user preferences

Irish and foreign workers must stand firmly together

category ireland / britain | migration / racism | opinion / analysis author Wednesday October 05, 2005 22:00author by James O Brien - WSM (personal capacity) Report this post to the editors

Workers have different interests to the bosses. It is in the workers' interests to have a more pleasant working environment, more money to spend on our families, and more leisure time to enjoy it all. We can't have all this while slaving to increase the bosses' profits. And workers of all nationalities, from the factory hands to the teachers, from street-cleaners to domestic workers have these basic interests in common.

Metro Eireann, a newspaper largely written by and aimed at immigrants in Ireland, pubished the article (written by a WSM member) below. It is distrbuted in Dublin at least, and maybe around the country.

Solidarity is strength:
Irish and foreign workers must stand firmly together

The scandal concerning Gama, the Turkish construction company,which paid its workers as little as a ¤2.20 per hour, showed a nationwide audience just how vulnerable immigrant workers are. The current policy whereby work permits are issued to employers rather than workers ensures that the employer has a stick to beat any worker who stands up for her rights.

New legislation on the work permit system is still to be debated in the Dailm and until this new system is put into practice, it remains unclear if it will significantly reduce exploitation.

However, exploitation is not confined to non-EU workers on permits. With large numbers of Poles, Lithuanians and other workers from the former Soviet bloc coming here, there is the prospect of a "race to the bottom" as employers force workers into competion with each other.

Despite the occasional nationalist rhetoric of Irish bosses they are much more comfortable with their foreign counterparts than with the local bus driver who's a bit too enthusiastic about the trade union.

Bosses, be they Irish and foreign, have common interests. It is in a bosses'interest that workers work harder, longer, for less pay and less benefits. This is because they will increase their profits.

Capitalists know this. It is why they have associations such as IBEC and allies like Fianna Fail and the Labour Party. It is why you will have Turkish bosses xploiting both Turkish and Irish workers and Irish bosses exploiting both Turkish and Irish workers.

Workers have different interests to the bosses. It is in the workers' interests to have a more pleasant working environment, more money to spend on our families, and more leisure time to enjoy it all. We can't have all this while slaving to increase the bosses' profits. And workers of all nationalities, from the factory hands to the teachers, from street-cleaners to domestic workers have these basic interests in common.

So there is a natural opposition between bosses and workers.

When it suits them, bosses can be quite international. They'll employ any nationality as long as they can squeeze more profit out of them. But they can also play one nationality off another. Politicians will use immigrants as an excuse why there isn't enough money to adequately fund the health services or why dearly won working conditions are threatened.

It is important, and in our interest, that Irish working people see through this propaganda. It is in our own interest because if we allow bosses to play, for example, the Poles against Irish on the building sites then both sets of workers will find their working conditions being reduced as they will effectively be undercutting each other.

The obvious solution is for both sets of workers to come together, to jointly demand decent working conditions. If they do so, it is very hard to see what the bosses can do. You won't find too many Construction executives mixing mortar, laying blocks, and sticking sewage pipes together.They are utterly dependent on the workers.

If the workers' demands aren't met, and their labour withdrawn, the bosses' profits will disappear. Of course it's never easy to organise a militant campaign, and serious preparation would have to be done to give it a fair chance of success.

But the point is that nothing is being done at the moment. Indeed Ray Halpin, a SIPTU official, was on national radio (the Matt Cooper show) at the end of August lamenting the fact that due to the strength of the employers nothing could be done about the competion between Irish and immigrant labour on the building sites. He's wrong, as the history of the labour movement, including his own trade union, shows.

A start can be made by:

a) Recruiting members to unions

b) Encouraging activity in the unions.

c) The officials of the unions need to stop thinking they are in another NGO where taking subscriptions and producing policy documents are enough. If they are unwilling to facilitate direct action by members they should step aside and get a job with Oxfam.

d) Organising a militant, self-managed campaign with concrete goals, which includes the willingness to strike. This can unite workers from every country, not just because they'll feel an outpouring of brotherly love, but because it is in their interests to unite.

The old trade union slogan is as relevant as ever: Agitate, Educate,Organise!

This is an elementary approach to improving our daily lives. It's what got us our basic freedoms and perks, such as the eight hour day, holidays, sick pay and social insurance a few decades ago.

But more is possible. The labour, both manual and intellectual, of working people is the what makes all that is valuable in the world. And so there isn't any decent reason why a parasitical employer should cream off hundreds of millions while the workers around the world are left with crumbs.

Thanks to the centuries of endeavour of our ancestors, of all countries, we are born into a society with electricity, transport, science, and a fascinating variety of cultures. Modern society is advanced enough so that all can live quality lives to one's taste.

It is disgusting that a tiny minority, such as Ireland's Michael O'Leary and America's Donald Rumsfeld, get to swagger around in mansions, and actively prevent the achievement of a fair society, not least by forcing explotiative working conditions - he gets millions, workers get peanuts - or, as in Iraq, by savagely destroying people's homes in order to rob their natural resources.

As well as winning small gains in the present, workers need to develop a vision of a future society where there isn't any exploitation at all.

Given technological development, it is possible for everybody on the planet to have a high standard of living.

With the intelligence and good will that most of us see in our friends and family, it is possible to organise society so that everybody can have an input into decisions that affect them. In other words, meaningful democracy in the workplace and the neighbourhood. This means organising without any bosses making decisions over our heads. Once bosses get a foothold, they accumulate power and develop different interests from the rest of the population.

Sections of the workers' movement, particularly the anarchists, have articulated this vision of self-management over the decades. For those interested in pursing these ideas, it is a tradition well worth exploring…

For more information see

James O'Brien

This page can be viewed in
English Italiano Deutsch

Front page

Cajamarca, Tolima: consulta popular y disputa por el territorio

Statement on the Schmidt Case and Proposed Commission of Inquiry

Aodhan Ó Ríordáin: Playing The Big Man in America

Nós anarquistas saudamos o 8 de março: dia internacional de luta e resistência das mulheres!

Özgürlüğümüz Mücadelemizdedir

IWD 2017: Celebrating a new revolution

Solidarité avec Théo et toutes les victimes des violences policières ! Non à la loi « Sécurité Publique » !

Solidaridad y Defensa de las Comunidades Frente al Avance del Paramilitarismo en el Cauca

A Conservative Threat Offers New Opportunities for Working Class Feminism

De las colectivizaciones al 15M: 80 años de lucha por la autogestión en España

False hope, broken promises: Obama’s belligerent legacy

Primer encuentro feminista Solidaridad – Federación Comunista Libertaria

Devrimci Anarşist Tutsak Umut Fırat Süvarioğulları Açlık Grevinin 39 Gününde

The Fall of Aleppo

Italia - Ricostruire opposizione sociale organizzata dal basso. Costruire un progetto collettivo per l’alternativa libertaria.

Recordando a César Roa, luchador de la caña

Prison Sentence to Managing Editor of Anarchist Meydan Newspaper in Turkey

Liberación de la Uma Kiwe, autonomía y territorio: una mirada libertaria para la comprensión de la lucha nasa

Misunderstanding syndicalism

American Anarchist and Wobbly killed by Turkey while fighting ISIS in Rojava

Devlet Tecavüzdür

Attaque fasciste sur la Croix Rousse et contre la librairie libertaire la Plume Noire

Red November, Black November – An Anarchist Response to the Election

Resistance at Standing Rock

Ireland / Britain | Migration / racism | en

Thu 30 Mar, 18:44

browse text browse image

textWSM remove racist slogans in Cabra, Dublin 18:52 Mon 18 Dec by Alan MacSimoin 0 comments

Local members of the WSM have removed racist slogans which had been painted along the canal.

AY Banner at Afghan hunger strike imageImmigration and Racism in Ireland 20:39 Tue 10 Oct by J. Carax 0 comments

In the last fifteen to twenty years, two new phenomena have finally reached Ireland –Immigration and alongside it - Racism. This is not to say that we Irish never had our prejudices before the ‘blacks’ arrived, back then we were quite happy directing our bigotry and ignorance towards travellers, gays, Jews and Protestants.

afghanbanner.jpg imageAfghan Asylum Seekers occupy St Patricks Cathedral in Dublin 23:14 Thu 18 May by Joe 0 comments

There is a growing crisis in Ireland with the hospitalisation of around 8 of the 41 Afghan Hunger strikers who occupied St Patricks Cathedral on Sunday last. WSM members have been taking part in solidarity vigils and other support work for the 41 Afghan hunger strikers . We support their demand to be allowed to stay in Ireland and we will be taking part in demonstrations and other events over the new few days in support of that demand.

textLabour party leader Pat Rabbitte turns on migrant workers 18:38 Wed 05 Apr by WS 0 comments

The exploitation of migrant workers who are often paid illegally low wages has hit the Irish news many times in recent months. Labour party leader Pat Rabbitte reacted to this explotation by suggesting further controls should be place on migrant workers!

Front of the GNIB (from by 'Freak') imageArrests at attempt to block deportations in Dublin 22:31 Thu 20 Oct by Joe 1 comments

Two people were arrested in Dublin on Tuesday as Residents against Racism activists attempted to block the deportation of 39 people (including fourteen children, 5 of whom were born in Ireland) to Lagos. Nigeria. This account is from Emma a WSM member and RAR activist who was arrested.

textMan Deported Because Of Garda Brutality Cover up 16:41 Wed 10 Aug by Dermot Sreenan & James O'Brien 0 comments

In the early hours of May 19th Michael Alabi was deported by the Irish State. Michael was resident of a hostel in Lower Gardiner street and was part of a group of Nigerian men who decided to go on hunger strike to protest against the department of Justice's draconian immigration policies.

textIrish union branch Opposes Tactics Of Deportation Cops 21:41 Tue 09 Aug by Gregor Kerr 0 comments

The Dublin City North Branch of the INTO has passed a motion endorsing the call by outgoing union president, Austin Corcoran, that all schools become safe places for all children -to be given the status of embassies. It is hoped that more branches within the union will take up this issue and that by next year's annual congress a campaign will be launched in the union to make this a reality

textDeported to be Mutilated? 00:57 Sun 03 Jul by Emma WS-83 0 comments

The Irish government is currently trying to deport women and children under the threat of Female Genital Mutilation (FGM), which frequently results in death. Asylum in Ireland can be sought on grounds of religious or political persecution. However the government refuse to acknowlege FGM as a political act and therefore women and children cannot apply for asylum on the basis they have suffered or will suffer FGM if deported.

textSolidarity Action for the political seekers Bahoz & Temiz 06:02 Sat 25 Jun by ΟRA MIDEN 0 comments

Solidarity Action with the political asylum seekers Bahoz and Temiz, Friday, 24/06/2005 6pm outside the Greek Consulate, 50 Gogarloch Syke, Edinburgh, EH12 9JB Kurdish Asylum Seeker on Hunger Strike in Greece – close to death.

image100 years after 1916 will the Irish state recognising Traveller ethnicity Nov 04 by Dermot Freeman 0 comments

2016 is fast approaching and we will be subjected to endless documentaries about that start of our bloody history as a nation. It will also be a time for analysis of how far we’ve come since the proclamation of this Republic.

In the proclamation there are lines which are aspirational, but grounded in the reality of experience of the rebels.
“The Republic guarantees religious and civil liberty, equal rights and equal opportunities to all its citizens, and declares its resolve to pursue the happiness and prosperity of the whole nation and of all its parts, cherishing all of the children of the nation equally, and oblivious of the differences carefully fostered by an alien Government, which have divided a minority from the majority in the past.”

imageTravellers’ struggles are our struggles too: decent housing for all! Oct 14 by Tom Murray 0 comments

Last weekend, ten people died in a fire at a halting site in South Dublin. Thomas Connors, Sylvia Connors, Willie Lynch, Tara Gilbert, and Jimmy Lynch and five children lost lives. Their deaths are a tragedy, and we mourn their loss. But we are also angry. Because we know the loss of their lives was not the outcome of chance or blind fate. Our society, its laws and its institutions are designed to marginalise, to penalise and to discriminate against Travellers (traditionally itinerant ethnic group) . So long as we accept these forms of oppression and exploitation, tragedy will follow tragedy.

imageA critical view of the Refugees are Welcome Rally in Dublin Sep 16 by Dermot Freeman 0 comments

The Refugees Welcome rally saw a good crowd assembled at the Spire in Dublin. The rally was a response where people wanted to express their solidarity with the refugees who are attempting to escape war and death.

imageMarch in support of refugees in Dublin Sep 15 by Dermo 0 comments

Thanks to the work of a few volunteers we had some banners to bring to the Refugees are Welcome rally and march at the Spire on Saturday the 12th of September. I was on my bike into the Barricade Inn to pick up the banners. The banners were important to link up certain struggles. One linked the appalling reaction to the social housing crisis by this government with their slow reaction to the humanitarian crisis on the edges of fortress Europe, which simply stated Homes for All, Refuge for All, and another which read No Borders No Nations. There was a good crowd assembled there when we arrived at the Spire and it grew steadily as Memet Uludag spoke frequently, often, and introduced each of the speakers. The rally was a response where people wanted to express their solidarity with the refugees who are attempting to escape war and death.

imageCéad Míle Fáilte*? Racial Profiling in the Ireland Oct 24 by José Antonio Gutiérrez D. 1 comments

Over the last couple of days we have witnessed massive media hysteria about the case of Maria, a young girl supposedly abducted by a Roma couple in Greece. DNA tests and Lombroso-style racial profiling have come into action in a case that has stirred the irrational anxiety that feeds racism and bigotry. Beyond the fact that child abduction is a serious issue, the "whiteness" and "blondeness" of the alleged victim have been emphasised together with the "Roma" condition of the alleged culprits. Let us remember that this is taking place in Greece, a country where blatant racism (as expressed by Golden Dawn) is on the rise, so there are good reasons to be cautious about this whole case.

more >>

textWSM remove racist slogans in Cabra, Dublin Dec 18 WSM - Jack White branch 0 comments

Local members of the WSM have removed racist slogans which had been painted along the canal.

© 2005-2017 Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by [ Disclaimer | Privacy ]