user preferences

New Events

Ireland / Britain

no event posted in the last week

Paedophilia: the Church in Ireland staunches the flow of refugees from Roman Catholicism...

category ireland / britain | religion | opinion / analysis author Wednesday March 09, 2011 23:55author by Francesca Palazzi Arduini Report this post to the editors

Archdiocese of Dublin impeding formal defections from the Roman Catholic Church

In October 2010, the Irish website Count Me Out, which had until then supplied the forms needed to carry out formal Defection from the Roman Catholic Church, suspended distribution of the forms and its own activity as a result of a statement from the Catholic Church in Ireland regarding the acceptance of defection requests. But was the Archdiocese of Dublin being truthful when it issued its statement? Italian anti-clericalist activist Francesca Palazzi Arduini examines the changes in which led to the Church's statement.

countmeout.jpg


Paedophilia: the Church in Ireland staunches the flow of refugees from Roman Catholicism... through even more silence


In October 2010, the Irish website Count Me Out, which had until then supplied the forms needed to carry out formal Defection from the Roman Catholic Church (“actus formalis defectionis ab Ecclesia Catholica”), suspended distribution of the forms and its own activity as a result of a statement from the Catholic Church in Ireland regarding the acceptance of defection requests.

Count Me Out had accumulated a large following thanks to the indignation which arose on foot of the many cases of paedophilia (531,000 emails to the site and thousands of forms completed) which had come to public attention after being denounced following years of silence by the Irish Church and the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

The act of defection, according to the Roman Catholic Church itself, should be considered a total renunciation of the sacraments and is intended to bring about a “breaking of the bonds of ecclesiastical communion”. It is comparable to the Italian practice of the sbattezzo, or de-baptizing, first promoted by the Associazione per lo Sbattezzo and later by the Unione degli atei e degli agnostici razionalisti (UAAR – Union of Rationalist Atheists and Agnostics). It is not, thus, a mere “justification” for the non-payment of a religious tax, but a “true act of apostasy”, one for which canon law provides grave consequences (including excommunication) and which, more concretely, and if clearly communicated in writing to the ecclesiastic authorities, allows an official note of the defection to be recorded in the baptismal register, as prescribed by the General Decree of the Italian Episcopal Conference of 30 October 1999 providing “Dispositions for the protection of the right to a good name and to privacy” (1). This Decree recognized for the first time the right to obtain the correction of data contained in baptismal registers, although a decision by the civil courts in Padua in 2000 allows for such data not to be cancelled. Naturally, these pronouncements were actively sought by the de-baptizing movement and as part of a legal case taken by a member of the UAAR in Italy in 1999 with the recently-established Italian Commissioner for Data Protection (2).

So why this sudden decision on the part of the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland to evade defection requests, albeit perhaps only temporarily? In 2010, the provisions of the motu proprioOmnium in mentem” (3), which had been under study by Vatican canon law experts for some time, came into effect. It made changes to three articles of the Code of Canon Law regarding the possibility of defecting from the Church. The three articles, however, affect solely the institution of marriage. After lengthy consultations, references to formal defection were removed by reasons of the “expediency of not having in these cases different treatment from that given to civil unions of baptized persons who make no formal act of abandonment; the need to demonstrate with coherence the identity of “marriage and sacrament”; the risk of encouraging clandestine marriages; further repercussions in countries where Church Marriages have civil effects, and soforth” (4).

The Pontifical Council also explains that the change concerns “the domain of matrimony” in connection with the obligations of baptized persons not to marry non-baptized or non-Roman Catholic persons, and by way of confirmation cites the process of consultations during which, indeed, it was thought necessary to issue a Letter to clarify the modalities of defection, in recognition of the sheer number of requests, since “In the meantime, the suppression of that phrase concering the canon discipline of Marriage has been linked with a completely different question, which however required suitable clarification, and concerned exclusively certain central European countries: it concerned the effect on the Church in cases where a Catholic made a declaration to the civil authorities that he did not belong to the Catholic Church and, consequently, was not required to pay the so-called tax for religion”.

Hence the issuing of the Letter which the Pontifical Council cites: “In this precise connection and, thus, regarding areas other than that strictly concerning matrimony referred to which the above-mentioned phrase in the three canons of the Code referred to, a study was begun by the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts in collaboration with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in order to clarify what the essential requisites for manifesting one's will to defect from the Catholic Church are. Such conditions of effect were indicated in the Circular to the Presidents of Episcopal Conferences” (5) which the Pontifical Council issued on 13 March 2006 and which there is thus no reason to consider no longer valid as it was written during the same process which led to “Omnium in mentem” and deals with the possibility of abjuring, something which has by now been confirmed.

The Catholic Church in Ireland has instead declared (and has not yet rectified in any way) that: “...it will no longer be possible to formally defect from the Catholic Church. This will not alter the fact that many people can defect from the Church, and continue to do so, albeit not through a formal process. This is a change that will affect the Church throughout the world. The Archdiocese of Dublin plans to maintain a register to note the expressed desire of those who wish to defect. Details will be communicated to those involved in the process when they are finalised” (6).

It would appear, then, that there is an attempt at hand to stall on requests of defection (not for matrimonial purposes, but for reasons of conscience) which continue to be made, without due consideration for the above-mentioned explanations provided by the Pontifical Council, which have been publicly available for some time on the Vatican website. And this is causing perplexity and frustration among people wishing to defect.

More silence, more clouding of issues in Ireland? It is time for the Catholic Church to stop this exploitation of “Omnium in mentem” in its attempt to put a halt to the exodus of its members.

Francesca Palazzi Arduini
http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Associazione_per_lo_Sbattezzo
http://www.anarca-bolo.ch/a-rivista/356/dossier_anticlericale.htm

Translation by Nestor McNab (FdCA)


Notes:
1. Disposizioni per la tutela del diritto alla buona fama e alla riservatezza, available online at http://www.chiesacattolica.it/pls/cci_new_v3/cciv4_doc.redir_doc?id_doc=4163&id_ufficio=10&id_allegato=1175&url_rimando=/cci_new/documenti_cei/1999-11/24-18/not10_99.doc
2. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali. http://www.garanteprivacy.it/
3. Dated 26 October 2009. The title is translatable as “To everbody's attention”. Links to the Latin original and Engish translation on the Vatican's website are available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnium_In_Mentem
4. Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts, 15 December 2009. In Italian at http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/intrptxt/documents/rc_pc_intrptxt_doc_20091215_omnium-in-mentem_it.html
5. In English at http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/intrptxt/documents/rc_pc_intrptxt_doc_20060313_actus-formalis_en.html
6. Archdiocese of Dublin, “Statement on Formal Defections”, 12/10/10. Online at http://www.dublindiocese.ie/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2103&Itemid=373

Related Link: http://www.fdca.it
This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch
Issue #3 of the Newsletter of the Tokologo African Anarchist Collective

Front page

Elementos da Conjuntura Eleitoral 2014

The experiment of West Kurdistan (Syrian Kurdistan) has proved that people can make changes

[Chile] EL FTEM promueve una serie de “jornadas de debate sindical”

Ukraine: Interview with a Donetsk anarchist

The present confrontation between the Zionist settler colonialist project in Palestine and the indigenous working people

Prisões e mais criminalização marcam o final da Copa do Mundo no Brasil

An Anarchist Response to a Trotskyist Attack: Review of “An Introduction to Marxism and Anarchism” by Alan Woods (2011)

هەڵوێستی سەربەخۆی جەماوەر لە نێوان داعش و &

Contra a Copa e a Repressão: Somente a Luta e Organização!

Nota Pública de soldariedade e denúncia

Üzüntümüz Öfkemizin Tohumudur

Uruguay, ante la represión y el abuso policial

To vote or not to vote: Should it be a question?

Mayday: Building A New Workers Movement

Anarchist and international solidarity against Russian State repression

Argentina: Atentado y Amenazas contra militantes sociales de la FOB en Rosario, Santa Fe

Réponses anarchistes à la crise écologique

50 оттенков коричневого

A verdadeira face da violência!

The Battle for Burgos

Face à l’antisémitisme, pour l’autodéfense

Reflexiones en torno a los libertarios en Chile y la participación electoral

Mandela, the ANC and the 1994 Breakthrough: Anarchist / syndicalist reflections

Melissa Sepúlveda "Uno de los desafíos más importantes es mostrarnos como una alternativa real"

Ireland / Britain | Religion | en

Mon 22 Sep, 08:10

browse text browse image

Sorry, no stories matched your search, maybe try again with different settings.

imageCardinal Sins to cover up in Catholic Church- an instrument of control and domination May 18 by Sean Matthews 0 comments

The media frenzy may have settled for now over Cardinal Sean Brady’s failure to pass on information about a notorious clerical sex abuser in his midst but we need to make sure we don’t let this extremely wealthy multi-national chiefdom called the Catholic Church off the hook.

textWhy are priests still running schools in Ireland? Dec 06 by Cover Story 0 comments

The report by the inquiry into child sexual abuse by pervert priests in the Ferns diocese has at last exposed the suffering endured by huge numbers of people in Ireland. Priests were able to get away with their rape and abuse of children because the state abdicated its responsibility to protect children

imageThe Orange Order: An enemy of all workers Jul 13 by Andrew 0 comments

Last night saw the all too familar conflict in Northern Ireland between loyalist and nationalist workers over Orange Order parades. The reality of the Orange Order is that it is a counter-revolutionary institution set up and maintained to target not just Catholics but also 'disloyal' Protestants.

Sorry, no press releases matched your search, maybe try again with different settings.
© 2005-2014 Anarkismo.net. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Anarkismo.net. [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]