in unemployment is met with a corresponding 0.79% increase in suicide.

shellma.jpg imageHundreds of Garda deployed to protect Shell's machine from the people of Ireland 14:47 Wed 01 Aug by Andrew Flood 0 comments

A huge secretive Garda security operation last night swung into operation in Dublin Port as Shell's Tunnel Boring Machine (TBM) left the port as part of a huge convoy of Garda vehicles. News of the operation had leaked at the last minute meaning that with only an hours notice a handful of Shell to Sea campaigners managed to get down to the port entrance despite the pouring rain. Most of us were pulled over and questioned by Garda at least once and the Garda helicopter stayed overhead as various Garda vehicles including a van load of riot cops with the door open drove past us repeatedly.

rossportcampsunsetradar.jpg imageCouncil tries to silence protest by threatening Rossport Solidarity Camp with eviction 14:54 Tue 22 May by Costas 0 comments

In a new twist to the decade long struggle against Shell Rossport Solidarity Camp has revealed that Mayo County Council (MCC) has issued an eviction notice to the landowner of the field where the Rossport Solidarity Camp is located. Mayo farmer Gerry Burke has been threatened with fines of over €12,000 and two years in prison. Despite these theats the annual June Bank Holiday solidarity gathering will go ahead in a couple of weeks.

htrallycrowdprostedfgplacards.jpg imageMassive National rally of community campaign against new Household tax in Ireland 18:53 Tue 27 Mar by Andrew 0 comments

Saturday's National Rally against the Household Tax in the National Stadium was literally filled to overflowing. As well as nearly 3,000 people crammed into every possible space in the Stadium another 4 to 500 were in the car park at the side, unable to fit into the building. And the thousands who attended were angry, energized and expectant of victory. The National Stadium normally hosts boxing marches but the atmosphere on Saturday topped that of watching a home fighter coming out on top in a close fought bout.

textDublin: The eviction of the Occupy Dame Street camp 21:19 Thu 08 Mar by Andrew Flood 0 comments

A large force of Garda and council workers were deployed at 3.30am today, International Women's Day, to clear Occupy Dame Street (ODS) camp. The camp was completely demolished in the course of the eviction, campers intimidated and their personal property stolen. This was a level of force way out of proportion with the numbers in the camp (about 15 people) and stands in contrast with the lack of resources put into investigating what happened at Anglo, the collapse of which has left a debt of 26,000 Euro on every single person in the country.   [Italiano]

textDetailed account of Shell's prosecution of 19 more people for ongoing resistance in Erris, Ireland 21:14 Thu 08 Mar by anon 0 comments

The end of February saw 19 Shell to Sea campaigners, including a WSM member, being prosecuted on 80 charges for civil disobediance against Shell's decade long attempt to impose an experimental high pressure raw gas pipeline on the communities of Erris.  Over 8,000 euro in fines were handed down by this special sitting of the Belmullet court and Shell to Sea spokesperson Terence Conway was given two 3-month prison sentences under section 8 of the Public Order Act for blocking the road on two seperate occasions, a 'crime' that anyone following the struggle will be aware Shell's private security company committs three times a day with the co-operation of the Gardai. (Image: Community show support in advance of the court cases, J Bender, RSC)

textReport from 40th anniversary of Bloody Sunday March 17:56 Thu 02 Feb by Sean Matthews & Sean Dubh 0 comments

Despite the opposition of the governing SInn Fein party, relatives of families of the victims of Bloody Sunday and political supporters, including Irish anarchists, marched in remembrance last Saturday. A report from the anarchists present and a background to the issues behind those determined to continue the annual commemoration. [Italiano]

householdtax.jpg imageThe Household Tax: Don’t Register, Don’t Pay 23:30 Fri 27 Jan by ? 0 comments

Mid-December saw the eventual publication of the long-threatened household tax legislation. The first three months of 2012 will present every household in Ireland with a choice: whether to succumb to this new home tax, which along with the proposed water tax will rise to approx €1,200 per annum within a couple of years, or to refuse to register, refuse to pay and make a stand against the costs of bailing out bankers and developers continuing to be hoisted on our shoulders.

more >>

imageWhy it’s right to resist the Government Nov 13 by Joe Conlon 0 comments

“The law is essentially the weapon of the privileged, it is made by them for the purpose of enshrining their power and the people need to dismantle it entirely if they want to be genuinely free” – Errico Malatesta

imageHomeless Direct action Sep 15 by Joe Conlon 0 comments

A housing direct action is took place this morning at the Dublin City Council (DCC) office in Bunratty Civic Centre, Coolock in Dublin. Mother’s and their children who are in need of housing occupied the offices in order to force the council to answer their questions. In particular they want to know why many people are discovering there isn’t even emergency accommodation available.

imageAsylum seeker, homeless - We Rebel! We support decent housing for all! Sep 02 by Tom Murray 0 comments

Last week, three children under the age of six slept rough in Dublin city centre while their parents stayed awake to watch over them. As of August 2015, this family is but one of 620 families in Ireland, including more than 1,300 children, who are homeless. The root of the current crisis of housing is the current crisis of capitalism.

imageThe reality of homelessness, the fight for decent housing and lessons from The Bolt hostel Aug 27 by Joe Conlon 0 comments

Over the Last 12 months, particularly since Christmas the housing and homeless problem has deepened significantly. From last summer the amounts of families’ registering as homeless went from 264 to now, which are 531. The number of families that are registered as being in need of emergency accommodation is 792 adults with 1,112 dependent children. These statics were issued by the Dublin Regional Homeless Executive. This is a 100% rise within 12 months, but yet the state has not come out and said there is a crisis in housing.

imageWe are winning the water war Aug 21 by Brian Ancom 0 comments

Our upcoming show of strength in Dublin on August 29th is going to be an absolutely huge gathering of people from all over the island to deliver a wholehearted 'No' to the Fine Gael/Labour government's plans to establish water charges. [Italiano]

more >>

imageStatement from the Barricade inn squatted anarchist social centre Oct 29 0 comments

On Wednesday The Barricade Inn Collective received court summons papers informing us that the following day (Thursday 22nd October) the estate holders of the building would be seeking an injunction against us. Court was adjourned and the case will be back in court next Wednesday (28th October).

imageWhy we are leaving Campaign Against Home and Water Taxes (CAHWT) Jun 26 WSM 0 comments

The Workers Solidarity Movement has decided to withdraw from the Campaign Against Home and Water Taxes. Please see statement below. We have made a donation of €1,000 towards paying off the debts of CAHWT.

textScotland's for Council Housing! Glasgow Demo, 24th September Sep 18 Liberty and Solidarity & IWW 0 comments

With the full backing of the Glasgow chapter of Liberty and Solidarity and local community newspaper 'The Burgh Angel' , Hamiltonhill Action Group will be holding a demonstration with the Scottish Tenants Organisation on Thursday 24th September, against the Glasgow Housing Association's (GHA) refusal to invest money in their community.

imageThe Libertarian - issue 2 Aug 28 WSM 5 comments

The second issue of 'The Libertarian' a local newsletter distributed in Dublin 8 by the WSM is online.

© 2005-2015 Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]